Replies:
Honestly I feel like we're better of lynching Karen or Alise because Alise isn't really doing anything and neither is Karen.
Well my opinion is that we should lynch an inactive. I don't think the risk of lynching an active Town player is worth it.
I think we have four options right now:
Karen - Seem extremely lazy and disinterested. Isn't making a real effort to contribute.
Here?s the larger posts I had made before you posted that:
I'm in class right now but I will post later, Lauren has been posting weirdly imo from my experience with playing with her. When I was mafia and she was town she was a lot less aggressive, instead sitting back a bit more and making interesting posts every so often. That was a while back though and I don't know if her playstyle has changed or something but I will be keeping an eye on her.
And people probably skipped this one:
Just caught up...sort of confused by this factional kill thing. Do we have to wait for Tina for a definition before someone can explain how this related to the current situation?
@above posts I think we should ignore Sataric and his Kallie theory, it's probably not of any use for today's lynch plus he did say that it would reveal in time.
-------
Current Thoughts
So, I *may* have skimmed over a few pages just because I've been a bit short on time, but here are a few things I did notice over the course of things:
>how quickly people jumped off the oath/Sataric suspicion train
^Don't just agree with what other people say (cough C r y s t a l)
>If you have a suspicion, STICK TO IT unless some other evidence comes up. This obviously means that you're just jumping around trying to blend in.
>the confusion caused by Sataric about the Kallie thing
^surely if it was that important, he would have shared the information immediately
>which leads me to believe that the two pages of "wtf is going on" "wtf am i dumb" was a distraction caused by Sataric for some reason
>People who only post to give facts (cough Alice cough)
>People who have been disappeared (earth to Jello, Cariad, and alise!)
>The many "cases" put forward on the FIRST day
^I don't think I've ever played a game where day one had this many suspicions! I don't know if it's just me but I find this strange.
>It's almost as if these cases are either extremely flimsy, or people are trying to "be active" by posting crap to make themselves seem town-aligned.
>Arguments over nothing.
^This is just distracting. People play how they play. Sure, their posts may be lame/useless but you don't need to spam pages to rectify that.
I hope this makes sense. There's a few more but I have to go to class now.
Well then. I know it may not be as much as what I used to post, or it may seem little compared some other people (mostly spam, arguments, nonsense making them seem ?active?), but I should be contributing way more when the weekend comes around.
Karen - She doesn't seem quite up to date with how Mafia has "changed" since she left, and called me out quite harshly for my "fluff posts". I know I use more words than necessary sometimes but I try my best to contribute. I was hoping we had moved beyond this. Can't get a good read on her at all.
Please enlighten me on how mafia has changed since I last played. And yes, your posts still annoy me like crazy but I?ll let your wording slide for now as it seems you have some information you are still withholding from us (which, everyone is still waiting for). And sorry if I was too harsh.
?????
Current Thoughts:
WTF ARE YOU ALL DOING.
I literally read through 20 pages of crap, the same thing repeated over and over again which I can pretty much sum up like so:
Yui scum cuz her role name Mark
Karla vs Jeremy rawr rawr rawr
Oh look SP bandwagon train ok cool let me hitch a ride and hide here hehehehe
Hey you look scummy but WAIT you do too oh and you nvm let me switch votes 10000 times
Y u not posting u scum then hahahhaha
Wat Kallie thing i wanna know why have wait
Ryan scum o but he town role blocker he town then but actually idk
Can you guys actually do something productive instead of going around in circles like blind mice? Theres a few of you who are actually doing something (mentally noted), and others who have contributed BS but are staying up in the ?active contributor? category simply because of post count.
The SP lynch wouldn't have happened if you guys hadn?t spent pages complaining about each others play styles. It wouldn?t have happened if you had actually read through the thread and absorbed the information from a non biased point of view. I really really hope that tomorrow this crap will be replaced with some quality posts.
???
I'm just trying to be nicer because if I start being a bit mean I'll become really mean and get modkilled.
I don?t think you?re that bad though?you being nice, like others have said, is extremely strange and will only serve to distract us. Play like your normal self and if you do get too mean I?m sure someone will be around to make sure it doesn't go too far.
Maybe I worded things poorly but I meant responding to this:
As well as a few other things. Which it took you many many hours to reply to, giving you plenty of time to figure out good and clever things to say! But we cannot be online 24/7, I completely understand that, and as I said I do believe you for now. You must admit, however, that if no other thieves/mermaids would ever make an appearance as the days go by then you'd be looking incredibly scummy.
Wasn?t Natty at work or something which is why she couldn?t respond? And also, Sataric, looking at your summary just because a player doesn?t seem to care doesn?t mean that they?re mafia or third party. For all I could know one of these super spammy or extremely ?pro town? posters we have could be scum.
??
I have several current suspicions, but I?m going to need a few more posts from them and some time to look through the thread again since I?ve just been skimming?my head hurts reading through all those repetitive one liners. I will call out on one right now though ? Ashtot.
No, I?m not suspicious of you (well, maybe a bit). I?m extremely curious why you?ve been acting like you are now. You switched votes 2 times I think? And all you?ve been doing is pointing fingers and following other people. You?ve made so many tiny posts everywhere that when people think of active contributors you name automatically pops up just because you?ve made so many (useless) posts. I will admit though, Post 832 was pretty good compared to all your other ones and I hope you keep that up.
You know, at least I'm questioning people unlike you, who can't seem to make up their mind and honestly looks pretty damn scummy.
Isn?t that a bit contradictory since you can?t make your mind up either? You and Oath both have been posting around the same I think so stop your little quarrel unless one of you has some actual arguments to make.
If someone makes an actual good case on somebody I'm obviously not going to discredit it. I don't see how responding to you makes me look more scummy. I find you pretty hilarious. Who knows, maybe this will turn out like Kingmaker?
We don?t talk about that game.
??
