Confused by Jack's RNG

[DragonAceSg7]

There are so many furniture items but from the villagers, I keep getting the same few. For the Lollipops, I've received 3 of his faces and 3 of his robes, and giving him just candy he first gave me a carriage but then gave me the 3rd or 4th Spooky Wall of the night.

Do I keep giving him the lollipops or just candy to get more furniture to try and get the 5 or so things I've not received? Cause I'm running out of candy.

Oh I am finding other links that say he doesn't give the furniture other than the carriage. So the RNG on my villagers is being crummy.

 

[Mutti]

It was mainly getting the craft diy from him for lollypops, since we got them last year and its not been updated we are stuck with randomised halloween furniture & outfit pieces

 

[DragonAceSg7]

I didn't play last year. And now I'm getting nothing but pumpkins from the villagers. This stinks. I'm still missing so much.

 

[Pig-Pen]

I didn't play last year. And now I'm getting nothing but pumpkins from the villagers. This stinks. I'm still missing so much.

This was my first year doing the halloween event too.... It took me 20 or so interactions with him by giving him candy and lollipops to get everything, I did end up with a bunch of extra garlands, dining sets, robes...but eventually got everything. Just keep at it, if you can.

 

[DragonAceSg7]

I'll try with what I have left but the last 6 interactions have been either face or robe, thanks.

 

[MarkySharky]

I read that after a few items from Jack, you will only get face and robe duplicates as he has nothing else to give.

https://animalcrossingworld.com/guides/new-horizons/jacks-halloween-event-guide-rewards/

 

[Kg1595]

That’s a shame. The big reward last year was the spooky carriage.

 

[DragonAceSg7]

I managed to get the Carriage since I got that before the face and robe. But I was hoping for more DIY. I don't know how to get the rest of them.

ETA: I did get the carriage DIY. How do you get the rest of the DIYs?

 

[MarkySharky]

I managed to get the Carriage since I got that before the face and robe. But I was hoping for more DIY. I don't know how to get the rest of them.

ETA: I did get the carriage DIY. How do you get the rest of the DIYs?

Giving candy to other villagers is the way.

 

[DragonAceSg7]

Giving candy to other villagers is the way.

Alright, I'll keep trying. I've been getting either stacks of pumpkins or the same wallpaper again. Thanks.

 

[MarkySharky]

Alright, I'll keep trying. I've been getting either stacks of pumpkins or the same wallpaper again. Thanks.

If you check that article, I think it says there is only a limited number of things to get before you start getting duplicates.

 

[Brookie]

This video might help,
Separate from this, He did a 1 hr livestream figuring out the mechanics of how halloween works. He also has another video on spooky items and how to get them.

 

[DragonAceSg7]

If you check that article, I think it says there is only a limited number of things to get before you start getting duplicates.

Okay, was confusing because I got duplicates before I got a couple of the other things so wasn't sure if I'd eventually get more.

Post automatically merged: Oct 31, 2021

This video might help,
Separate from this, He did a 1 hr livestream figuring out the mechanics of how halloween works. He also has another video on spooky items and how to get them.

I'm down to my last piece of candy, I'll take a quick look, thanks.

Post automatically merged: Oct 31, 2021

Watched the vid. The villagers did not give me any DIYs, sadly. I'll have to trade for the ones I still need later. Thanks all.

 

[Rosch]

Check the first post of this thread:

🎃🎃🎃 HALLOWEEN SEASON begins! 🎃🎃🎃

🎃 It's October 1st and that means it's SPOOKY SEASON again. Jack's Poster should be mailed to you on October 1st. Pumpkin starts are sold by Leif and the Nooklings. Every day, one Spooky item can be bought at Nook's Cranny. You can purchase 1 candy a day at Nook's Cranny. So make sure to buy...

www.belltreeforums.com

 

[moonshi]

Yeah I just stopped because I was getting repeats of his robe and face mask.

 

[DragonAceSg7]

Check the first post of this thread:

🎃🎃🎃 HALLOWEEN SEASON begins! 🎃🎃🎃

🎃 It's October 1st and that means it's SPOOKY SEASON again. Jack's Poster should be mailed to you on October 1st. Pumpkin starts are sold by Leif and the Nooklings. Every day, one Spooky item can be bought at Nook's Cranny. You can purchase 1 candy a day at Nook's Cranny. So make sure to buy...

www.belltreeforums.com

I feel dumb for not finding that sooner, thank you. Though I'm still super short on DIYs

 

[VanitasFan26]

All Jack gives you are the following items:
1. Spooky Carriage or DIY
2. Spooky Wand or DIY
3. Jack's Face
4. Jack's Rob

There really hasn't been anything new added to Jack from last year.