I have checked his profile I think he is making a post I guess we have to wait.
I'm fine with any of those people.
I'm going to throw a crazy idea, and I hope people are with me - but could we maybe try and get through a game WITHOUT role claiming en masse? It's almost always town's downfall. Scum always happens to get a copy of the list somehow. I don't know about others, but it irritates the heck out of me because it's almost always why I die. I trust one person and they pass it on to the bad guys.
It'd be nice to see if we can play a game on skill rather than mass role claiming. I'm not saying that role claiming to one or two people (after you've have enough time gauge their alignment) is bad - but when one person is in a position where they know the role of every other player in the game it's dangerous. Even confirmed town players often end up passing that list onto scum before they die.
Gonna agree with this in Mafia II we got in trouble because of role claiming to Kayla and Jubs, in HP theme the town team were about to lose because of rc and Karen (well its true sorry).
New members: Alice, Miss Dandere and sn0wxyuki.
Alice isn't new; she's just changed her username. She used to be Sway.
- - - Post Merge - - -
Also, for the uninformed:
GopherManSupreme = formerly Trundle.
alise = formerly makkine.
Well, we need to start talking about the lynch now. And I'd like to bring up the players who I think are inactive and lurkers: Alise, Waffles, and of course we always have the annoying player option of Cory.
Waffles and Cory are clearly both scum just pretending to hate each other so that we won't suspect them working together. So obvious.
@ SuperPenguin - You are absolutely right. The day will only be 24 hours long so it's important we get some ideas rolling. I feel like you oldschool veterans know better which people are the most active and helpful, and which aren't. Personally I WOTC'd Cory because I felt that his behaviour in the previous game (where he did get WOTC'd!) was very unsportsmanlike since he kept on posting after his death a few times. But I guess there was not enough votes.
The only thing about you that sets you apart from Alise is that you actually talk and can perform your action if you have one. Alise was a Doctor before and she never even bothered using her action. We all know Day One lynch involves the risk of lynching a blue, but with Alise, she is always useless with actions.
Last game, Dolby was lynched first, due to his inactivity throughout games, are we going to go on that route?
Lol what about you? Says the person who keeps posting one-liner and most of your post are useless no offense. If you want to help then you should try your best and not being a jerk in game
- - - Post Merge - - -
Ahhh been ninja'ed
In relation to people lurking? I open tabs up so I leave windows on my phone open and I forget to leave a thread. But in relation to my last post, we can't just focus on the people that barely contribute and what not. When the game starts and we have information we can pick out those who the majority think is mafia. I should have mentioned that instead of how I said it. Obviously it's not the easiest thing to do when it's day 1
Agreed, it's what I do on my phone when I'm at work. Clean an aisle, check the thread. Clean another two aisles or so, check the thread.
Agreed, it's what I do on my phone when I'm at work. Clean an aisle, check the thread. Clean another two aisles or so, check the thread.
I always give people a few hours or so for a chance to check in and/or defend themselves, otherwise I'm okay with this.Last game, Dolby was lynched first, due to his inactivity throughout games, are we going to go on that route?
Well, there's not much to make a case of right now. But I will once I see enough to make a case out of. There's one person in particular that I want to make a case of.
stg if you say waffles
Well, there's not much to make a case of right now. But I will once I see enough to make a case out of. There's one person in particular that I want to make a case of.
Checking in!
For the most part, I'm agreeing with everything that has been said so far (especially what Tina said about role claiming from personal experience) but I think the wrong names are being thrown out.
Here are some names I'd like to bring up/would be okay with lynching.
-MissNoodle
-Dolby
-Cory
-ITookYourWaffles
I'd prefer to lynch MissNoodle because she just lurks around and does pretty much nothing. I think the two names that have been brought up the most, Cory + ITookYourWaffles, will be easy to catch as scum. Cory slips up easily and Waffles surrendered so that's that for those two. And I honestly don't know what to think about Dolby after the day 1 mislynch last game, but I do believe he should be kept on close radar as he is good as scum.
Agreed! Because I agreed can I have cake?
Yeah there's the life-is-busy excuse which I totally understand (since I'm also busy with AP exams this week) but if you're not going to make the time for mafia, don't join.