• Guest, you're invited to help build our new TBT time capsule! It contains three parts, with some of its elements planned to open in 2029 and others not until the distant future of 2034. Get started in 2024 Community Time Capsule: Blueprints.

Mafia TBT Mafia V: There and Back Again [Game Over/Town Win]

Not quite. Even though I haven't posted recently I'm still very suspicious of beary509 but I'm not ready to make a case at the moment. If I do, it will likely be Day 3.
Also, I am supporting the Blu Rose lynch today, so I'm going to put my vote in on the that. I, as well, have suspicions of Blu Rose, and from what I've seen, Blu Rose has been searching around for blue roles (blu rolses lel) all game. Not even their roles, just whether or not they're blue. Doesn't this scream mafia to you? What else would he need it for? He's not trying to bring up any other conversation in these cases, just whether or not they're blue.

I'm also going to vote for Blu Rose to be lynched due to her lying to me about being in cahoots with Beary, and when it comes to Beary, I'm still suspicious. Right now it looks that either one or both of them are mafia.
 
Well I guess You just put another nail in the coffin. Catching a slip up.
Trundle also makes a good point. I think any town aligned person would want to know said blue role and use it to Town's advantage.
 
Yes, it might rid you of an apparent distraction.

Wait wait wait.

But you saw how big of a distraction I was on Day One right? I practically took over the thread the entire Day. If you are a Town role you need to fight to keep yourself alive. Wasting a lynch on a Town player hurts us more than anything.
 
You can call it whatever you want.

@Kayla: Yes, I remember. Do you want me to fight? I'm more than willing...

Yes, we need to get as much information out of you in case you really are Town and avoid lynching you if possible.

Did anyone contact you about me or Trundle? If so, what did you say? What did they ask you?

- - - Post Merge - - -

Are you speaking with anyone besides Beary509?
 
Just adding to the Blu Rose case, here.
Blu Rose, where are all your posts that analyze what people said that you did the last two games? Why are they suddenly missing? You were doing really good at catching things in people's posts, so there's no reason to stop now. I'm going to post PMs I got from Blu Rose. I just wanted to state that I am townie but my brother PMed beary509 last night that I was a Detective. Blu Rose messaged me soon after asking if I was a Detective, as you'll see below. Then she lies about not talking to beary509. Why would she be lying? Why does anyone lie? To hide something.
PM Conversation said:
Blu Rose 1: By any chance, are you a Detective?

Just wondering...

Lastly, do not share if you think I am a person not to be trusted. This would help me get to know where ai am on everyone's helpfulness scale.

Trundle 1: Why would you be asking me this?

Blu Rose 2: Ugh, sorry for responding so late, my wi-fi went crazy last night...

I'm just asking you as I'm wondering.

Again, feel free to not say anything in regards to this.

Trundle 2: I'm sure you'd love to know. You obviously are in cahoots with beary509 because beary is the only person who knew I was Detective.

Blu Rose 3: What makes you say that?
I'm not working with Beary, but it might be time to start...

Trundle 3: What made you think I was a Detective?

Blu Rose 4: A lot of things...
Which will not be disclosed, other than the fact that You (user) told me.

Trundle 4: "A lot of things..."
Nice. It's quite obvious you're scum at this point. "You" only messaged beary509 that I was a DT last night, and even if he did tell you, he didn't last night, when you originally messaged me.

Blu Rose 5: Okay.
Whatever.

Blu Rose 6: I just want to tell you five my personal suspicions, before I die Townie:

Prin
Jeremy
TheCreeperHugz
Lunatic

I'm pretty sure that these four are the last Mafioso.

So, once I die Townie, my efforts will not go to waste.
 
This is just completely a theory, but what if River was lying about being Dwarf as well? Lauren shone the spotlight on River, and Lauren was killed at night. Was it by mafia? I'm pretty damn sure it was. Could it have been River who killed Lauren, because she called River out about roleclaiming two completely different roles? I don't know, and as I mentioned earlier, this is just a theory. Since River "fake roleclaimed" as Serial Killer, why didn't mafia kill her just to be sure? Because River could possibly be scum!

Lauren's death was my fault. I am working with a vigilante, we compiled a list of names we thought suspicious and we eventually settled on Lauren because she was being dodgy plus we considered her death being the safest of them all. Not a particularly strong player nor very active, essentially getting another lurker out. Obviously, we choose poorly.

There are ways to confirm Tom's alignment, such as inspecting him tonight. With the Godfather out of the way, it'll be the best way to do things. We do not have to rely on deaths to confirm roles.

Much like you claimed, it'd be a waste to inspect me. I know a bunch of blue roles by sheer dumb luck (really, the vig contacted me and I found others by accident), so if I was scum there would have been a blue blood bath last night.

Just another note. We keep linking everyones death together. Karla died cuz he's strong, Lauren died cuz she called someone out. But what about Tinaa? We haven't linked anything to Tinaa's death at all.

I believe Tina died because she would most likely catch onto Karla and he knew that, thus singling her out. Honestly if Karla hadn't died last night I would have been bringing his name up, practically all three mafia hits scream his doing.

I don't know why this hasn't been brought up, but I was told Lauren's death was caused by a vig. I bet the vig who shot her was a 2-shot vig, thus not wanting to reveal themself, so I guess I'll be the one to bring this information to the thread.

Was going to bring that information to the thread earlier, but I didn't have the time. This is correct, the vig I am working with is a 2-shot.

Wait, so you're saying mafia missed two shots last night???

Don't act to surprised friend.
 
Yes, we need to get as much information out of you in case you really are Town and avoid lynching you if possible.

Did anyone contact you about me or Trundle? If so, what did you say? What did they ask you?

- - - Post Merge - - -

Are you speaking with anyone besides Beary509?

Okay, I have a suspicion list, which I shared with six people, you (Kayla) and beary being two of them.

Prin
Jeremy
TheCreeperHugz
Lunatic

I'm not even going to bother presenting evidence. Y'all know where I stand on TCH, Prin, and Lunatic, and I gave Beary's suspicions list to her, as, if you remember right, she said she got them from a person.

Here, I'll even get the PM:
beary509 said:
Blu Rose said:
Nick is SK.
I'm betting all of my money I have right now on this fact.

Prin, Lunatic, TheCreeperHugz, and Jeremy are Mafia.

I'm prettysure about the first three, but Jer is a fleeting suspicion.

LETS DO THIS.
*cracks knuckles*
Can you explain why you suspect each of the, besides Jeremy?

Oh, and, I did not respond, as I said so in the main thread.
 
I'm not even going to bother presenting evidence.

Why not? No one else is highly suspicious of anyone else on there. If you're really town then you should probably give us some reason as to why you suspect them, otherwise, you will die for no reason.
 
Blu Rose sent me that last PM too stating they were a Townie + their suspicion list. I really don't want this lynch to be wasted on a Townie.

Unfortunately a lot of the blue role hunting that Blu Rose is doing happened through PMs last night and somehow Me + Trundle were targeted by the Mafia. These are specific hits that align greatly with the people Blu Rose chose to approach. Which is why we need to know who you spoke to about us? It could be that you told a potential Mafia player and that they chose to target us to frame you since this happened through PMs.
 
Okay, I have a suspicion list, which I shared with six people, you (Kayla) and beary being two of them.

Prin
Jeremy
TheCreeperHugz
Lunatic

You also shared this with "You" (the user) and I, just a few minutes ago, so what was the point of that if you were just going to post it publicly anyways?
 
The fact that you PM Beary509 to say you think Nick (Superpenguin) is SK is also very interesting.
 
Just adding to the Blu Rose case, here.
Blu Rose, where are all your posts that analyze what people said that you did the last two games? Why are they suddenly missing? You were doing really good at catching things in people's posts, so there's no reason to stop now. I'm going to post PMs I got from Blu Rose. I just wanted to state that I am townie but my brother PMed beary509 last night that I was a Detective. Blu Rose messaged me soon after asking if I was a Detective, as you'll see below. Then she lies about not talking to beary509. Why would she be lying? Why does anyone lie? To hide something.

Oh my God, I'm just burnt out after the ACTs.
I was really good at catching things in people's post, as it was much easier to think.
I've been preoccupied with many things lately, whereas I wasn't the last two games.
Of course I lie. Everyone in this game does. SP lied to hide the whole story. I lie because it is a necessity in this game, and I have done so in every oher game.
When Waffles was lynched, two games ago, I had gone back into Game II, and hid the rest of the evidence that could have proved Waffles innocent, as I was so darn sure she was Mafia, that I needed her to appear as scummy as possible.

Which is why we need to know who you spoke to about us?

I have only talked to Beary, and the five others I revealed my suspicions list to this whole game.

@Trundle: I was not planning on posting it publicly. I said six people, also.

Here, I'll even try ripping people's posts apart... Even though it is very time-consuming...

Here I go!
 
Oh my God, I'm just burnt out after the ACTs.
I was really good at catching things in people's post, as it was much easier to think.
I've been preoccupied with many things lately, whereas I wasn't the last two games.
Of course I lie. Everyone in this game does. SP lied to hide the whole story. I lie because it is a necessity in this game, and I have done so in every oher game.
When Waffles was lynched, two games ago, I had gone back into Game II, and hid the rest of the evidence that could have proved Waffles innocent, as I was so darn sure she was Mafia, that I needed her to appear as scummy as possible.



I have only talked to Beary, and the five others I revealed my suspicions list to this whole game.

@Trundle: I was not planning on posting it publicly. I said six people, also.

Here, I'll even try ripping people's posts apart... Even though it is very time-consuming...

Here I go!

But what is the point in lying to the confirmed town if you don't want to get lynched? You're best bet to stay alive would be to talk to them.
 
I have only talked to Beary, and the five others I revealed my suspicions list to this whole game.

@Trundle: I was not planning on posting it publicly. I said six people, also.

Here, I'll even try ripping people's posts apart... Even though it is very time-consuming...

Here I go!

So those people you PM'ed Trundle and Kayla were actually in contact with you? Can you please say what you were discussing with each of them?

Don't bother ripping apart posts at this point. Your main goal right now is to avoid getting lynched and getting all that you know out to town if you can't avoid it.
 
Can someone summarize the whole Blu Rose thing? I missed the first part and have been lost since.
 
Back
Top