Dolby is fairly quiet both as a town and a scum player, admittedly. But more so as scum. People get edgy about him every game though because he's a strong asset to any mafia team despite being a complete nuisance as a town player (sorry honey, you know ILY really <3).
I'd been thinking about this as well. But iLoveYou knew for certain she had been caught out - and by the one confirmed town member. She knew it was over. It could mean anything: especially as they had lost LittleBeary so fast too. I definitely think her focus on wanting to get rid of players early who just "slide by" means that they are at least active players, regardless of skill.
☆ This is probably one of the more interesting first days we've had in a long while.
But being seemingly uninterested doesn't mean your town. In fact, the one game I was seriously disinterested in I was the godfather. I think that role just comes with a dose of apathy or something, because I know I'm not the only person who has felt that way after receiving that role. ☆ If you're town, then fudging act like it and help us find scum. A defeatist attitude is not going to get us anywhere. I'd rather lynch scum than get a bored player out of the game. I know two scum in one day seems to alleviate the challenge and mystery a little, especially as we didn't even have to use our brains to get rid of them, but on Day 2 the usual excitement of the game should be back full force.
Gandalf said:
Those two names had already come to my attention since iLoveYou flipped red. But the question is did Karla adjust the roles or not? He didn't in Cell Mafia so it could just be random again this time. So far, Tom and Justin aren't playing too differently from usual - as far as Day 1 goes anyway. I think we're just under the illusion they're being inactive because we've found scum unusually fast this game. Plus, of course, there was a huge amount of spam in the first eight hours too. I definitely think they're people we should keep an eye on, but so far their playstyle isn't drastically out of the ordinary for them.
Syd said:More to add to this:
Personally, when I joined Mafia I thought since Justin is a admin/mod/whatever he is like almighty and can't be Mafia. Hopefully no other newbies thought this? If they did time to realize it's not true. Justin can be in Mafia, and isn't gonna be Harry Potter unless Karla says so.
Hahaha. Staff have the same chances of rolling a scum role as everyone else in the game.
