Best and worst of tier 5

CainWolf

CainWolf

Hipster Sheep
Joined
Apr 28, 2014
Posts
519
Bells
2,253
On the forums villagers tend to be organized into tiers and each tier seems listed in order of most to least popular, until you reach tier 5 which is listed alphabetically. I'm curious as to who people think the best and worst villagers of tier 5 are. Some say might say Tabby is pretty low on the list but is she so infamous that it keeps her from being at the absolute bottom with obscure villagers you never even heard of? On the other end you may have your underrated villagers like Sterling who have a unique costume-like appearance like the more popular ones such as Anka but get dragged down by the stigmas of being a jock and eagle despite being an armored knight. What are your personal opinions about the best and worst of tier 5?


Here is a link to the tier list I'm talking about.
http://www.belltreeforums.com/showthread.php?109343-List-of-Villagers-Based-on-Popularity

I have created a poll to settle this in a more concrete manner, you have the option to pick multiple villagers but please don't overdo it or spam your favorite. I put in all the villagers currently in Tier 5 of the thread I linked above. Feel free to share the poll if you want, it took a while to put in all the names so it would be great if lots of people put in their vote. I think I'll put it in my signature too.
The Poll: http://goo.gl/hVs9J4
The Results So Far: http://goo.gl/EtaQmd
 
Last edited:
Big Top - Why, he's the actual coolest. Just look at him. An elephant who is also a villain? With a cool hat? I want that, why does nobody else.
Rodeo - Why, he's the actual coolest. Just look at him. A bull who is also a chill dude? With cool horns? I want that, why does nobody else.
Victoria - Why, she's the actual coolest. Just look at her. A horse who is also a racer? With cool blinders? I want that, why does nobody else.
 
Rooney, my favorite villager honestly.

Oh there's also Aurora, Sydney, Rodeo, Big Top, & Snooty Ham Ham.
 
PomPom :3


Also looking at the tier lists...It saddens me that Carmen is so much lower than Eugene. I finally got him to move out of my village on the 26th. It's like a Christmas present for me.
 
Queenie is the worst. And a few other unmemorables.

But Bud, Teddy, Rasher, and Lionel are pure gold and don't deserve to be tier 5.
 
Sterling, Robin, Walt are in my village. I think they're underrated. They're also Rod, Margie, Monty, Drift, Caroline, and Mallary who I think deserve a bit more love.

Meanwhile, there are villagers like Velma and Elise that should go die in a fire.
 
I don't know why Wendy and Paula are Tier 5! I have both in my town and I wanted them! I actually paid for both of them :)
 
Dad said:
Queenie is the worst. And a few other unmemorables.

But Bud, Teddy, Rasher, and Lionel are pure gold and don't deserve to be tier 5.
Click to expand...

wtf queenie is the best ur opinion is wrong
 
Mr. Marowak said:
Big Top - Why, he's the actual coolest. Just look at him. An elephant who is also a villain? With a cool hat? I want that, why does nobody else.
Rodeo - Why, he's the actual coolest. Just look at him. A bull who is also a chill dude? With cool horns? I want that, why does nobody else.
Victoria - Why, she's the actual coolest. Just look at her. A horse who is also a racer? With cool blinders? I want that, why does nobody else.
Click to expand...

I love Victoria, she is my 2nd favorite horse in the game besides Roscoe. If I wasn't aiming for a medieval fantasy town then I would have snapped her up from the campsite in a heartbeat. Rodeo is probably my favorite bull for the same reason Roscoe is my favorite horse, the color scheme. Black fur with red eyes looks positively devious, and I mean that in the best way possible.
 
Chevre until recently, she's now 30th in Tier 4 but still that's almost Tier 5.
Keaton/Sterling/Celia are underrated.
I see Wendy pop up a ton and she's always snatched up.

Most of the Tier 5 villagers are underrated because tons of people fanboy over Marshal and i don't even find him cute.
*braces for Marshal Fanboys*

- - - Post Merge - - -

Also i think Nan is underrated as well yet i see her in signatures lately
 
Last edited:
I added a poll to my first post, let's find out who the best of the worst really is once and for all. Whichever villager gets placed dead last can get a little campaign or something to spread awareness of their existence.
 
Pfft my favorite Tier 5 is definitely Marcel. I mean people probably find him weird because of his face, but come on! He is so cute and sweet especially when he talks about food. He reminds me of a little kid who just got his face painted. I can understand why he is tier five, but I love him to death. Not to mention his name is my new nephew's name which is cooler.
 
Caroline, Aurora, Butch, Freckles, Soleil, Wendy. They're better than most of the tier ones actually imo.

Bottom would have to be Jambette, everyone hates her. As for me, Barold. His face makes me wanna barf.
 
DarkFox7 said:
Caroline, Aurora, Butch, Freckles, Soleil, Wendy. They're better than most of the tier ones actually imo.

Bottom would have to be Jambette, everyone hates her. As for me, Barold. His face makes me wanna barf.
Click to expand...

Agreed on Barold. Like why?
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

rocketspruggs
Bulls and Cows Tier List
Replies
9
Views
601
Nika
Nika
Yanrima~
Cat villager tier list
Replies
12
Views
1K
Halloqueen
Halloqueen
eeveelovee
Favourite Bottom Tier Villagers
2 3
Replies
48
Views
2K
Neb
Neb
C
The Flanderization of Animal Crossing's Characters and Dialouge
Replies
5
Views
676
-Apples-
-Apples-
Cetoddle769
What villager has grown on you?
Replies
8
Views
192
ShawnFuzz
ShawnFuzz
Back
Top