I agree with this. Of course there are some that I don't like, but it's just my personal opinion for whatever reason. But I've had Freckles in my City Folk game and she was just ADORABLE. And yet... not well liked. At all. And I just don't understand why. On the flip side, I love Fang. He's my favorite. But I've had him in every game since Wild World. I never looked at forums and saw who was popular until maybe a month ago. So I was surprised that my tastes span across the entire spectrum, from Freckles to Tangy to Fang. And I look at some of the Tier 1 and I can't help but think "WHY are they so popular?" But it's just everybody's personal opinions, and like with everything else, there will always be the ones that are super popular and some of us just can't understand why.For me it's all the unpopular ones. You'd think that all the villagers would be more or less evenly matched in terms of popularity. Still, I can see why they're unpopular: it's just that many players who like the game like certain types of designs too and the less popular villagers don't have them.
I love many villagers that aren't popular and it's sad they're disliked but that's just my opinion.
Bonbon. She's adorable and lovable C:
Also Willow, Frobert, Biskit, and Olivia..
I had her in my town. She was great.i think tutu the bear is cute, but she's always considered tier 5
she looks like a big puffy marshmallow bear <3