Mafia Make Mafia Grate Again! Game Over! Town wins!

Sorry if this is sloppy i don't really know how to do one of these ISO thingys very well, ill be back with a couple more on who else i think is sus atm, give me some time.

Yeah, after reading through the past couple pages (40 posts per page so it's not a lot), it really *SEEMS* like he's townie who THOUGHT claiming doctor would be a good idea.
Then when we all freaked out about him claiming, he realized it was the worst thing he could've done. So, I'm reading him as like 60% town 20% actual doctor 20% scum, for now.

why if you have decided that Aron was 80% town/doctor have you repeatedly gone after him? maybe it's cause you're new? and don't know the possibilities of the game? im not sure but its very contradictory. i understand if new information is gained or there certain game development that opinions change but what you've been doing is different... with stuff like this...

yesss tae is back. im loving this right now - esp your read on aron. everyone wants to townread him but i can pull real quick 5+ quotes from him that sound scummy as hell.

good to hear you landed safely btw

the more i look into it, the more aron screams scum.

aron if you really want to make some good guesses and lynch some scum, maybe a read on someone who hasn't been already mentioned? or even someone who has been but for different reasons you find sus?

your tone/words say you know he's not scum but then you always keep this 'suspicious attitude' towards him.

A lot of us don't have definite reads and with having 24+ hours left makes complete sense. Still waiting on a replacements and some others to post more so I'll wait for that.

I'm expecting Crys to actually deliver something "[good]" crys DO NOT LET ME DOWN.
Then theres ness who said he would post today.

One, or both of those two things are sure to deliver us in some direction.

- - - Post Merge - - -

oh i missed sarasakat's reads. reading rn

As per lately, Xine delivers with good reads and has similiar sus with who I'm thinking - which is Ness. Really just been waiting for him to come on and post then go from there.

the three above quotes shows Alexi waiting for 6 players (the 2 replacements:Tina, Luca, Xine, Crys, Ness, Sarasakat) to post/make reads without her making any effort and actually not delivering on her promise to do some herself. This is a sign of her being very sheepish and not willing to form her own opinions and wanting to just piggy back off of the other (more experienced) players in the game.

@ness, why are you focusing so much on sarasakat? she's been townread by every single one of us. she even townread YOU adn you still think she's scum?
idk.. like I said, getting weird vibes from ness - i think he's just trying to take the attention off of the fact some of us were sus that he just left.

Im sorry but this is ridiculous the more i look at it, this just shows her mind set, Why would Ness town read someone just cause that person town read them? thats not how the game works, so if i just go around town reading everyone no one will scum read me in return? NO! it just sounds like you have the mind set of trying to stay on everyones 'good side' and get town read.

when i was reading back this stuck out to me as really weird and i can't quite figure it out whats happening between the three (Aron, Clam, Alexi of them here in this quote:

Why even say that? They had swapped the topic off of you and all you did was immediately bring the spotlight right back on you.

This, though.

^Exactly what Curry said. Like... Why say that. You get most of the sus of off you, then bring it right back. Wth?

This is like Clam and Alexi are scum coaching Aron in the thread? to me this reads "Hey Aron they almost caught you and you got the attention off you, why bring it back up!" but then again that would be very stupid for scum to do so it's most likely that Alexi is just trying to agree and blend in where she can maybe ? but then still where from Clam.

this is Aron[/B's] response to Clam and Alexi:

It was just an offhand comment, it wasn't supposed to amount to anything. But then I remembered: Riiight, this is TBT mafia. everything you say can and will be used against you in the worst way possible. oops.

I'm finding it hard to read Aron at times his tone and statements read very genuine but at the same time some of the stuff is so ridiculously anti-town that it makes me second guess it, but in the end i think he's most likely telling the truth (with what info i gathered from the development with Sarasakat and recent events), or at least if he's not we should give him another day to prove himself and then maybe we can look at him again, ("blocking" toad, dead role name and not protecting a stronger town member ect.).
 
I actually really like panda's thought process here. Really like panda's thought process this game, probably one of my highest townreads right now.

In other words i'm thinking of voting Alexi but I want to read into her more before I do.
 
I'm gonna have to agree with Toad here. I'm pretty sure at least one person on the mafia team is new/lurky so I'm pretty sure there's one in Tardis/Clam. I don't think it would be Tardis since he's mkstly bringing up scenarios and doesn't seem scummy. Clams case on me was pretty weak and it seem like she was pulling things out of nowhere. I'm voting Clam.
 
I actually really like panda's thought process here. Really like panda's thought process this game, probably one of my highest townreads right now.

In other words i'm thinking of voting Alexi but I want to read into her more before I do.

@Ness can you help look into Heyden and Tardis (and anyone else you sus) as well... im doing that as we speak and im getting so overwhelmed.
 
Hi everyone, I just wanted to let you know that I'm still dealing with real life problems and won't be around as much over the next day or so. The problem I have is that I'm very prone to seizures and almost had one last night (when I posted what I did) and I've still been in the same headache that it gives me when I'm about to have one, so I won't be on much. If for whatever reason people don't believe me, I'd be happy to provide a picture of my medication bottle for proof.

As for actually helping, I'll try and do what I can while I'm still on for the time being. After reading Xine's testimony in favor of Kat, I remove my sus of her. I'm still fishy of the whole two doctor thing, but when Kat is claiming to have protected Xine, who is then claiming to be shot and saved, I'm much more inclined to believe her. That then switches my sus over to Aron though. I'm not saying two doctors is impossible, but in the games of TOS I've played, I never saw that happen so I assumed it wouldn't happen in forum mafia. Reading over everyone's posts though, apparently it has happened here before so I'm not saying scum but it makes me much more sus.

I'd love to hear the reasoning for me being put into the yellow for some people. I'll hopefully be back later tonight.
 
I'm gonna have to agree with Toad here. I'm pretty sure at least one person on the mafia team is new/lurky so I'm pretty sure there's one in Tardis/Clam. I don't think it would be Tardis since he's mkstly bringing up scenarios and doesn't seem scummy. Clams case on me was pretty weak and it seem like she was pulling things out of nowhere. I'm voting Clam.

@Heyden you are seriously contradicting yourself so much this game. ill show you how shortly.
 
Hi everyone, I just wanted to let you know that I'm still dealing with real life problems and won't be around as much over the next day or so. The problem I have is that I'm very prone to seizures and almost had one last night (when I posted what I did) and I've still been in the same headache that it gives me when I'm about to have one, so I won't be on much. If for whatever reason people don't believe me, I'd be happy to provide a picture of my medication bottle for proof.

As for actually helping, I'll try and do what I can while I'm still on for the time being. After reading Xine's tetimony in favor of Kat, I remove my sus of her. I'm still fishy of the whole two doctor thing, but when Kat is claiming to have protected Xine, who is then claiming to be shot and saved, I'm much more inclined to believe her. That then switches my sus over to Aron though. I'm not saying two doctors is impossible, but in the games of TOS I've played, I never saw that happen so I assumed it wouldn't happen in forum mafia. Reading over everyone's posts though, apparently it has happened here before so I'm not saying scum but it makes me much more sus.

I'd love to hear the reasoning for me being put into the yellow for some people. I'll hopefully be back later tonight.
were you our vig now townie?
 
were you our vig now townie?
I'm not a Vig, but I am a town. Borrowing from Kat's logic, "I can't explain because of circumstances."
when i was reading back this stuck out to me as really weird and i can't quite figure it out whats happening between the three (Aron, Clam, Alexi of them here in this quote:


This is like Clam and Alexi are scum coaching Aron in the thread? to me this reads "Hey Aron they almost caught you and you got the attention off you, why bring it back up!" but then again that would be very stupid for scum to do so it's most likely that Alexi is just trying to agree and blend in where she can maybe ? but then still where from Clam.
People are always pushing me to contribute, and while it's not much, that was the first question I felt really comfortable asking someone because I thought it may actually be beneficial.
 
Should I just claim and stop wasting everyones time who makes cases on me.

@Heyden i don't know ? why do you have a fake claim ? you seem pretty quick to want to just had us a bit of information that will make us stop suspecting you. AND if you are pro town WTF did i say yesterday about people role claiming?, it only helps mafia/sk with POE. come on.
 
Should I just claim and stop wasting everyones time who makes cases on me.

@Heyden i don't know ? why do you have a fake claim ? you seem pretty quick to want to just had us a bit of information that will make us stop suspecting you. AND if you are pro town WTF did i say yesterday about people role claiming?, it only helps mafia/sk with POE. come on.
 
were you our vig now townie?
I'm not a Vig, but I am a town. Borrowing from Kat's logic, "I can't explain because of circumstances."
when i was reading back this stuck out to me as really weird and i can't quite figure it out whats happening between the three (Aron, Clam, Alexi of them here in this quote:


This is like Clam and Alexi are scum coaching Aron in the thread? to me this reads "Hey Aron they almost caught you and you got the attention off you, why bring it back up!" but then again that would be very stupid for scum to do so it's most likely that Alexi is just trying to agree and blend in where she can maybe ? but then still where from Clam.
People are always pushing me to contribute, and while it's not much, that was the first question I felt really comfortable asking someone because I thought it may actually be beneficial.
 
:/

Well I still think we should push ARON or lean towards a Clam vote. Maybe Tardis or Alexi but meh
i don't think ur my cop so im okay. I'm pretty sure clam is town.

I'm ok with tardis lynch or alexi.
 
Back
Top