Posting this read before I go to bed as when typing this post it got pretty late.
I'm not gonna townread anyone on the first day, so anyone I don't feel like they're a threat/scummy/off ATM will be null for me.
xCleb - I want to see more posts from him
Dolby - He's a good player and contributing, so I want to see how he plays on the 2nd day after night passes
Heyden - I feel like he's being passive this game, at least I remember as town he would question more people than he would in this game
Zendel - I've said it before but his tone, the time it took for him to reply to posts directed at him, and his reasoning so far doesn't give the feeling that he's scum.
Mogyay - Not seeing things that gives strong indication to either town nor scum, not enough posts to make a lean either.
SenseiGallade - Null, while they have contributed reads I'd like to see them interact more with players.
Yzanda & Ashvenn - Will either be replaced or be late to the party.
Byngo - Same as Dolby, she's contributing and I would like to see how she plays in 2nd day.
Toadsworthy - Their explanation for their behavior in this game made sense, and it seems my pressure on him made him contribute more. I did say I was going to elaborate my reads on him but I'm too tired atm because I need to reread his posts, consider his explanation, and then consider the context of his posts, that will take more time and I'm not ready for that atm. Consider what I've pointed out previously and what he said.
Kirbystarship - Null. As far as I remember he tends to seem scummy even as town so he could be either at this point in the game.
Brijade07 - Null. Her reply to my questioning showed that she's familiar to how mafia works despite this being her first game, and she's contributing well so far for a new player, and because of that I need to see more of her posts & interactions with other players from her.
Uttomori - I may need to read their meta because theyr'e townread by other people pretty quick yet their posts doesn't stand out to me nor incline me to put them as town nor maf. Hoping to see their reads.
Curry - Needs to post more as people have pointed out
Arstotzkan - Waiting for their reads
PandaDarling - Like Heyden pointed out, she seemed more stern this game? Sadly she didn't interact much players so I can't see how she stands. Would like a read from you.
KermitTea - Would like to hear more from you now that there are more posts to discuss
Qwerty111 - Where are you
Apple2013 - I have a bad feeling about your playstyle atm because when you're this aggressive, you usually (from my experience playing with you) play badly or just stirring people up which is distracting to town, and that's bad whatever you alignment is.
After reading what I wrote, I feel like my reads are kind of lacking and I don't like how I'm undecided on half of the players. This might be because I'm tired, and I usually feel more confident after Night when people's stance would be more clearer. I'd like to see the people whose name are bolded to post more, as your lack of posts or interactions made it kind of hard for me to make a stance for everyone.
ATM I have no idea who to lynch, as you can see from my list I only have
toads and
Apple as suspicious but it's not very strong, as seeing how
Apple acts in this game just because gives me bad memories of his previous games and toads I have stated I need to read more thoroughly.
Going to bed now and hopefully I see more people posting, as it feels like just the same set of people (timezone is probably why though)
also
@Byngo:
TBT mafia wiki has links to all the games I've played. Last time I played town was in Trump mafia, and last time I played maf was in AoT but I quit halfway because I didn't want to play as mafia while I was fasting :s And I actually coached on the original SU mafia?? I didn't even remember...
