It's bothering me how much information Aron is trying to fish on blue roles.
Mafia TBT Mafia-Korean War (Cancelled)
- Thread starter Dolby
- Start date
It's bothering me how much information Aron is trying to fish on blue roles.
I strongly disagree - His claim is solid enough to make him a potential target and I find it better to use the shot on one of the people that acts the most scummy than to 'save it' and end up dead either way. Normally I wouldn't say that using your Vig shot on Night 1 is very clever but since we assume there's going to be a lot of deaths either way, taking out a Mafia member to reduce the KP or eliminating the potential SK/third-party killing role could be truly game-changing in town's favour. High risk, high reward! Embrace the "YOLO!" lifestyle!
긴조선민주주의인민공화국을살!
I think I'll just type up a post because we need more talking at Night anyways. Anyone who says that they're afraid of death to further our country's purpose should be killed as it is...
I won't really go in-depth in response to Minties' post simply because it's true (the serious part, not the Mafia part). I'm taking this game seriously even though the theme is like so much more exploitable than Faithful June's, and even though serious I'm still having fun with the theme <3. Not to mention, I generally played Mafia on an iPad, and this explains to me why I'm typing properly now (iDevices make me cry to sleep and being on a computer reminds me of typing classes). Enough excuses; nobody cares at all!
We will forever miss 선생 Lenin. 선생 Lenin helped our country tremendously (even if not in this game), and it is saddening to have such a great man be lost. However, we shant be sad; it was the doing of our 영원한대통령! He thinks in ways we can't comprehend, but it will forever be for the best.
Byuntae has no real anything from me. They're relatively inactive, and this can be seen as coasting? Something to keep in mind; last post on TBT was there last post in this thread, about 20 hours ago (at the time of writing).
Crys told us to expect a lot of posts with not much length in his responses to the RQS~
i'm pathetic and don't look at playerlists soz <3
Either way, I pointed it out then and I'm pointing it out now: This superb piece of logic has only worked against inactives once in my history of Mafia, and it was lynn105 and Horus in The Murder Before Christmas. Maybe Alice in the first Kingmaker? Although that was Ashtot challenging--I still have no idea why he did it nor why it was successful. Dismissing it as sarcasm.
I didn't like his continuance of it.
After that, he then stops really bringing attention to it, picking a suspicion up on Shiida (SHEE-duh
) and then dismissing what he did as reaction-testing. I guess that's okay? I'm not really liking it tbh
Crys adding Endless into his suspicions simply because of controlling behavior--which matches up with every game he's played ever--and then erroneously stating that it's a "recipe for being blocked and frames." The blocks part is totally wrong (as long as the PR's identity stays hidden, unlike in Kirbystarship's possible case), the frames part would be right--if Endless told Det what to do (I don't think he did lol).
Overall, I'm viewing Crys as scum/third party--and for probably all of the wrong reasons because that's just me being amazing
CMD had some fun. Thing is, are you continuing his suspicion, Jared? I'm actually hardcore-townreading CMD despite my vote on him last Day (which was more of a reaction test to get something based off of a hunch, anyways soz </3)... His intentions are in all the right places and he actually was able to pinpoint his gut feelings. I still don't like his pinpointed reason (coast followed by giant fluff post which was apparently huge to look important--not because there was a lot to react to, then a continued coast), but his thought process after coming to the conclusion that I was doing this coasting playstyle makes sense, so we'll credit him there. Either way, I'm calling Jared/CMD Town for now <3
I just realized that I haven't really ever tried to reaction test before ehehe
And this is me, being lazy as hell. I'll get the rest up later (I haven't done Miharu up simply because I'm getting kicked off atm)
So yeah! Sorry about the still amazing amount of fluff, I tried to condense it down to just Ashtot's section.
- - - Post Merge - - -
And, I know, I know, my organization is absolutely beautiful, it gives me a headache too ?\_(ツ)_/?
I think I'll just type up a post because we need more talking at Night anyways. Anyone who says that they're afraid of death to further our country's purpose should be killed as it is...
I won't really go in-depth in response to Minties' post simply because it's true (the serious part, not the Mafia part). I'm taking this game seriously even though the theme is like so much more exploitable than Faithful June's, and even though serious I'm still having fun with the theme <3. Not to mention, I generally played Mafia on an iPad, and this explains to me why I'm typing properly now (iDevices make me cry to sleep and being on a computer reminds me of typing classes). Enough excuses; nobody cares at all!
We will forever miss 선생 Lenin. 선생 Lenin helped our country tremendously (even if not in this game), and it is saddening to have such a great man be lost. However, we shant be sad; it was the doing of our 영원한대통령! He thinks in ways we can't comprehend, but it will forever be for the best.
Byuntae has no real anything from me. They're relatively inactive, and this can be seen as coasting? Something to keep in mind; last post on TBT was there last post in this thread, about 20 hours ago (at the time of writing).
Crys told us to expect a lot of posts with not much length in his responses to the RQS~
When Miharu asked why:
And then I responded thinking he was making a reference to my avatar or something lol
i'm pathetic and don't look at playerlists soz <3
Either way, I pointed it out then and I'm pointing it out now: This superb piece of logic has only worked against inactives once in my history of Mafia, and it was lynn105 and Horus in The Murder Before Christmas. Maybe Alice in the first Kingmaker? Although that was Ashtot challenging--I still have no idea why he did it nor why it was successful. Dismissing it as sarcasm.
But then the next one appears. So it was actually going through his head as a possible thing? I guess gut feeling is still there and not to eliminate, but I'm not seeing it~
I didn't like his continuance of it.
After that, he then stops really bringing attention to it, picking a suspicion up on Shiida (SHEE-duh
) and then dismissing what he did as reaction-testing. I guess that's okay? I'm not really liking it tbhCrys adding Endless into his suspicions simply because of controlling behavior--which matches up with every game he's played ever--and then erroneously stating that it's a "recipe for being blocked and frames." The blocks part is totally wrong (as long as the PR's identity stays hidden, unlike in Kirbystarship's possible case), the frames part would be right--if Endless told Det what to do (I don't think he did lol).
Overall, I'm viewing Crys as scum/third party--and for probably all of the wrong reasons because that's just me being amazing
CMD had some fun. Thing is, are you continuing his suspicion, Jared? I'm actually hardcore-townreading CMD despite my vote on him last Day (which was more of a reaction test to get something based off of a hunch, anyways soz </3)... His intentions are in all the right places and he actually was able to pinpoint his gut feelings. I still don't like his pinpointed reason (coast followed by giant fluff post which was apparently huge to look important--not because there was a lot to react to, then a continued coast), but his thought process after coming to the conclusion that I was doing this coasting playstyle makes sense, so we'll credit him there. Either way, I'm calling Jared/CMD Town for now <3
I just realized that I haven't really ever tried to reaction test before ehehe
And this is me, being lazy as hell. I'll get the rest up later (I haven't done Miharu up simply because I'm getting kicked off atm)
So yeah! Sorry about the still amazing amount of fluff, I tried to condense it down to just Ashtot's section.
- - - Post Merge - - -
And, I know, I know, my organization is absolutely beautiful, it gives me a headache too ?\_(ツ)_/?
yeah you're right, i guess as long as the shots refunded if he's roleblocked it doesn't really matter
Aronthaer
Back from Hiatus (3/18/22)
Just trying to assess the situation, keep in mind this is my second forum mafia game.
Was talking about Bluepikachu.
To clarify this, picking up a suspicion on Shiida and the action dismissed are meant to be two different things <3Me said:After that, he then stops really bringing attention to it, picking a suspicion up on Shiida (SHEE-duh
Sorry for confusion~
- - - Post Merge - - -
oh wow two spoilers in the crys quote sorry </3
Kirbystarship
Senior Member
I'm a 1shot Vig.
If I'm still alive on D2 can I have some Won so I can buy items?
If I'm still alive on D2 can I have some Won so I can buy items?
No free rides
Be a dirty capitalist and save your money
Kirbystarship
Senior Member
Going to type my color code reads at the end of N1 and my thought out reads on D2 if I'm still alive.
Sounds good B]
well that's nice and everything, but between this post and the post where you FINALLY posted your case on minties (which was still a SHORT POST iirc only about 9-10 lines. that's hardly building a proper case, that's just posting the bare minimum) you must've posted at least another 5 or 6 times saying you were going to do it and you were just finding the posts. in fact you had to refind the posts at one point. why did you put it off for so long? it's not like you weren't active in the thread seeing as you posted a bunch in between where you said you were making a case for minties and the actual 'case'. i'm not sure if i buy into your vig claim either - whereas no-one has come forward and counterclaimed why would they since you could be lying and it would just put a target on their head too. and sataric, as somebody pointed out to me in the last game i played, it is possible that the mafia could have a list of the names to go with each role, so therefore i don't believe that the namedrop is enough to prove that his claim is legitimate.
your choice of language as miharu has pointed out is funny - saying that you have been 'caught off guard' implies that you have something to hide. i'd still like to see more thoughts from you on the other players in this game. also, why haven't you caught up? we're over 60 hours into the game and all you've really said that is contributing to discussion is that you think kirby is suspicious, and you haven't even listed your own reasons for thinking that.
i'm going to address these together since i'm pretty hurt by what has happened (lol). i personally did think meta had a large part in reading somebody hence i based part of my suspicions of kirby on his meta - which by the way, is the EXACT same as when he was scum - so i wasn't exactly going to ignore this in my read since it was raising so many red flags. i've only played one game with only a small handful of the players here and so far i've discovered that the benefits of playing mafia within a small group of people is that you get to know people's playstyles and that betters your judgement and reads. but when a more experienced player comes along and basically says 'no don't do that' it's understandable that it made me think twice since i'm still sitting here and learning the ropes of this game as a whole, so now i'm left feeling like a bit of a guillable idiot. another one of the reasons i listened to endless is because i was town-reading him at the time, but now it's been pointed out how controlling his behaviour seems to be i'll have to have another think when i go back through his posts and complete my reads after i finish this post.
i briefly touched upon why i hadn't purple voted at the end of my last post - due to timezones the end of the day/night falls in at an inconvenient time for me, and by the time i'd posted the first half of my reads it was already 12am and i needed to sleep since i had school the next day. even though i was and still am highly suspicious of kirby, i didn't want to throw his name in the hat without having a close look at everybody and making a read for everybody before deciding who i found to be the most suspicious. i like the idea of the purple voting system and will use it on the next day, it was just due to unfortunate timing last night that i couldn't.
i've already addressed my feelings on a lot of this above but i feel the need to point out that i'd posted a scum lean on ashtot before xine posted their case so they weren't the only one to have suspicious feelings about them and didn't really 'dogpile' a lynch. kirby and oak's names were put up for possible lynches many more time than ashtot's, and their first post and subsequent disappearance was very suspicious, at least to me. and theoretically dogpiling a lynch on someone isn't really possible since at the end of the day it's only the king's one vote that count for anything.
uhh, some choice wording there. i didn't find call me daniel suspicious so i'm not going to take anything from your use of words here but i'll be interested in seeing what you have to say about everybody.
Just out of curiosity, why did the name Stalin seem right to you? o:
Tui, am I to understand that you're defying my experience and claiming that meta is a good method of reading someone, while simultaneously claiming to retract your townread on me because of something that I do which is an integral part of my meta?
You can't have your cake and eat it too. I was townreading you up until this point but I'm starting to wonder if you're just playing crowds' favourite.
You can't have your cake and eat it too. I was townreading you up until this point but I'm starting to wonder if you're just playing crowds' favourite.
