• Guest, can you feel the love in the air? Valentine's Week at The Bell Tree has begun with a new mini-event featuring four activities to enjoy -- new and returning collectibles are up for grabs! Dive in to the love here.

Mafia Pleasure Cruise Mini Mafia VIII [Game Over/Mafia Win]

Well since Purpl is gone, wouldn't it be our best bet to go after the person almost ALL of those people were suspecting... AKA Blu Rose?

It would be the safe vote. I'm not really sure what is style of play is and/or if it's different, etc.
 
Now, Tina says I fail to make decent defenses. But what the heck am I supposed to be defending myself against?
The fact that I get on, read posts, and post about it later? What's so wrong with that? I usually hardly have any time every time I get on the computer in order to make a decent post, so I just wait until later.
Oh wait, I'm sorry, I'm just too full of excuses to do anything.

Because the votes are probably going to lean my way, so I'll just throw it out now; I'm a blue role.

The game's theme makes me seem like a 30-or-40-year-old man, the Unregistered Sex Offender, or Voyeur.

I can see what was done to one person each night, but do not know who did it.

YES, I DO KNOW THAT THIS WILL PROBABLY PUT ME UNDER EVEN MORE SUSPICION, AND I DON'T CARE. I WANT TO MAKE MY THOUGHTS KNOWN WHETHER ANYONE THINKS I AM MAFIA OR NOT, AND, IF I'M LYNCHED, I WILL GO KNOWING THAT I HELPED TOWN.
I ALSO REALIZE THAT THE MAFIA HAVE A LIST OF SAFE CLAIMS
(at least, I think they do?).


So, I can tell you all that Lauren was the unaccounted for KP, but what strikes me as weird is that he was also roleblocked. Vig-hunting, Mafia? Obviously, he was also protected.

Now, what strikes me as odd is that absolutely nothing happened to SP last Night.
Would last Night not have been an ideal time to kill him? After all, he is probably going to turn out to be a big threat for Mafia--if he isn't Mafia himself?

So, SP, how are you today?

Yes, only because you keep enforcing the idea that you wouldn't

Remind anyone of anything?

Now, I'd like to bring up a theory here. What if both Ashtot and Alice were scum? While it does seem ludicrous, hear me out: To me, it actually seems like Alice was giving up because everything was going according to plan, and I would actually not be surprised if Alice were cheering in /obs after Day 1's lynch. She wasn't that helpful of a Mafia role, only being able to absorb blues which Mafia are assumedly trying to snipe out anyways. In the long run, her role would not have been that useful anyways.

Well, here we are. I'd like to point out this part in particular...
SuperPenguin said:
Also, you haven't been that big of a contributor to conversation lately/ In a game without PMs, it is kind of expected for players who use PMs a lot to communicate will have much more to discuss within the thread/
You haven't been talking a lot yourself either, and, trust me, I know I haven't either. I usually didn't use PMs, but when I do, I'm a blue role, or, in other words, Vigilante in Tina's Pirate Mini Mafia. In fact, I've discussed a lot less without PMs, as most of you have noted, due to the fact that, well, I can't rely on PMs to speak privately with people whom I think are town. Encryption would be as hard as **** to try and make it seem a legitimate, related post anyways (besides, we aren't supposed to try).

Yes, I know that this is most likely flawed. I'm just sharing my thoughts and opinions on what is happening.

Okay, just need to wonder something here for a second.
Where is your helping us? All you've done so far is nail one Mafioso based off of hardly existing evidence, and, in fact, when no one else suspected her, or, if they did, did not show it.

But, the main reason I'm making this post is due to the fact that I suspect SP, and also want to get my thoughts out before I die. I also want to point out that I am, in fact, a Voyeur, and believe that my role can be used to provide an asset to us Town.

Now, if you'll excuse me, my head is murdering me.

*dies from migraine*
 
Roleclaims = We all have so in the past.

But in this type of setup? That's much too risky.

- - - Post Merge - - -

I think Blu's post is pretty convincing and it would be too much of a risk to lynch him at this point.

- - - Post Merge - - -

Jersey Shore Guido (1-Shot Gladiator)

Btw, this is the actual name of my role if any of you were wondering.
 
Would Olive and Alise please explain why they voted for Blu Rose with absolutely no reasoning whatsoever? Especially you, Olive. Even after Rose put out a long and thoughtful post, you still place your vote on him. Why?

Seems pretty scummy tbh.
 
Would Olive and Alise please explain why they voted for Blu Rose with absolutely no reasoning whatsoever? Especially you, Olive. Even after Rose put out a long and thoughtful post, you still place your vote on him. Why?

Seems pretty scummy tbh.

As oath said, I said something.

Also to Blu Rose, if you are telling the truth, and you're a blue role, I'll unvote you. I'm still reading your post, so I'll decide after I'm done. We don't want any more green / blue blood spilling. :(
 
I think Blu Rose may be telling the truth, but I'm not sure who to lynch if not him. So I'm going to have to read through a bunch of posts again and see if anything sticks out.
 
Now, I'd like to bring up a theory here. What if both Ashtot and Alice were scum? While it does seem ludicrous, hear me out: To me, it actually seems like Alice was giving up because everything was going according to plan, and I would actually not be surprised if Alice were cheering in /obs after Day 1's lynch. She wasn't that helpful of a Mafia role, only being able to absorb blues which Mafia are assumedly trying to snipe out anyways. In the long run, her role would not have been that useful anyways.

After reading your post, I have changed my opinions of you. I don't see you as scummy, however... I don't see how Ashtot could be scum. Yes, I know scum will vote fellow scummates to throw suspicion off themselves, but that early in the game? Alice was hardly on anyone's radar for being lynched. Now if people were considering her for lynching, I can understand why IF HE IS MAFIA, he would use that role of his. But to force people to choose between either of them, knowing that lynching either of them would result in a mafia getting lynched? I just don't see it. It's reckless. I'm fairly convinced Ashtot is town.

- - - Post Merge - - -

Would Olive and Alise please explain why they voted for Blu Rose with absolutely no reasoning whatsoever? Especially you, Olive. Even after Rose put out a long and thoughtful post, you still place your vote on him. Why?

Seems pretty scummy tbh.

I agree, I'd like to hear Olive explain why she voted. Unless I missed it, she didn't post any reasoning at all.
 
uhh Blu rose. Why couldn't you have made that defence two days ago? I was all for having you lynched or shot by a vig yet you stayed quiet saving it all up. Im not going to to totally change my opinion on you now but credit is due for bringing forward some actual suspicions. You've made yourself a pretty big mafia target so i'm still going to be keeping an eye on you if you pull through night after night unscathed.

And then this post. Everyone else was discussing how, if anything, Ash using his role early only made him look less suspicious. However, you were trying to get suspicion back onto him here.

And then yeah, the fact that easy targets are actually still dying continues to point fingers at you. Even more so now that stronger players died last night making it seem as an attempt to cover it up.

- - - Post Merge - - -

Plus, you didn't vote until the end on Alice which by that time her fate was sealed. However, you had no troubles hopping on early for the PurplPanda lynch.

This part seems really misinformed to me. oath2order wasn't the only one who thought Ashtot was stupid for using his action early on. Looking back, it seems you were the only one saying it made him look less suspicious. Also I think the campaign you have made here is a bit too opinionated or personal to be taken seriously. Not as smooth talking as you were on day 1 defending Ashtot's move that's for sure.

I wouldn't look too much into Olive's vote at the moment, can't say whether she has had the chance to read up on the thread yet or not.
 
After reading your post, I have changed my opinions of you. I don't see you as scummy, however... I don't see how Ashtot could be scum. Yes, I know scum will vote fellow scummates to throw suspicion off themselves, but that early in the game? Alice was hardly on anyone's radar for being lynched. Now if people were considering her for lynching, I can understand why IF HE IS MAFIA, he would use that role of his. But to force people to choose between either of them, knowing that lynching either of them would result in a mafia getting lynched? I just don't see it. It's reckless. I'm fairly convinced Ashtot is town.

It was more just a ludicrous theory; highly doubtful, but still possible.

uhh Blu rose. Why couldn't you have made that defence two days ago? I was all for having you lynched or shot by a vig yet you stayed quiet saving it all up. Im not going to to totally change my opinion on you now but credit is due for bringing forward some actual suspicions. You've made yourself a pretty big mafia target so i'm still going to be keeping an eye on you if you pull through night after night unscathed.
-snip-
I wouldn't look too much into Olive's vote at the moment, can't say whether she has had the chance to read up on the thread yet or not.
Y'know, I wanted more to bring to the table. In truth, I was actually going to wait one more day, and see all that happened.

I actually second that Olive's vote shouldn't be looked into too much, because, well, she also explained it here (shown below), and my last post in no way was supposed to put me in the clear of suspicion. No one should blame her if, after reading that, she still has suspicions on me.

One thing I would like to point out, though, is that with all of the attention on purpl, trundle, gandalf, (and even oath a little earlier on), it would seem as though blue rose has, once again, gone off radar...

I still hold strong suspicion (based on evidences in an earlier post I made) to blue rose.

I am also now stating that gandalf lies on the fence in my eyes. I know he is being made topic of interest along with a few others now, but all I really have to go on is that the only posts he really makes are those of strong opinion when it comes to blaming someone else.

I think Blu Rose may be telling the truth, but I'm not sure who to lynch if not him. So I'm going to have to read through a bunch of posts again and see if anything sticks out.

I'd actually suggest all of you do this...
 
After looking through the post filters of the people that have died so far (except for Alice, of course), I've noticed one thing.

Everyone who has died so far has had absolutely no suspicions worth really mentioning, or their suspicious people were dead.

Some of them did have suspicions on me, however.

Just thought it would be worth pointing out.
 
After looking through the post filters of the people that have died so far (except for Alice, of course), I've noticed one thing.

Everyone who has died so far has had absolutely no suspicions worth really mentioning, or their suspicious people were dead.

Some of them did have suspicions on me, however.

Just thought it would be worth pointing out.

So, do you think the mafia want to kill off the weaker players? Or the ones that were quiet, didn't really have suspicous. I'm probably targeted, as I am aware I'm a weaker player, if thats their plan.

- - - Post Merge - - -

*suspicions.
 
So, do you think the mafia want to kill off the weaker players? Or the ones that were quiet, didn't really have suspicous. I'm probably targeted, as I am aware I'm a weaker player, if thats their plan.

- - - Post Merge - - -

*suspicions.

That doesn't sound like a logical strategy for mafia to use.
 
So, do you think the mafia want to kill off the weaker players? Or the ones that were quiet, didn't really have suspicous. I'm probably targeted, as I am aware I'm a weaker player, if thats their plan.

- - - Post Merge - - -

*suspicions.

No; I think they are killing off the people that have no suspicions so that no lead can happen based off of deaths. We can't communicate through PMs, and they either...
1.) Aren't posting, or...
2.) Are posting but being extremely careful not to leave traces.

For this reason, and I know it is not that reasonable, so I really hate suggesting it, I think that we should lynch an inactive for today.

Either one of them or SP.
 
No; I think they are killing off the people that have no suspicions so that no lead can happen based off of deaths. We can't communicate through PMs, and they either...
1.) Aren't posting, or...
2.) Are posting but being extremely careful not to leave traces.

For this reason, and I know it is not that reasonable, so I really hate suggesting it, I think that we should lynch an inactive for today.

Either one of them or SP.

I don't think they're targeting weaker players, as a few strong players have been picked off already.

I agree with Blu, but I wouldn't just suddenly decide to lynch Superpenguin.
 
Back
Top