Mafia TBT Mafia III: The Murder Before Christmas [Game Over/Town Win]

I've read through the posts and i think that vd is a better lynch canidate then Kippla, if he turns up something different then i'm probably voting for Karla tomarrow

Are you seriously going to vote for Karla?

Instead of just voting for someone who was possibly wrong, step up your act and speak up. If you're just going to complain to Karla, you should do something helpful for a change.
 
Are you seriously going to vote for Karla?

Instead of just voting for someone who was possibly wrong, step up your act and speak up. If you're just going to complain to Karla, you should do something helpful for a change.
I'm thinking about the logic here and Karla could easily fake-claim a sent pm like iloveyou did to beary last game

- - - Post Merge - - -

And yes, i do now think that VD is mafia
 
I'm thinking about the logic here and Karla could easily fake-claim a sent pm like iloveyou did to beary last game

- - - Post Merge - - -

And yes, i do now think that VD is mafia

I was so mad last game because nobody believed that I didn't send that bodyguard PM D:
Anyways, so much evidence is stacked up against VD, that it only makes sense to vote for him at this point. I WILL refrain from voting for him in case some good evidence zones up after I go to bed.

- - - Post Merge - - -

Dolby. Why is your title, I drive the bus?
Are you a bus driver?!
 
I'm thinking about the logic here and Karla could easily fake-claim a sent pm like iloveyou did to beary last game

- - - Post Merge - - -

And yes, i do now think that VD is mafia

If the VD PMs were fake and not real, VD could have disputed that in his defense. He did not. He actually provided more PMs.
 
I was so mad last game because nobody believed that I didn't send that bodyguard PM D:
Anyways, so much evidence is stacked up against VD, that it only makes sense to vote for him at this point. I WILL refrain from voting for him in case some good evidence zones up after I go to bed.

- - - Post Merge - - -

Dolby. Why is your title, I drive the bus?
Are you a bus driver?!

I think we should lynch Karla if VD isn't mafia, unlike last game.

FOOL, WHY DIDN'T YOU PM ME ABOUT IT, THEY'LL KNOW NOW. I'll probably be more of a burden to the town though. Most likely switching mafia and paramedics when the detective rolechecks the medic.
 
So that's what you REALLY meant by "self protection" and that I wouldn't understand =P (Honestly having your role in your User Title was stupid.)
You said the exact same thing about "being a burden" to me as well. Do you really think you'd mess up?
 
I think we should lynch Karla if VD isn't mafia, unlike last game.

FOOL, WHY DIDN'T YOU PM ME ABOUT IT, THEY'LL KNOW NOW. I'll probably be more of a burden to the town though. Most likely switching mafia and paramedics when the detective rolechecks the medic.

Last game, the mafia mayor sacrificed Hikari to try gain trust.
 
So that's what you REALLY meant by "self protection" and that I wouldn't understand =P (Honestly having your role in your User Title was stupid.)
You said the exact same thing about "being a burden" to me as well. Do you really think you'd mess up?

Yes, probably on night 5, 6, or 7
 
I think we should lynch Karla if VD isn't mafia, unlike last game.

FOOL, WHY DIDN'T YOU PM ME ABOUT IT, THEY'LL KNOW NOW. I'll probably be more of a burden to the town though. Most likely switching mafia and paramedics when the detective rolechecks the medic.


It was a wild guess. Wait..
If you really are ten bus driver, then I highly advise making some sort of master plan to switch people around to the towns advantage.
Or maybe that's a stupid idea and nobody cares. I think it's cool though. :p
 
There's no way I'd be able to dig up unmentioned evidence on why I have suspicions against VillagerDweller. Karla's PM conversation definitely holding the most weight against him. He just seems a bit to sketchy and 'on edge'. Why would he tell Karla that he should save it later on in the game when there are fewer players, but then want it used on him for the following night phase? You do have three to spare which is plenty speaking that the previous game only used one(if my memory serves correctly). I would really like to know why he was so confident in knowing he'd make it threw night one.

I'm pretty set on VillageDweller, but I need to get something else out on the table before I forget about it and then for it to get swept under the rug, since I'm going to bed and work another long early morning shift. Someone I've had suspicions on from the start.
Anybody else remember how against Kuma was to vote for Karla in the election?
Karla, I don't feel like voting for you because you're desperate for protection. Could that possibly mean that you may perhaps be someone we want dead?
A few hours later she says
See Karla, you have set your expectations up way too high! You're expecting us to trust you right away when it's only been 24 hours! Really, the only person I would vote for at the moment is Harry (VillageDweller). He seems to be the better candidate.
That was stated one hour before VD made his campaign speech. But why didn't Kuma ever question about VD's claim about wanting protection? He also said he was killed early in both games(night one and two, which she obviously knows playing both the previous games). Wouldn't that make you believe VD would be someone you wanted dead as well? Although, the way Kuma is playing has not been different in this game than the previous she did pretty much role claim to being a townie for the third time:
The 'evidence' that we have against Kippla is just outright ridiculous. I strongly believe that she is townie. Honestly, I can relate. Being the same role twice or thrice is actually very annoying. It doesn't really push us out of our comfort zones when we are the same role more than once.
which makes me want to believe she is saying that just because she's known to lurk more than being a contributing poster(at least for the second game, the first game she was active but eventually got modkilled)- it might just be her own way of blending in. Kuma, if you truly are a townie for the third time, I understand that you'd feel uninterested and unmotivated to play. But you signed up for this, if this is your third time playing you should know by now you need to help out your side. A townie may not be an important role, but it's still a role.

I'm hoping my post made some sense since I'm half asleep :/
 
Actually, Trundle and I were talking about Dolby's bus driver title. Trundle said Dolby denied everything. To me, 200 bells is a waste for a title that doesn't mean anything.
 
It was a wild guess. Wait..
If you really are ten bus driver, then I highly advise making some sort of master plan to switch people around to the towns advantage.
Or maybe that's a stupid idea and nobody cares. I think it's cool though. :p
What's the point in making an idea if you think it's stupid? Be confident in your ideas and don't expect that it will be perfect. This was your failing point last game; you weren't confident enough to truly defend yourself and you basically just gave up when everyone's votes were on you.
 
Actually, Trundle and I were talking about Dolby's bus driver title. Trundle said Dolby denied everything. To me, 200 bells is a waste for a title that doesn't mean anything.

Actually, i got it for free from settings
 
What's the point in making an idea if you think it's stupid? Be confident in your ideas and don't expect that it will be perfect. This was your failing point last game; you weren't confident enough to truly defend yourself and you basically just gave up when everyone's votes were on you.

Thank you for telling me. I didn't relize I sounded so deflated.
I'm half asleep, excuse me.
I think that using a bus driver to our advantage might help us, but could burden us as well.
We can never be sure if Dolby is a bus driver, until he dies.
Lets keep out eyes peeled and keep asking questions.

- - - Post Merge - - -

Oh, we're going back to Kumafia now?

I suppose. We need to investigate the people who are hiding in the shadows and hoping to not be noticed.
I am short on time, so I apcant spend an hour digging up evidence against everybody, but everyone can pitch in.
 
Thank you for telling me. I didn't relize I sounded so deflated.
I'm half asleep, excuse me.
I think that using a bus driver to our advantage might help us, but could burden us as well.
We can never be sure if Dolby is a bus driver, until he dies.
Lets keep out eyes peeled and keep asking questions.

- - - Post Merge - - -



I suppose. We need to investigate the people who are hiding in the shadows and hoping to not be noticed.
I am short on time, so I apcant spend an hour digging up evidence against everybody, but everyone can pitch in.
Thank you for explaining why :)
~~~~
I do agree that if we use the Bus Driver correctly (have you roleclaimed to Karla, Dolby?) with the right clues in mind, we can actually perform a switch precisely.
 
Thank you for explaining why :)
~~~~
I do agree that if we use the Bus Driver correctly (have you roleclaimed to Karla, Dolby?) with the right clues in mind, we can actually perform a switch precisely.

Woo, I'm being useful! :D

On the worse side of things...I'm going to start digging um some evidence. I may be gone for about half an hour, so don't think I'm lurking :p

- - - Post Merge - - -

Ahem.
I have not come up with anything suspicious...
But certain people need a reminder PMing. Like Bowserfangirl?
Or all those other people with less then 10 posts??
 
I'll be sending out a group PM to all people who need to post. If they don't come, let them be modkilled. It's their fault.

- - - Post Merge - - -

Alright, I sent it to in-actives. Note that I didn't send it to low posters that contribute occasionally. I sent it to: Bowserfangurl, PikaSweet, SlaughterShy, and Kuma.
 
Back
Top