Mafia DA:I Mafia

[oath2order]

Ok get ready for me spending half an hour doing this cause that's how long it takes me, let me just put some good music on lmao

- - - Post Merge - - -

So uh this is gonna take forever but meh reads! Gonna try and make it detailed as possible

Trojan- basically jumping on the bandwagon but super sketchy, either doesn't care at all or is Mafia. Or both, or he could just be trolling
Sarsakat- Not really suspicious of you but haven't town read you yet
Call me Daniel- kinda suspicious. But generally your cool
Pushreen the cat- Mahbe like when I played, a newbie is siding up with a pro

As labelle said, she's doing nothing, maybe trying to avoid suspicion?
Dad- I'm suspicious of you because... Well nothing just my heart or something. Just you personality is too townie or something
Panda1376- not sure yet
Labellefleur- not sure
Capella- town read because they are getting mod killed and obviously would play more if Mafia
Ashtot- kinda suspect because the attitude

Blaming it on others to town read you? Hmm
Oath2order- is a one shot vig


Another idea! We were suspect of Tom, so maybe two noob mafias? Why else would you kill of a suspect

Eh? Where'd you get this?

- - - Post Merge - - -

You sure you aren't thinking of Ender?

it's an old mafia joke

 

[Ashtot]

it's an old mafia joke

dang these whippersnappers using our memes all the time

 

[Geoni]

no they're the kind that join a game and every time they do nothing regardless of their alignment or role

This. : |

Which is why it's always worse when she's mafia. She's the only person in tbt history for all I know to have a solo third party win, which is not an easy thing to do although it was nub mafia. But yeah, I don't get why she can pull off stuff like that but then go lazy in most cases.

 

[N e s s]

She won as 3rd party? Dang...

Also what are 3rd party roles? I only know 2 but dunno what they do...

 

[oath2order]

She won as 3rd party? Dang...

Also what are 3rd party roles? I only know 2 but dunno what they do...

They have differing win conditions than town.

They could be an entirely different team (XCOM, The Apocalypse), a Survivor (survive til the end. Dark Lord Ascending, Person of Interest et al), Serial Killer (kill everybody. There and Back Again, Siren's Call, et al), or a cult (Honno-ji Incident, Mean Girls, et al)

 

[Geoni]

Also, I'm starting to get slightly suspicious of Oath. I'm trying to develop some reads today and before I even began I had the thought that the only people in this game who I think would truly worry about Tom because of previous experience with him is me, Oath, and Ashtot. And I just found that Daniel literally said what I was thinking in reaction to Tom, although I think he missed a person. But yeah, Oath knows Tom knows him decently, I know Tom knows me decently due to us being scum together twice at least (maybe more, I can't remember), and Ashtot just in general has a large tbt mafia history and played lots of games with Tom.

And then he sort of bandwagoned the Daniel and EnderWiggen votes although he seemed to provide reason as to why he agreed with these wagons. Both of these wagons were kiiinda mine (although LaBelle was really the one to throw her vote on him fiercely). But I can't discount the possibility that he could have been joining me on my leading to a mislynch.

These are just some things I have to point out, but I had been townreading him for a while and still partially do due to the way he's sort of posting like he's testing the waters and bouncing questions around like a townie would.

I'm also feeling slightly iffy about LaBelleFleur again but I'll go into that later. I need to stop devoting so much time to mafia when I'm wrong half the time.

So that's one of the reasons I'm feeling funny about Oath.

Second reason is all this doubt he's creating with all of the setup questions he has been bringing up in the past day. Trojan admits he's mafia, what I consider an emotional slip, and Oath is the only person who doubted it and brought up worries of a third party or there being two vigilantes or even weirder, a jester. I'm pretty sure like...the only host on tbt who would every be bold enough to put a jester in their game would be Superpenguin. I know Oath has seen a lot of games and probably enjoys thinking about setups and unique roles being included in games though. But still, I don't see how he can't take that at face value. Second reason I feel iffy about Oath.

- - - Post Merge - - -

Omg those paragraphs are all mixed up.

 

[oath2order]

Also, I'm starting to get slightly suspicious of Oath. I'm trying to develop some reads today and before I even began I had the thought that the only people in this game who I think would truly worry about Tom because of previous experience with him is me, Oath, and Ashtot. And I just found that Daniel literally said what I was thinking in reaction to Tom, although I think he missed a person. But yeah, Oath knows Tom knows him decently, I know Tom knows me decently due to us being scum together twice at least (maybe more, I can't remember), and Ashtot just in general has a large tbt mafia history and played lots of games with Tom.

And then he sort of bandwagoned the Daniel and EnderWiggen votes although he seemed to provide reason as to why he agreed with these wagons. Both of these wagons were kiiinda mine (although LaBelle was really the one to throw her vote on him fiercely). But I can't discount the possibility that he could have been joining me on my leading to a mislynch.

These are just some things I have to point out, but I had been townreading him for a while and still partially do due to the way he's sort of posting like he's testing the waters and bouncing questions around like a townie would.

I'm also feeling slightly iffy about LaBelleFleur again but I'll go into that later. I need to stop devoting so much time to mafia when I'm wrong half the time.

So that's one of the reasons I'm feeling funny about Oath.

Second reason is all this doubt he's creating with all of the setup questions he has been bringing up in the past day. Trojan admits he's mafia, what I consider an emotional slip, and Oath is the only person who doubted it and brought up worries of a third party or there being two vigilantes or even weirder, a jester. I'm pretty sure like...the only host on tbt who would every be bold enough to put a jester in their game would be Superpenguin. I know Oath has seen a lot of games and probably enjoys thinking about setups and unique roles being included in games though. But still, I don't see how he can't take that at face value. Second reason I feel iffy about Oath.

- - - Post Merge - - -

Omg those paragraphs are all mixed up.

I'm sorry, how is it weird that I'm suspicious that someone would just admit to being mafia

 

[Dinosaurz]

You don't have enough experience with Capella to be saying that. She's very much the kind of mafia team member to sit on the sidelines and wait to post and vote until the modkill threat is there. Then again, she's also lazy as hell as town too. But yeah, don't townread her on that. The type of mafia who don't disrupt arguments against certain players that might lead to a mislynch are the most difficult ones to deal with in forum mafia. It's basically how SP, Alice, and I won the Portal mafia.

But she's getting mod killed today or something xD

 

[Geoni]

Fixed version:

Also, I'm starting to get slightly suspicious of Oath. I'm trying to develop some reads today and before I even began I had the thought that the only people in this game who I think would truly worry about Tom because of previous experience with him is me, Oath, and Ashtot. And I just found that Daniel literally said what I was thinking in reaction to Tom, although I think he missed a person. But yeah, Oath knows Tom knows him decently, I know Tom knows me decently due to us being scum together twice at least (maybe more, I can't remember), and Ashtot just in general has a large tbt mafia history and played lots of games with Tom.

So that's one of the reasons I'm feeling funny about Oath.

Second reason is all this doubt he's creating with all of the setup questions he has been bringing up in the past day. Trojan admits he's mafia, what I consider an emotional slip, and Oath is the only person who doubted it and brought up worries of a third party or there being two vigilantes or even weirder, a jester. I'm pretty sure like...the only host on tbt who would every be bold enough to put a jester in their game would be Superpenguin. I know Oath has seen a lot of games and probably enjoys thinking about setups and unique roles being included in games though. But still, I don't see how he can't take that at face value. Second reason I feel iffy about Oath.

And then he sort of bandwagoned the Daniel and EnderWiggen votes although he seemed to provide reason as to why he agreed with these wagons. Both of these wagons were kiiinda mine (although LaBelle was really the one to throw her vote on him fiercely). But I can't discount the possibility that he could have been joining me on my leading to a mislynch.

These are just some things I have to point out, but I had been townreading him for a while and still partially do due to the way he's sort of posting like he's testing the waters and bouncing questions around like a townie would.

I'm also feeling slightly iffy about LaBelleFleur again but I'll go into that later. I need to stop devoting so much time to mafia when I'm wrong half the time.

- - - Post Merge - - -

I'm sorry, how is it weird that I'm suspicious that someone would just admit to being mafia

Because in trying to save his neck he claimed one shot vig, and none of us foresaw that Ender was actually the one-shot vigilante. So essentially he dug his grave deeper when that role flip happened to counterclaim him - which Ender might have done had he had the time to get on before he got lynched, another thing that frustrates me lol. So given this circumstance, it comes off as a little weird that you'd be so doubtful about a mafia admittance that stemmed from claiming vig and the result of Ender's flip. Vig is also a go-to claim if you're mafia and actually do claim something that isn't just townie.

- - - Post Merge - - -

But she's getting mod killed today or something xD

Justice is a troll and the day will still be 48 hours so it's very likely that Capella will at least get a vote in. Then again she really might not and get modkilled lol. If she doesn't even come around to post today now that we're talking about here and there's time left then I'm more prone to believing she's just lazy town.

- - - Post Merge - - -

about her*

 

[Capella]

Hello everyone.....

 

[Geoni]

Hello. Good to see you. We were just talking about why we hate you.

 

[Capella]

I know ;_;

 

[Damniel]

Hello everyone.....

Hello

- - - Post Merge - - -

Also, I'm starting to get slightly suspicious of Oath. I'm trying to develop some reads today and before I even began I had the thought that the only people in this game who I think would truly worry about Tom because of previous experience with him is me, Oath, and Ashtot. And I just found that Daniel literally said what I was thinking in reaction to Tom, although I think he missed a person. But yeah, Oath knows Tom knows him decently, I know Tom knows me decently due to us being scum together twice at least (maybe more, I can't remember), and Ashtot just in general has a large tbt mafia history and played lots of games with Tom.

And then he sort of bandwagoned the Daniel and EnderWiggen votes although he seemed to provide reason as to why he agreed with these wagons. Both of these wagons were kiiinda mine (although LaBelle was really the one to throw her vote on him fiercely). But I can't discount the possibility that he could have been joining me on my leading to a mislynch.

These are just some things I have to point out, but I had been townreading him for a while and still partially do due to the way he's sort of posting like he's testing the waters and bouncing questions around like a townie would.

I'm also feeling slightly iffy about LaBelleFleur again but I'll go into that later. I need to stop devoting so much time to mafia when I'm wrong half the time.

So that's one of the reasons I'm feeling funny about Oath.

Second reason is all this doubt he's creating with all of the setup questions he has been bringing up in the past day. Trojan admits he's mafia, what I consider an emotional slip, and Oath is the only person who doubted it and brought up worries of a third party or there being two vigilantes or even weirder, a jester. I'm pretty sure like...the only host on tbt who would every be bold enough to put a jester in their game would be Superpenguin. I know Oath has seen a lot of games and probably enjoys thinking about setups and unique roles being included in games though. But still, I don't see how he can't take that at face value. Second reason I feel iffy about Oath.

- - - Post Merge - - -

Omg those paragraphs are all mixed up.

What did I say that you agree with?

 

[Geoni]

What did I say that you agree with?

That the players who would worry about Tom being town as mafia because of player history, this bit of a post of yours:

Who could have killed tom?
Well if i believe that it was to kill tom to prevent the risk of him swaying a lynch for them, Tom has had a couple of suspicions
Gonna be busy today, so I don't really have time to look into Daniel or Trojan, but Pusheen's lazy vote for Daniel bugs me a lot especially since they completely ignored my post questioning it and instead when illuminatti 666 on me.
He had suspicious on Pusheen, and when you think about it Pusheen has been acting strange the whole game, not posting alot, yet they have switched their opinions and vote to whoever was getting the most votes, from Me, to Trojan, to Ender clearly Bandwagoning. Seems very suspicious to me and I don't trust it... Especially since Tom was one of the few people who have been suspicious of Pusheen.
So yeah it could also be Oath or Dad because of previous game history but i don't have much evidence on that.

- - - Post Merge - - -

Who those players are, that is.

- - - Post Merge - - -

Aaand now Capella has voted and won't get modkilled. You better be town.

 

[N e s s]

The only person I'm suspicious about right now is pusheen, but I'll talk about that when my sus' list is up.

Also for future reference, why are people suspicious about LaBelle? As far as I've seen she hasn't said anything scummy.

 

[Geoni]

It's still a gut level thing with LaBelle. But she's always town. Always. Part of the gut feeling comes from her ease of jumping on the EnderWiggin wagon and possibly starting the Daniel wagon because you and I in particular had put a lot of criticism on him and made him a logical suspicion target, somebody you can aggressively take a stance on and thus not appear hesitant.

 

[Damniel]

That the players who would worry about Tom being town as mafia because of player history, this bit of a post of yours:



- - - Post Merge - - -

Who those players are, that is.

- - - Post Merge - - -

Aaand now Capella has voted and won't get modkilled. You better be town.

Oh okay, but yeah it would make the most sense why tom was killed.

Oh crap one of my dogs has a tick I gotta go for now.

 

[Geoni]

Oh crap one of my dogs has a tick I gotta go for now.

What to do:

 

[Dinosaurz]

Hello everyone.....

You really are a B

 

[Capella]

You really are a B

Wat...