Eh... Overall disappointed with this game...

Cheerios4u98

Junior Member
Joined
Jun 9, 2007
Posts
7
Bells
1,450
Hey I just remembered this site out of the blue and I've been reading through a ton of threads just randomly hoping to learn a little more about City Folk.

Anyways I just thought I'd vent a little about this game.

I'm a huge AC fan, but overall City Folk is a definite disappointment to me.

One thing I noticed right off the bat when I started playing, is that Nintendo didn't even put the effort into making new overworld music for this game. WW had different music than GC, but CF has the exact same music as WW. I know for a fact it wouldn't have been hard to write 24 new short loops of music for the game. Luckily the music doesn't affect the gameplay, so its not that big of a deal, but it still bugs me.

The neighbors aren't nearly as fun to talk to in this game. In the original, whenever I got bored, I would talk to the neighbors and they would almost always send me on little "quests" to run errands for them. In City Folk, they hardly ever do that, and as a result, I find myself hardly ever talking to them because I don't see a point.

Something I was hoping for in this game, was for Nintendo to bring back some of the things I loved about the original game. The acres, the gyroid outside of your house, and (although I really didn't expect this one) the return of NES games. I'm really glad they at least brought back multiple-level towns, but, like the music, that doesn't really effect gameplay so much. Also, I wish they would have made the grass like it was in the first game; all over the town. I hate the dirt patches, and I especially hate how easy it is to ruin your grass, and how difficult it is to get it to grow back.

I was all excited about the city aspect of this game, but all I've found is that it actually kind of made the game worse (in my opinion). I loved having to look forward to the random Crazy Redd and Katrina appearances in my town. Allowing us to see them every day in the city kind of takes away from the 'specialness' of them. Overall, I don't like the city. There isn't nearly enough to do there.

Anyways, my last complaint, is also my biggest. Just today, I got the basement in my house, and when Nook told me "your house can't get any bigger!" it caught me off guard. Really? Not ANY bigger? Why the huge downgrade from Wild World? This doesn't make any sense to me at all. Why allow us to have a mansion in Wild World, and then go back to the two-room house that we got in the original game? If anything I would have thought we'd be able to get an even bigger house than in Wild World.

I'm hoping for a BIG change in the next Animal Crossing. City Folk is more or less still the same game as the original, which isn't a bad thing at all, but still, I want something new next time. A cool significant change would be to make the entire game set in the city instead of in a small town. That would be cool, and it would definitely be a nice change. Just throwing random ideas out there.


Well, that's about it. Just felt like complaining. I know that probably none of you even know who I am, and I don't think I know any of you, but I just had the urge to say all that. Haha okay I'm done. Thanks for putting up with this ridiculously long post.

-Cheerios
 
Nikoking said:
Thank you for actually being mature about hating it.
Sorry if I wasn't clear. I still love this game, but I was expecting a lot more out of it.

I spend hours a day on this game if I can :p
 
i think it's nice to see someone else that can actually have a mature about an argument instead of just spamming "it sucks it sucks it sucks it sucks it needs to be changed it needs to be changed it needs to be changed omg it suck omg it sucks omg it sucks" over and over and over...

i agree with everything you said except for the grass part. i actually like the trails you can make, although i would tone down the rate at how much grass deteriorates by stepping on it... ugh.
 
Nedrian said:
i think it's nice to see someone else that can actually have a mature about an argument instead of just spamming "it sucks it sucks it sucks it sucks it needs to be changed it needs to be changed it needs to be changed omg it suck omg it sucks omg it sucks" over and over and over...

i agree with everything you said except for the grass part. i actually like the trails you can make, although i would tone down the rate at how much grass deteriorates by stepping on it... ugh.
Yeah I guess the trails are actually kind of cool, but my town is so full of dirt :p It looks horrible. Haha.
 
I hated the acre system, it was so annoying.

While they did rehash the WW music, they revamped it a little and sounds pretty on stereo :3

The gyroid outside the house was meh. Never noticed it.

The house? I'm glad they made it smaller. I'm more of a closed space person, so once again, meh.

The city is okay, i really like kicks, harriet and the sea otter/walrus.

The game had much potential, but you have to under stand this:

WW didn't make it to many AC fans. For most, it went from GC to Wii directly. It's because most didnt have a DS. And Nintendo knew it.
 
erhmm idk cuz the ppl who have been playing this game since the GC will appear as a fail but as for meh that im new to the series its just full of epicness well i think thats for ALL new people of animal crossing seires so its just an awesome game :p
 
xYoh said:
erhmm idk cuz the ppl who have been playing this game since the GC will appear as a fail but as for meh that im new to the series its just full of epicness well i think thats for ALL new people of animal crossing seires so its just an awesome game :p
Oh definitely. If City Folk would have been the first Animal Crossing game I'd ever played, I'd have nothing to complain about.
 
And, like I said, it's an epic win if the only other one you had was GC, not WW.

I guess I can sympathize with Nintendo. (Pile it on, dun hurt me.)
 
Cheerios4u98 said:
Anyways, my last complaint, is also my biggest. Just today, I got the basement in my house, and when Nook told me "your house can't get any bigger!" it caught me off guard. Really? Not ANY bigger? Why the huge downgrade from Wild World? This doesn't make any sense to me at all. Why allow us to have a mansion in Wild World, and then go back to the two-room house that we got in the original game? If anything I would have thought we'd be able to get an even bigger house than in Wild World.
The reason the Wild World house was so big is because all four players had to share the one house. In City Folk there is one house for each player, so the houses don't need to be as big.

I actually prefer having four smaller houses than one big one.
 
I agree. They could have done SO much more with this game, but the fact is they didn't. I also didn't like how they recycled the music.(even though I really do like the WW music) I personally would have been fine with 2-3 GC songs, 3-4 new songs, and the rest WW music, but they didn't do it that way. There were some small things that they added that I really loved(for example, being able to design the back and sleeves of a shirt) but small things don't make a game, and the only big thing they really added was the city and that was kind of a disappointment. Over all I pretty much agree with you. ^^ Yay for logical and mature opinions that aren't flame!
 
Kinda random question here, but is there even a point in paying off my basement? :p

I'm thinking I'll just give all my money to the town fund instead of paying off my mortgage...
 
Nedrian said:
i think it's nice to see someone else that can actually have a mature about an argument instead of just spamming "it sucks it sucks it sucks it sucks it needs to be changed it needs to be changed it needs to be changed omg it suck omg it sucks omg it sucks" over and over and over...

i agree with everything you said except for the grass part. i actually like the trails you can make, although i would tone down the rate at how much grass deteriorates by stepping on it... ugh.
different towns have different trampling rates. mine doesn't trample that fast.
 
im new 2 the animal crossing series so im kinda glad i am new 2 the series after all who likes a wrecked series (not saying tht this is wrecked well......i dunno)
 
Back
Top