Best & Worst of Each Personality

[Shawna]

I know this type of tread has existed before, but I wanted to make one with multiple categories: Best, Worst, Most Attractive, Least Attractive, Most Overrated, and most Underrated from each personality. Feel free to come up with your own categories!

Best
Normal: Marcie
Peppy: Tammi
Snooty: Astrid
Uchi: Sylvia
Lazy: Big Top
Jock: Kid Cat
Cranky: Rooney
Smug: Eugene

Worst
Normal: Jambette
Peppy: Anicotti
Snooty: Ursala
Uchi: Canberra
Normal: Al
Jock: Samson
Cranky: Rolf
Smug: Hans

Most Attractive (beautiful)
Normal: Celia
Peppy: Marcy
Snooty: Ankha
Uchi: Phoebe

Most Attractive (handsome)
Lazy: Big Top
Jock: Bam
Cranky: Rooney
Smug: Lopez

Least Attractive
Normal: Jambette
Peppy: Anicotti
Snooty: Jane
Uchi: Canberra
Lazy: Al
Jock: Coach
Cranky: Gaston
Smug: Hans

Most Overrated
Normal: Mitzi
Peppy: Peanut
Snooty: Blaire
Uchi: Canberra (the only other uchi I dislike is Rocket, but she gets less hate)
Lazy: ?
Jock: ?
Cranky: Rolf
Smug: ?

Most Underrated
Normal: Peaches
Peppy: Tammi
Snooty: Velma
Uchi: Sylvia
Lazy: Anchovy
Jock: Genji
Cranky: Rooney
Smug: Eugene

My lists may not be 100% as it can be hard to choose, but I colored the ones I feel most strongly about in purple (e.g. Ankha's name is in purple because I think she is the most beautiful).
Remember: Make lots of lists, respect others' opinions, and have fun with this topic!

 

[GalacticGhost]

OK, so these are mine:

Best
Normal: Poppy
Peppy: Felicity
Snooty: Francine*
Uchi: Hazel*
Lazy: Alfonso
Jock: Rudy
Cranky: Static*
Smug: Eugene

*I don't feel too strongly about these because I've never had them before (though Hazel is moving into my town soon)

Worst
Normal: None
Peppy: None
Snooty: None
Uchi: None
Lazy: None
Jock: None
Cranky: None
Smug: None

That's right... there isn't a single villager that I dislike.

Cutest (I couldn't think of any for 'Most Attractive' lol)
Normal: Poppy
Peppy: Meow (if she counts. Why was she only in the e+ version ;-; )
Snooty: Mint
Uchi: Hazel (because of her catchphrase)
Lazy: Stitches
Smug: Marshal
Jock: Kid Cat
Cranky: ???

Least Attractive
Normal: Jambette
Peppy: ?
Snooty: ?
Uchi: Elise
Lazy: Al
Jock: Boone
Cranky: Peewee (I can't remember whether or not he's a cranky tho)
Smug: ?

Most Overrated
Normal: ?
Peppy: ?
Snooty: ?
Uchi: ?
Lazy: ?
Jock: ?
Cranky: ?
Smug: ?

I don't really know who to put here. Though I do wonder why so many people like the wolves. It's not that I don't like them, but I just don't know why they're so popular.

Most Underrated
Normal: MELBAAAAAAAA
Peppy: Wendy
Snooty: Mint
Uchi: Hazel
Lazy: Alfonso
Jock: ?
Cranky: ?
Smug: Eugene

I honestly have no idea why Melba is tier five. In fact, I think koalas in general are pretty underrated.

 

[SensaiGallade]

Best
Normal: Merangue
Peppy: Bunnie
Snooty: Diana
Uchi: Rocket
Lazy: Drago
Jock: Kid Cat
Cranky: Octavian
Smug: Marshal

Worst
Normal: ?
Peppy: Hazel (Urrgh that monobrow!)
Snooty: Ursala
Uchi: Canberra
Normal: Al
Jock: Samson
Cranky: Rolf
Smug: Hans

Most Attractive (beautiful)
Normal: Pekoe
Peppy: Chrissy
Snooty: Diana
Uchi: Phoebe

Most Attractive (handsome)
Lazy: Pietro
Jock: Kid Cat
Cranky: Roscoe
Smug: Marshal

Least Attractive
Normal: Jambette
Peppy: Anicotti
Snooty: Jane
Uchi: Canberra
Lazy: Al
Jock: Coach
Cranky: Gaston
Smug: Hans

Most Overrated
Normal: Marina
Peppy: Peanut
Snooty: Ankha
Uchi: Canberra
Lazy: Big Top
Jock: Kid Cat
Cranky: Rolf
Smug: Marshal (You can't resist his cuteness!)

Most Underrated
Normal: Peaches
Peppy: Tammi
Snooty: Velma
Uchi: Sylvia
Lazy: Anchovy
Jock: Genji
Cranky: Rooney
Smug: Eugene

 

[Shawna]

bump

 

[Balverine]

Best
Normal: Kiki
Peppy: Carmen
Snooty: Diana
Uchi: Muffy
Lazy: Clay
Jock: Rudy
Cranky: Hamphrey
Smug: Eugene

Worst
Normal: Margie?
Peppy: Anicotti
Snooty: Gloria
Uchi: Anyone besides Muffy lol
Lazy: Barold
Jock: Cobb
Cranky: Angus
Smug: Curlos

Cutest
Normal: Fauna
Peppy: Carmen
Snooty: Rhonda (from e+ )
Uchi: --
Lazy: Beau
Smug: Chadder? lol
Jock: Samson
Cranky: Hamphrey

Least Attractive
Normal: Jambette
Peppy: Anicotti
Snooty: all of them lol (besides Rhonda and Diana)
Uchi: Gloria (I think she's uchi)
Lazy: Al
Jock: Lyman
Cranky: Chow
Smug: Marcel (which is sad because I love that name)

 

[radioloves]

This one is mine~ c:

Best
Normal: Maple
Peppy: Sprinkle
Snooty: Diana
Uchi: Hazel
Lazy: Bob
Jock: Teddy
Cranky: Apollo
Smug: Julian

Worst
Normal: ---
Peppy: ---
Snooty: ----
Uchi: ---
Normal: ---
Jock: ---
Cranky: ----
Smug: ----

Most Attractive (beautiful)
Normal: Gayle
Peppy: Biana
Snooty: Whitney
Uchi: Phoebe

Most Attractive (handsome)
Lazy: Filbert
Jock: Bud
Cranky: Wolfgang
Smug: Marshal

Least Attractive
Hmm
Normal:
Peppy:
Snooty:
Uchi:
Lazy:
Jock:
Cranky:
Smug:

Most Overrated
I'm not even sure lol
Normal:
Peppy:
Snooty:
Uchi:
Lazy:
Jock:
Cranky:
Smug:

Most Underrated
Normal: Melba
Peppy: Tabby
Snooty: Velma
Uchi: Hazel
Lazy:
Jock:
Cranky:
Smug:

 

[Greggy]

Best
Normal: Tia
Peppy: Dotty
Snooty: Willow
Uchi: Renee
Lazy: Zucker
Jock: Snake and Genji (I love both of them equally ;_
Cranky: Fang
Smug: Ken

Worst
Normal: Peaches
Peppy: Freckles
Snooty: Elise or Claudia
Uchi: Diva
Lazy: Elmer or Clyde
Jock: Jitters (I like jocks, Jitters just happens to be my least favorite)
Cranky: Camofrog
Smug: Hippeaux

Most Attractive (Female)
Normal: Poppy or Tia
Peppy: Bunnie
Snooty: Olivia or Timbra
Uchi: Phoebe

Most Attractive (Male)
Lazy: Beau
Jock: Genji
Cranky: Lobo literally got a nosebleed for making him wear glasses in my HHD game
Smug: Phil or Ken. Lovely feathers!

Least Attractive
Normal: Peaches
Peppy: Anicotti
Snooty: Queenie and Robin
Uchi: Canberra (I like Canberra, but I admit that she's the least attractive uchi to me)
Lazy: Clyde
Jock: Jitters
Cranky: Limberg
Smug: Quillson or Ed

Most Overrated
Normal: The normal cats and Flurry
Peppy: Chrissy
Snooty: Diana
Uchi: Phoebe and Mira
Lazy: Beau
Jock: Kid Cat
Cranky: The cranky wolves (Fang > Wolfgang > Chief > Lobo in order), but I get their appeal.
Smug: Marshal

Most Underrated
Normal: Cally, Caroline, or Dora
Peppy: Dotty, Tammi, or Victoria
Snooty: Yuka
Uchi: Charlise
Lazy: Doc, Big Top, or Clay
Jock: Ribbot
Cranky: Knox
Smug: Henry, Shep, or Chadder

 

[treetops]

Spoiler

Best
Normal: Daisy
Peppy: Pinky
Snooty: Francine
Uchi: Muffy
Lazy: Stitches
Jock: Antonio
Cranky: Tom
Smug: Olaf

Worst
I honestly don't hate anybody. There are certainly some that I dislike, but I don't really want to call them the worst.

Cutest
Normal: Daisy
Peppy: Pinky
Snooty: Willow
Uchi: Pashmina
Lazy: Stitches
Jock: Rod
Cranky: Tom
Smug: Marshal

Least Cutest
Normal: Jambette
Peppy: Tabby
Snooty: Elise
Uchi: Rocket
Lazy: Al
Jock: Tank
Cranky: Peewee
Smug: Hippeux

Most Overrated
Normal: Tia
Peppy: Ruby
Snooty: Diana
Uchi: Cherry
Lazy: Zucker
Jock: Genji
Cranky: Octavian
Smug: Julian

Despite what I've listed, I can see why all of those villagers are loved by other people. Some of these villagers (namely Genji and Julian) I do like regardless of how "overrated" they may be.

Most Underrated
Normal: Nan
Peppy: Pinky
Snooty: Monique
Uchi: Frita
Lazy: Moe
Jock: Rod
Cranky: Rooney
Smug: Quillson

I'm not sure how underrated these villagers are, though. I'm more just going by villagers that I like, but not many people talk about them.

To take up less space, I have decided to put my lists in the spoilers above. Villagers that are highlighted in Italics are my favourites/least favourites.

 

[Shawna]

bump

 

[AccfSally]

Best
Normal: Sally
Peppy: Nibbles
Snooty: Francine
Uchi: Hazel
Lazy: ??
Jock: Genji!!!!
Cranky: Static
Smug: ??

Worst
Normal: Gladys
Peppy: Puddles or Tangy
Snooty: Alli (Have more)
Uchi: ??
Lazy: ??
Jock: Jitters
Cranky: Peewee or Rocco
Smug: ??

Most Attractive (beautiful)
Normal: Sally or Poppy Sally more!
Peppy: Bonbon
Snooty: Blaire
Uchi: Muffy

Most Attractive (handsome)
Lazy: ??
Jock: Genji
Cranky: Static
Smug: Chadder

Least Attractive
Normal: Jambette
Peppy: Pompom
Snooty: Elise
Uchi: ??
Lazy: Al
Jock: Jitters
Cranky: Rocco or Peewee
Smug: Chops

Most Overrated
Normal: Poppy or Merengue
Peppy: Chrissy
Snooty: Francine (sorry, buddy T_T) and Diana
Uchi: Phoebe
Lazy: Erik or Zucker
Jock: ??
Cranky: ??
Smug: Marshal (duh)

Most Underrated
Normal: Sally, Caroline and Cally (more really)
Peppy: Nibbles
Snooty: Tiffany or Timbra
Uchi: Hazel or Frita
Lazy: Doc
Jock: Sheldon
Cranky: Ricky
Smug: Chadder (Sweetheart that needs more love)

 

[davidlblack]

I'm just doing best and over/underrated because I'm a very lazy person.

Normal: Molly
Peppy: Felicity
Snooty: Whitney
Uchi: Cherry
Lazy: Nate
Jock: Stinky
Cranky: Grizzly
Smug: Marshal

Underrated:
Normal: ?
Peppy: Tabby
Snooty: Amelia
Uchi: Shari
Lazy: Nate
Jock: Jitters and Stinky!
Cranky: Grizzly and Rolf
Smug: Pietro

Overrated:

Normal: Merengue/Marina
Peppy: Rosie
Snooty: ?
Uchi: ?
Lazy: Beau, Zucker Stitches
Jock: Genji
Cranky: Octavian, EVERY CRANKY WOLF!
Smug: Marshal and the stupid unicorn who got stabbed in the head with a freaking butchers knife