Since
Sataric's PM said the player he chose to curse would die
instantaneously when they spoke the word he had chosen, I don't see why people are saying 'he must be the only day killer/only third party!'. This suggests that the cursed player would die like a death from a gun given by a gunsmith in a separate post, not by the end of the day. Most games of this size have more than one third party, that is not uncommon at all. Have a look through
Sataric's posts again. He asked
Karla about playstyles for people as town or scum multiple times. That clearly says to me that he cursed
Karla and wanted him to say town as the four letter word, as
Karla did mention the word scum in Day 1, but he never said town. Not once did he question
Minties in any way like this, it simply doesn't match up with what he needed to do with his role. Both
Trundle and
Sumemr have disregarded this and are saying Sataric definitely killed
Minties, and that there won't be any other day killers. This is very strange and somewhat suspicious if they bothered to do some research into
Sataric's Day 1 posts, knowing he would be baiting someone. Based on this I believe there is still a daykiller in play. If anyone can argue against that, please do, but I don't see it after this analysis at all.
I have mentioned before that I am definitely wary of
Karla. However, now that many people have voted to lynch him and some of those players also come off as scummy, I am having second thoughts.
Karla also finds
Campy scummy which I definitely agree with.
I know for a fact that
Sataric was talking to
Campy and implied strongly that he suspected her. (And yes, before anyone is like 'how do you trust what
Sataric said was right he was third party lol!!!', I knew he was third party in the first place. I spoke to him in a skype call because I knew there was something off about him, and I got that info out of him. He told me he wanted to work with town. I said that was fine, but I would not hesitate to put him up for lynch if he stepped out of line in any way. Now I don't really have to worry about that since he's dead, but yeah.) Since he was clear about that, it's very possible she might have suggested him for a kill to her scum team if she couldn't deal with that pressure. The role
Campy claimed to
Sataric also doesn't add up to how she's playing. She is playing very poorly if that's her real role. She hasn't even posted in the past 24 hours - not really useful when we have 24 hour days and nights. Her posts don't add anything new to the table and she is generally just agreeing with others. This post kind of threw me off as well:
Female and yes, this is my first game.
Yep, I can understand you calling me out on this. I'm a huge lurker, I'll admit. As for your theory: It seems extremely unlikely to me, but even if it were true, it's not like it'll happen again since no one's going to be voting for
Cory anymore. He's already proven to be unlynchable, so there's no merit in trying again.
Personally, I'm still very wary of
Alise. You can keep saying you're never that active on day and night 1, but earlier today you spent well over half an hour arguing with
Feloreena when you could have used that time to actually contribute something.
And if there's one person who I feel is definitely town, it's
C r y s t a l, and mainly because of this quote:
Just the fact that she(?) wasn't entirely sure if she could get modkilled for posting that makes me think she's town. I don't think scum would ever take that risk.
Also, does anyone have any idea what kind of third party we're dealing with here? A serial killer? A cult? Could there be a third party role that can kill during the day?
As town you should be trying to get information from others since you are in the dark about roles, not just lurking and popping up when called out. Again, not really much contribution in the post - one player she's wary of and one she thinks is town. Well there were 19 players alive at that point, I'm sure a lot more could be said. Also how does one get modkilled for posting a wiki link? I thought that
Crystal was joking with that comment in the first place, so it seems weird to use as a 'strongest town read'. Then she completely switches the topic to third party. Night wasn't even over yet, so how could we even speculate that? It just felt like a random change of subject to get people off her back, with absolutely 0 substance.
There's also the fact that
Dolby is defending her which throws me off as well.
Campy's posts do not have solid contributions like he seems to say, especially compared to many other players, and she is certainly not an active player in this game.
Dolby has just been following any lynch target that's been brought up and being inactive otherwise. I just don't trust him at all, and his defense of
Campy makes him and her look even worse to me.
My vote will be going on
Campy today unless I can be persuaded otherwise - I will be busy this evening but I will check in whenever I can if possible.
- - - Post Merge - - -
Well she posted now, but it still doesn't change my thoughts in the post.
