Mafia Make Mafia Grate Again! Game Over! Town wins!

Heyden said:

You do realise they were trolls and you shouldn't take into account for what they say...

Click to expand...

great point
the great trumperino in the sky would be proud

Alexi said:

you voted for Heyden right after he voted you.. I'm sorry but the bolded part is very flawed.
As for the rest of this post ? Half the playerlist has 2-3 posts, which would put them at "no effort" in this game.

Click to expand...

Fair enough. I had legitimate reasons for putting in an early vote, and I'm sure Tardis did as well. I still think Tardis needs to be investigated further though.

inkling said:

@xine,

are you kidding me? all your reads consist of is you grasping for straws. i will give you credit for the creativity. All of the was happeneing around 11pm-12am here. The game had just started and the thread was suddenly bombarded by a troll. There was nothing to react to except for the troll. And no, for the first few posts it was not obvious that honey was a troll. And I'm not stupid or oblivious, I think most of us were confused until the posts became blatantly trolly.

Also I worked all day and I'm still catching up. There are way to many posts so far. But I'd thought I'd respond to your post.

- - - Post Merge - - -

also, @xine, why are you defending aron so hard?

Click to expand...

Its pretty interesting how you were quiet this whole time until I mentioned you, and then in about an hour you are here defending yourself.

Others said plenty of things that had nothing to do with the troll, so you can't use that excuse, sorry. Not once did I call you stupid so you don't have to be offended by the way. Your level of defensiveness isn't necessary.
I suggest taking more time to give reads if you would like me to townread you.

I did not defend him, we are not lynching someone that has claimed doctor. Why are you asking me that if you still haven't fully read the thread?

Tardis2016 said:

I have 2 reasons why they know about the quick topic.
1. they read some of the old games.
2. They got a Pm role and the link was linking them to the quick topic.

Click to expand...

They started babbling about Tarot Mafia, so it's the first of the two.

Aron, why'd you ignore my post? ):

Sorry Daniel, I legitimately didn't read this.

Call me Daniel said:

Why are you suspicious of ness and Tardis for being inactive/not trying when there's literally more than half of the other members you could say the same thing about?

Click to expand...

Because with the other members we literally have nothing to go on. With Ness, he was being very active and then when the accusations started he just... left. With Tardis, they weren't inactive, they've just been acting pretty suspicious and has been very quick to just agree with everyone else.

xine said:

Its pretty interesting how you were quiet this whole time until I mentioned you, and then in about an hour you are here defending yourself.

Others said plenty of things that had nothing to do with the troll, so you can't use that excuse, sorry. Not once did I call you stupid so you don't have to be offended by the way. Your level of defensiveness isn't necessary.
I suggest taking more time to give reads if you would like me to townread you.

I did not defend him, we are not lynching someone that has claimed doctor. Why are you asking me that if you still haven't fully read the thread?

Click to expand...

Sorry, I'm a bit confused. I'm not offended? Where did the stupid part come from?

By this time I've read the thread and I understand nobody wants to lynch aron bc he claimed doctor. I understand that.

As to the rest of whatever you said, I'm honestly just not interested and like I said you're grasping for straws here. I especially have nothing to say since you completely ignored and did not directly respond to my explanation.

Was it common for Ness to go inactive after being questioned? Maybe it's because I've never played with him before, but i don't see it as odd. Could have a genuine reason for not responding.

Gonna go play Pandemic Legacy with my mom and dad, be back in an hour or two Try not to post a ton, I don't want to have to read 27 pages when I come back haha

Kevinnn said:

Was it common for Ness to go inactive after being questioned? Maybe it's because I've never played with him before, but i don't see it as odd. Could have a genuine reason for not responding.

Click to expand...

In the games I've played with Ness he doesn't just disappear. Even if he is being scummy he'll keep posting - of course these posts become obvious frustration/emotion but now it just seems he's either: 1-avoiding the thread/maybe breaking meta? 2-something irl is actually going on and well then i feel bad but no way to tell I guess.

Kevinnn said:

Was it common for Ness to go inactive after being questioned? Maybe it's because I've never played with him before, but i don't see it as odd. Could have a genuine reason for not responding.

Click to expand...

It does seem rather suspicious that the moment a finger gets pointed the disappear.

Aronthaer said:

Sorry Daniel, I legitimately didn't read this.



Because with the other members we literally have nothing to go on. With Ness, he was being very active and then when the accusations started he just... left. With Tardis, they weren't inactive, they've just been acting pretty suspicious and has been very quick to just agree with everyone else.

Click to expand...

I have a pit in my stomach over Tardis, they have been only really defending against the already dead Honey.dew and making some quick view accusations with anything anyone says may be right. I am calling them as the prime suspects for this lynching.

Alright with there being so many people in this game it's kinda hard to keep track of everyone so i wanted to make a post kinda like an attendance report/ quick read of everyone to make sure we're all on the same page and aware of whom is yet to really contribute or join game. a fast run down if you will... ha

Players i feel are contributing enough to get a read on:

Cory, Sarasakat, Daniel, Aron, Ness (until going mia recently)

Xine - Glad to see you've finally released the game has started and look forward to more of your strong post.

Heyden - Seems to be participating but mostly with just general obvious things about the game, setup, roles, and abilities. would like to see some more read based post from you.

Crys - Isn't as helpful as last game when they were a town sided third party (??) not helping town scum hunt as much.

Clam - I know your new so i won't go crazy but 3-4 post pretty much just letting us know your reading isn't sufficient.

Cad - Same as Clam i know your New and it takes a lot of time to read the thread but please contribute.

Inkling - I know your still new as well but we need more than you just popping in and out without contributing much and then getting emotional whenever someone looks your direction.

Kevin - Has 3 post in total answering the RQS and stating he's reading.

Qwerty - You have a bit more experience than the really new people (from what i remember) you have 2 post total and you claim to be scum hunting but we haven't seen any result of that yet.

Shiida - Seems to be laying low just answering the RQS until you deiced to push Aron pretty hard with the other peeps.

Mother - Doing her usual thing, which i find pretty annoying im surprised if she ends up with 10 total post per game she's in. Every time we just let her skate on by til the end and im getting tired of it.

Tae - Seems to me as a bit more quiet than im use to maybe a little bit more timid for some reason ? unless im just over looking them cause they seem pretty town sided at this point.

Alexi - Same as Tae you are doing your usual thing but a little more timid maybe cause you got questioned coming out of the gate. Don't get discouraged if you town we still want to hear from you.

M3ow - Im not use to such an inactive M3ow, she usually comes with really strong reads and well organized post and makes it easy to be town, but not so much yet.

Toad - You seem to want to help but i think you might be looking in the wrong direction or maybe are trying to seem super town but giving these reads that no one else see?

Tardis - You keep bring up irrelevant things like trying to compare the two troll roles. post and find some hidden message, i think it would be best to just wait for those roles to be replaced so he can make sense of whats going on there.

Honey/Shondell Damn you troll ! no but really looking forward to the replacements we have a strong list of replacement that can help point us in the right direction, hope we don't have to wait till the end of day to get them in the game.

again these were just the first things that came to mind for each person and their activity thus far.

I like the change of gamestyle Panda, props to you. I should probably do some reads on everyone but I can't be bothered to right now haha

- - - Post Merge - - -

I might do it know because we all know I love colour coding

- - - Post Merge - - -

now*

Alexi said:

genuine question - do you know what a troll is?

Click to expand...

Someone who tries to get people upset, and starting arguments.

I appreciate the read on players Panda, very helpful, and I will attempt to contribute more. Now that it is the weekend I should be able to put more into this game.

Heyden said:

I like the change of gamestyle Panda, props to you. I should probably do some reads on everyone but I can't be bothered to right now haha

Click to expand...

@Heyden haha thanks im trying, its pretty tiring but im just trying not to lynch the Cop D1 again like last game. i hated myself for that especially cause i was so close to lynching Ness/Tom and let them get away last minute.

actually I might wait until the end of the day, depending on the lynch since we don't really have a basis at the moment.

- - - Post Merge - - -

Panda1376 said:

@Heyden haha thanks im trying, its pretty tiring but im just trying not to lynch the Cop D1 again like last game. i hated myself for that especially cause i was so close to lynching Ness/Tom and let them get away last minute.

Click to expand...

Don't sheep

Cadbberry said:

I appreciate the read on players Panda, very helpful, and I will attempt to contribute more. Now that it is the weekend I should be able to put more into this game.

Click to expand...

@Cad oh trust me i know Mafia games are very time consuming, just would like to hear anything from you guys really. anything is better than nothin.

Tardis2016 said:

Someone who tries to get people upset, and starting arguments.

Click to expand...

Then why are you reacting to every troll accusation towards you when it is known they are trying to throw the game off track.

Ugh this is pretty frustrating. I want to make reads but it would just end up mainly being regurgitated stuff that was said during the whole doc claim thing, and like half of the players have barely posted. Yiu lurkers need to start posting so I can actually properly read y'all. Even though we have a lot of posts and drama, not much has really happened expect some conversations between a few players.

- - - Post Merge - - -

Accept*

- - - Post Merge - - -

Except* damn it

at this point there isn't much to go off of but here are my current thoughts in a nutshell:

i think tae is being unusually quiet. i think this important to make note of and I'd like to hear an explanation.

heyden is following his typical meta so is probs town.

n e s s, its hard to say. i think he did get frustrated and quit. maybe he's giving himself breathing room? in the last game he was scum and acted defensive but was a bit more calm and collected. this game he kinda just exploded so i think he might really be town.

cad, seems like she's trying to be helpful to town and didnt post previously bc she was unsure or whatever.

xine is trying to be helpful to town but i don't feel she asks enough questions.

panda is being less aggressive this game

there's definitely something off about aron. i know m3ow and xine are defending him. but maybe he read the last game and saw the doctor was killed d1 and wanted to start a guilt trip? i don't want to lynch him of course but something's not right here.

- - - Post Merge - - -

oh and tardis is very confused as usual