Mafia DA:I Mafia

Gonna do my reads first, doing a color spectrum thing I did last game so its from green(Innocent) to red(Most scum)
Capella- Has only posted to say hi so... no read yet.
Labelle- Hasn't posted a lot so I don't have much to go on as of now.
Tom- Has really only posted to fool around, but i haven't seen any thing scummy yet.
Oath2Order- Same as tom, really has only posted to fool around, while a couple of gut feelings get me about him, i have no evidence so far.
Ashot- Yet again has been fooling around, but seems to have some important opinions I would like to hear.
SarsaKat- Questions a lot, similar to last game. If they're scum i wouldn't be too suprised though, but i just see it as townie questioning.
Ender- Eh, nothing scummy in particular I'm getting, but I wouldn't say your 100% innocent for me.
Dad- Basically the same as sarsa, kinda neutral opinion on both, but leaning more with Town.
Ahpo- Sometimes your posts are a little weird, but since it's your first game I just see it as a innonent mistake and I don't think you would be good at lying your first game.
Pusheen the Cat- Hasn't posted a lot, but what your opinions are really unclear and unsure. You seem to be very wishy washy but I don't have much evidence for now.
Runeraider- Has really only teased Trojan, but you have a couple of weird posts, but i'd like to see you post more and your reads on everyone.
Panda- You seem confused on a lot of stuff, but your opinion on the suspect isn't really clear and alot of your posts have .... which strikes me a bit odd.
Slammint you've only posted today but what you've posted seems really suspicious like
Not sure who is scummy but I will post a lot more now so do as much investigating as you want lol
Click to expand...
Okay you didn't get a good read yet you were willing to jump on the bandwagon to lynch me?
I'm on the bandwagon cause I need to sleep and stuff
Click to expand...
You can just wait off on voting or just say no lynch you know....kinda weird to me.
Dad seems scummy only cause he seems like he's pressuring everything on Daniel being scum
But I don't care I'm voting Daniel anyway lol
Click to expand...
But then you change your mind, you think Dad is scum yet you still wanted to vote on me? Seems more like your trying to play it safe if you ask me.
You know what I'm voting for dad cause he seems scummy that he is making Daniel look like scum, to me anyway

And I'm original
Click to expand...
Okay wayyyy to wishy washy on your vote, your either not reading or trying to look as innocent as possible.
All this stuff and more still rubs me the wrong way and your my #2 suspect.
Trojan- Has been acting really weird like this whole game, theres a bunch of evidence i don't like, but here's a few that strike me weird.
I'm hereeeeeeeeee!

@SarasaKat I think Daniel is chill, he likes me so I like him
Click to expand...
TO be honest here, I have no idea why you said this, i never really talked to you last game. And we were joking at the beginning so i assumed you were joking here(which is why i said what i said before) but it really strikes me odd now.
I don't like how hes going around pointing fingers at people. It makes me think taha the one pointing fingers is just doing it to make it seem that hes working for the town :p

And I don't know if Daniel is town but he hasn't said anything scummy so far so I just don't think he's mafia
Click to expand...
Dad was really only questioning like Sarsa and ender have, he realy hasn't been pointing fingers. Little weird to me.
I love Undertale Best game of 2015 ahead of Fallout 4![/QUOTE
Started getting off topic really quickly, but granted i did ask where the avatar was from, but before then people were asking you why you were suspicious of dad, but you were very eager to change the topic, maybe because you actually dont have a good reason why you were suspicious.
Your the main target bro. Stop leaching of ender
Click to expand...
That came out of no where, a very salty comment when i was just asking why i was being accused. You also voted for me without good reason so you are probably just hopping on the bandwagon to get a townie dead.
Click to expand...
Realllyyy suspicous if you ask me, i don't know why no one else picked up on this but yeah, my #1 suspect and who i'll probably be voting for.
But yeah that's all my reads for now. If anything seems weird or doesn't make sense, let me know.
Click to expand...
 
Are you serious Ashtot? Where did I say Pusheen was scummy? I just want to hear their thoughts and why they keep changing their vote. And they're not the only one - look back at my last big post where I listed all of the people I wanted to hear from. I've done nothing to convince anyone else that any of those people are scum. It just really irks me when people blatanly ignore those who quietly slide by.

Kat, I owe you an answer but I'm still at work. Will get back to you later.
 
In regards to Daniel, that's enough for me. I think you're innocent.

But you have really good points on trojan and slammint.
 
Call me Daniel said:
Gonna do my reads first, doing a color spectrum thing I did last game so its from green(Innocent) to red(Most scum)
Capella- Has only posted to say hi so... no read yet.
Labelle- Hasn't posted a lot so I don't have much to go on as of now.
Tom- Has really only posted to fool around, but i haven't seen any thing scummy yet.
Oath2Order- Same as tom, really has only posted to fool around, while a couple of gut feelings get me about him, i have no evidence so far.
Ashot- Yet again has been fooling around, but seems to have some important opinions I would like to hear.
SarsaKat- Questions a lot, similar to last game. If they're scum i wouldn't be too suprised though, but i just see it as townie questioning.
Ender- Eh, nothing scummy in particular I'm getting, but I wouldn't say your 100% innocent for me.
Dad- Basically the same as sarsa, kinda neutral opinion on both, but leaning more with Town.
Ahpo- Sometimes your posts are a little weird, but since it's your first game I just see it as a innonent mistake and I don't think you would be good at lying your first game.
Pusheen the Cat- Hasn't posted a lot, but what your opinions are really unclear and unsure. You seem to be very wishy washy but I don't have much evidence for now.
Runeraider- Has really only teased Trojan, but you have a couple of weird posts, but i'd like to see you post more and your reads on everyone.
Panda- You seem confused on a lot of stuff, but your opinion on the suspect isn't really clear and alot of your posts have .... which strikes me a bit odd.
Slammint you've only posted today but what you've posted seems really suspicious like
Okay you didn't get a good read yet you were willing to jump on the bandwagon to lynch me?

You can just wait off on voting or just say no lynch you know....kinda weird to me.

But then you change your mind, you think Dad is scum yet you still wanted to vote on me? Seems more like your trying to play it safe if you ask me.

Okay wayyyy to wishy washy on your vote, your either not reading or trying to look as innocent as possible.
All this stuff and more still rubs me the wrong way and your my #2 suspect.
Trojan- Has been acting really weird like this whole game, theres a bunch of evidence i don't like, but here's a few that strike me weird.
TO be honest here, I have no idea why you said this, i never really talked to you last game. And we were joking at the beginning so i assumed you were joking here(which is why i said what i said before) but it really strikes me odd now.

Dad was really only questioning like Sarsa and ender have, he realy hasn't been pointing fingers. Little weird to me.
I love Undertale Best game of 2015 ahead of Fallout 4![/QUOTE
Started getting off topic really quickly, but granted i did ask where the avatar was from, but before then people were asking you why you were suspicious of dad, but you were very eager to change the topic, maybe because you actually dont have a good reason why you were suspicious.

That came out of no where, a very salty comment when i was just asking why i was being accused. You also voted for me without good reason so you are probably just hopping on the bandwagon to get a townie dead.
Click to expand...
Realllyyy suspicous if you ask me, i don't know why no one else picked up on this but yeah, my #1 suspect and who i'll probably be voting for.
But yeah that's all my reads for now. If anything seems weird or doesn't make sense, let me know.
Click to expand...
Creating a case is only classified as annoying?
koopa

- - - Post Merge - - -

Right now I think that Slammint is just confused, but I thought that last game too and they were mafia there too so idk.
Click to expand...
 
Call me Daniel said:
Gonna do my reads first, doing a color spectrum thing I did last game so its from green(Innocent) to red(Most scum)
Capella- Has only posted to say hi so... no read yet.
Labelle- Hasn't posted a lot so I don't have much to go on as of now.
Tom- Has really only posted to fool around, but i haven't seen any thing scummy yet.
Oath2Order- Same as tom, really has only posted to fool around, while a couple of gut feelings get me about him, i have no evidence so far.
Ashot- Yet again has been fooling around, but seems to have some important opinions I would like to hear.
SarsaKat- Questions a lot, similar to last game. If they're scum i wouldn't be too suprised though, but i just see it as townie questioning.
Ender- Eh, nothing scummy in particular I'm getting, but I wouldn't say your 100% innocent for me.
Dad- Basically the same as sarsa, kinda neutral opinion on both, but leaning more with Town.
Ahpo- Sometimes your posts are a little weird, but since it's your first game I just see it as a innonent mistake and I don't think you would be good at lying your first game.
Pusheen the Cat- Hasn't posted a lot, but what your opinions are really unclear and unsure. You seem to be very wishy washy but I don't have much evidence for now.
Runeraider- Has really only teased Trojan, but you have a couple of weird posts, but i'd like to see you post more and your reads on everyone.
Panda- You seem confused on a lot of stuff, but your opinion on the suspect isn't really clear and alot of your posts have .... which strikes me a bit odd.
Slammint you've only posted today but what you've posted seems really suspicious like
Okay you didn't get a good read yet you were willing to jump on the bandwagon to lynch me?

You can just wait off on voting or just say no lynch you know....kinda weird to me.

But then you change your mind, you think Dad is scum yet you still wanted to vote on me? Seems more like your trying to play it safe if you ask me.

Okay wayyyy to wishy washy on your vote, your either not reading or trying to look as innocent as possible.
All this stuff and more still rubs me the wrong way and your my #2 suspect.
Trojan- Has been acting really weird like this whole game, theres a bunch of evidence i don't like, but here's a few that strike me weird.
TO be honest here, I have no idea why you said this, i never really talked to you last game. And we were joking at the beginning so i assumed you were joking here(which is why i said what i said before) but it really strikes me odd now.

Dad was really only questioning like Sarsa and ender have, he realy hasn't been pointing fingers. Little weird to me.
I love Undertale Best game of 2015 ahead of Fallout 4![/QUOTE
Started getting off topic really quickly, but granted i did ask where the avatar was from, but before then people were asking you why you were suspicious of dad, but you were very eager to change the topic, maybe because you actually dont have a good reason why you were suspicious.

That came out of no where, a very salty comment when i was just asking why i was being accused. You also voted for me without good reason so you are probably just hopping on the bandwagon to get a townie dead.
Click to expand...
Realllyyy suspicous if you ask me, i don't know why no one else picked up on this but yeah, my #1 suspect and who i'll probably be voting for.
But yeah that's all my reads for now. If anything seems weird or doesn't make sense, let me know.
Click to expand...
This. This is what I wanted from you - to prove me wrong, to prove you actually had an opinion. Hopefully I have time to read back again before the lynch...
Click to expand...
 
Alright, here's some food for thought, we all think it's trojan and he's probably getting lynched.
 
LaBelleFleur said:
Snip
This. This is what I wanted from you - to prove me wrong, to prove you actually had an opinion. Hopefully I have time to read back again before the lynch...
Click to expand...

yeah after my mind calmed down and cleared up, i basically reread the whole game and now I have a strong belief on the scum.
 
@panda you've been pretty confused most of the game, if you were to choose the 3 people your most suspicious of, who are they?
 
sorry my laptop froze and i have to restart... are you serious Daniel im sus to you cause i have a bad habit of typing "..." in my dialogue haha ok... i promise it doesn't mean anything.

- - - Post Merge - - -

had*
 
Can someone make a self-contained Daniel case please? I can't understand why they're scummy. I think that oath2ordermand someone else is still on them.
 
I have a wind storm incoming, and I'm not sure if it will turn the power off or not, so if I'm not online to post just know it's because of a storm. I'm still allowing day to end in about 3 hours though, but if I haven't posted just continue on until I come online.
 
Last edited:
Unvoted, starting to feel less sure about Daniel, although a part of me wouldn't be surprised if he is mafia because of how he decided on the easiest people to scumread: Trojan and Slammint. Trojan because that's who the votes are piling on and they've doubled back on things they've said. Slammint because he's playing and deciding to vote with very little logic, and I'm not just saying that to defend myself. Also I hate when people are close to getting lynched with little time left and they don't give all their reads until there's very little time left. It could be a last minute attempt at keeping enough heat off him to get someone else lynched.

I'm also less sure about Trojan and in reading into a lot of his posts, they seem to be coming from a place of nervousness. Yeah, he's revoked opinions and sheeped the Daniel vote, but honestly it's funny to see Daniel going at him for the hypocrisy of suspecting me because I was asking questions so early and then said the same thing he did about me when I asked who was the most suspicious so far. Both Trojan and Daniel have displayed nervousness, but what makes their nervousness different is the timing. Trojan was nervous from the beginning, but Daniel hasn't gotten nervous until votes started piling up on him.

Anyways, I'm somewhat rambling, but I don't think either Trojan or Daniel are mafia, a gut feeling in this moment.

It's those more experienced players utilizing the heat on Trojan and Daniel that I want to put a spotlight on: Enderwiggin and LaBelleFleur. I suspect that both of these players could possibly be attempting a mislynch out of the chaotic behavior of these players and I'm annoyed I was more or less the same as LaBelle a few hours ago, campaigning against Daniel. The thing these two share in common is that they both aired a very strong suspicion of their respective suspects (Trojan and Daniel) right off the bat, with their first posts of substance. I need to ISO and highlight their reasonings for wanting to lynch their votes, but the one that makes me feel more unsettled here is Enderwiggin. Need to start. Inb4 a million ninjas.

Also, I have my townreads but I am not airing them due to how that can be toyed with by the mafia team.

And good god do I want Capella gone, I already know she's going to just do nothing no matter what side she's on, but that's particularly troublesome if she's on the mafia team because people will just continue to null read her due to the fact that she's given nothing, meaning she's not as likely to be a lynch candidate than active players are, and given how justice is allowing people to miss votes for two days, that's around five days irl.
 
TheAhPo... if i had to choose three sus people at this very moment it would probably be Trojan, Daniel, and i don't know could be a few others... but really i don't see a whole lot to go off of still this is only my second game of mafia and i still don't know the small details to pic up on.
 
Runeraider said:
Can someone make a self-contained Daniel case please? I can't understand why they're scummy. I think that oath2ordermand someone else is still on them.
Click to expand...

Even though I think Daniel is innocent, I still have like 5% suspicions about him, there's no dirt on him now so I think he's innocent enough for me to take my vote elsewhere.
also rune, who are your top 3 sus' if you don't mind me asking?
 
if i absolutely had to choose a third right now it might be Slammint they are acting exactly like they did last game and they were mafia.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

N e s s
Mafia TBT Mafia - Darkest Dungeon (Cancelled)
Replies
15
Views
943
N e s s
N e s s
Damniel
Mafia Among Us Mafia Game Thread (Town Win!)
139 140 141
Replies
3K
Views
105K
unravel
unravel
C
Review the Video Game Above You!
Replies
11
Views
272
Midoriya
Midoriya
ILoveAnimalCrossing123
Bell Tree Forums Profile Inventory Item + TBT Bell Giveaway Contest Game (kinda but it is also kinda a game)
Replies
4
Views
211
-Blue-
-Blue-
E
Mafia The Quest for King - Mafia | Game Thread | GAME OVER
89 90 91
Replies
2K
Views
54K
Jacob4
Jacob4
Back
Top