I do not have any funny Club Tortimer stories, however, I found the island very enjoyable! It was always exciting to me, meeting players from all around the world. Sure, you encountered the occasional troll who would trap you there, spam messages, and even insult you with colorful words. Overall, it was a great experience though! I am glad Nintendo added the Club Tortimer feature!
I generally try to make conversation with the people I come across, unless they are being rude. I try to be a nice person by attempting to make conversation.