hALP! I can't decide what villagers to pick TT^TT

[Rio_]

I don't know if anyone will actually read this 50000000 word post, and normally I wouldn't ask for help deciding this sort of the thing, but I truly can't make up my mind also i need spores

I have 5 of my 10 villagers set in stone, but I'm having trouble with the rest. My island theme is Christmas European Citycore. There will also be a huge castle build, and the symbol of the island is a crow (along with a bunch of general bird imagery). I'm looking to choose villagers that fit at least one of those themes... or just ones that I really like I've narrowed it down to 13, but that's still a lot to decide between >.<

There are some additional factors that further complicate matters:

-I want one of each personality type
-I don't want to repeat any species (except Bob & Purrl)
-Bob & Purrl are a package deal- either both of them or neither of them will be on the island
-If I don't choose the following villagers, I will have them on my second island (but then I'll have less space for other villagers over there): Sasha, Raymond, Agnes, Bob & Purrl

If anyone has any input about any of these villagers please do share ;w;

Peppies (1 or both)

Piper- Fits the bird theme and is snow coloured
Truffles- I love her also her favourite colours are Red and Green so she must love Toy Day!

Snooties (1)

Purrl- I feel like she fits the vibes. Also she's in my top 5 favourite villagers.
Queenie- Bird and also regal
Timbra- She reminds me of a pine tree. That's about it lol

Sisterlys (1)

Flo- Very winter-y, but I'd have to give up Roald
Agnes- Doesn't fit any theme, but she's in my top 5 favourite villagers. But I'd have to give up Truffles.
Muffy- Not winter-y, but very elegant
Reneigh- A one-horse open sleigh?

Doubled up Personalities (1 or 2)

Sasha- Doesn't really fit any of the themes, but for some reason, I feel like he could be a winter villager maybe. Also I just really want him on an island.
Raymond- He can be an Aristocat lol
Roald- Obvious winter villager also I love him he's so goofy
Bob- He's just here to support Purrl. Also he's my favourite villager ever.

 

[jadetine]

Agnes is unskippable — she should be in every town in every world on every island!

 

[VulpineVengeance]

I love Purrl, so I'm biased but I think she'd be a good choice! Or Agnes

 

[Dunquixote]

I don't know if anyone will actually read this 50000000 word post, and normally I wouldn't ask for help deciding this sort of the thing, but I truly can't make up my mind also i need spores

I have 5 of my 10 villagers set in stone, but I'm having trouble with the rest. My island theme is Christmas European Citycore. There will also be a huge castle build, and the symbol of the island is a crow (along with a bunch of general bird imagery). I'm looking to choose villagers that fit at least one of those themes... or just ones that I really like I've narrowed it down to 13, but that's still a lot to decide between >.<

There are some additional factors that further complicate matters:

-I want one of each personality type
-I don't want to repeat any species (except Bob & Purrl)
-Bob & Purrl are a package deal- either both of them or neither of them will be on the island
-If I don't choose the following villagers, I will have them on my second island (but then I'll have less space for other villagers over there): Sasha, Raymond, Agnes, Bob & Purrl

If anyone has any input about any of these villagers please do share ;w;

View attachment 589040​

Peppies (1 or both)

Piper- Fits the bird theme and is snow coloured
Truffles- I love her also her favourite colours are Red and Green so she must love Toy Day!

Snooties (1)

Purrl- I feel like she fits the vibes. Also she's in my top 5 favourite villagers.
Queenie- Bird and also regal
Timbra- She reminds me of a pine tree. That's about it lol

Sisterlys (1)

Flo- Very winter-y, but I'd have to give up Roald
Agnes- Doesn't fit any theme, but she's in my top 5 favourite villagers. But I'd have to give up Truffles.
Muffy- Not winter-y, but very elegant
Reneigh- A one-horse open sleigh?

Doubled up Personalities (1 or 2)

Sasha- Doesn't really fit any of the themes, but for some reason, I feel like he could be a winter villager maybe. Also I just really want him on an island.
Raymond- He can be an Aristocat lol
Roald- Obvious winter villager also I love him he's so goofy
Bob- He's just here to support Purrl. Also he's my favourite villager ever.

I vouch for Raymond as an Aristocat . He’s kinda one on mine. My island was inspired by Dragon Age so it is a bit medieval & European. I personally feel like he vibes very well. Then again, I’m bias since I love him so much regardless . In my island journal, I assigned him the role as treasurer and so he fits nicely.

If you feel Purrl fits the vibes, I’d say definitely go for her & Bob . Since you know more of what kind of island you want and vibes that you’re going for, I say trust your gut and go with who you think would work best. Like I suggested Raymond but the vibes I got from him might not be what you’re looking for.

With that said, here’s more of my opinions:

I think Muffy and Reneigh could go well at least with the European citycore part of your theme; less so with the Christmas. Reneigh might honestly work more than Muffy because horses were used for carriages and her color is nothing unusual).

Peppies: I’d pick piper for her color; also just preference over the two. But if you love Truffles more, I say go for her unless you are trying to not decide based on how much you like a villager.

Snooties: I already said purrl, but Queenie might be a good choice too, though her colors might not be the best if you’re aiming to stick with winter/christmasy colors. Not sure about Timbra; her colors seem like they’d go with a woodsy area maybe.

Lazies: Bob since you want Purrl together. I think Sasha would go well too! The colors seem appropriate for a winter setting .

Jock: Roald would work great!

I hope that helps a little

 

[Rio_]

I vouch for Raymond as an Aristocat . He’s kinda one on mine. My island was inspired by Dragon Age so it is a bit medieval & European. I personally feel like he vibes very well. Then again, I’m bias since I love him so much regardless . In my island journal, I assigned him the role as treasurer and so he fits nicely.

If you feel Purrl fits the vibes, I’d say definitely go for her & Bob . Since you know more of what kind of island you want and vibes that you’re going for, I say trust your gut and go with who you think would work best. Like I suggested Raymond but the vibes I got from him might not be what you’re looking for.

With that said, here’s more of my opinions:

I think Muffy and Reneigh could go well at least with the European citycore part of your theme; less so with the Christmas. Reneigh might honestly work more than Muffy because horses were used for carriages and her color is nothing unusual).

Peppies: I’d pick piper for her color; also just preference over the two. But if you love Truffles more, I say go for her unless you are trying to not decide based on how much you like a villager.

Snooties: I already said purrl, but Queenie might be a good choice too, though her colors might not be the best if you’re aiming to stick with winter/christmasy colors. Not sure about Timbra; her colors seem like they’d go with a woodsy area maybe.

Lazies: Bob since you want Purrl together. I think Sasha would go well too! The colors seem appropriate for a winter setting .

Jock: Roald would work great!

I hope that helps a little

Thank you so much for all the feedback!

I definitely feel like Raymond fits the vibe! …but then Purrl also fits the vibe DX …but then Bob doesn’t fit the vibe I definitely made things harder on myself by insisting Bob and Purrl stick together lol

Right now, I’m leaning towards Raymond since Bob feels much better suited for my future second island (a year-round, colourful towncore; the villagers for that one are just: “anything goes!”). But that means I’d have to choose a different snooty and I’m unsure about both Queenie and Timbra I wish I could just have them visit and walk around the island to how well they fit in

I guess I could just scrap my snooty plans entirely and go with one that totally fits the theme like Diana or Whitney or Blanche… But I dunno, for some reason, I’m just not feeling them (though it’d make things so much easier if I did)

And thank you for all the other input too! (I’m glad I’m not completely delusional for thinking Sasha could be winter-y XD)