How it my sig?

[quincify]

I know it's not my best, but I am really trying to get better at making sigs! So be honest and tell me what is good and what isn't!

 

[Bacon Boy]

I know it's not my best, but I am really trying to get better at making sigs! So be honest and tell me what is good and what isn't!

Render s kinda weird. It doesn't flow too much. The orange glow in the top left corner doesn't fit. The blurred lines are just unneeded. Text doesn't really match, and the border could be lighter. But I'd have to say it's OK.

 

[quincify]

I know it's not my best, but I am really trying to get better at making sigs! So be honest and tell me what is good and what isn't!

Render s kinda weird. It doesn't flow too much. The orange glow in the top left corner doesn't fit. The blurred lines are just unneeded. Text doesn't really match, and the border could be lighter. But I'd have to say it's OK.

Haha, I just picked some random render, but thanks for the help!

 

[quincify]

<big>Version #1</big>

OR

<big>Version #2</big>

 

[Bacon Boy]

Two is the best, but still could use some work. The white between his hair and neck and the fact that his neck is missing messes it up.

 

[NikoKing]

The render is poorly rendered. The brushes are obvious. The border is a bit cheap, hard edge borders are usually the best. The text needs a lot of improvement, and the flow doesn't support the render's direction. 6/10.

 

[quincify]

The render is poorly rendered. The brushes are obvious. The border is a bit cheap, hard edge borders are usually the best. The text needs a lot of improvement, and the flow doesn't support the render's direction. 6/10.

I didn't use brushes thank you very much

 

[NikoKing]

The render is poorly rendered. The brushes are obvious. The border is a bit cheap, hard edge borders are usually the best. The text needs a lot of improvement, and the flow doesn't support the render's direction. 6/10.

I didn't use brushes thank you very much

Sorry, it looked like it <_< .

Also, it's got a weird screen effect on the signature, giving it a "transparent" feel which usually is bad in most signatures, like this one. Also, this signature feels like it needs lighting, that would really help improve it if you know how to place the lighting.

 

[Palad][n]

people are too picky in my opinion. Looks good

By the way, did you draw some of it then edit it?

Or just took some pics off of the web?

i never know how people design siggys.

I wish i could

 

[quincify]

The render is poorly rendered. The brushes are obvious. The border is a bit cheap, hard edge borders are usually the best. The text needs a lot of improvement, and the flow doesn't support the render's direction. 6/10.

I didn't use brushes thank you very much

Sorry, it looked like it <_< .

Also, it's got a weird screen effect on the signature, giving it a "transparent" feel which usually is bad in most signatures, like this one. Also, this signature feels like it needs lighting, that would really help improve it if you know how to place the lighting.

How does it "feel transparent"?

 

[NikoKing]

people are too picky in my opinion.

It's called giving the honest truth about the signature, it helps improve your bad sig making skills on something and make them better. Of course, it makes me act like a rooster because I tend to say it in a rude way, but I never mean to be rude.

 

[quincify]

[n,Nov 6 2009, 09:48:11 PM]people are too picky in my opinion. Looks good

By the way, did you draw some of it then edit it?

Or just took some pics off of the web?

i never know how people design siggys.

I wish i could

Haha I know >.>

And, no I can't draw to save my life!

 

[NikoKing]

The render is poorly rendered. The brushes are obvious. The border is a bit cheap, hard edge borders are usually the best. The text needs a lot of improvement, and the flow doesn't support the render's direction. 6/10.

I didn't use brushes thank you very much

Sorry, it looked like it <_< .

Also, it's got a weird screen effect on the signature, giving it a "transparent" feel which usually is bad in most signatures, like this one. Also, this signature feels like it needs lighting, that would really help improve it if you know how to place the lighting.

How does it "feel transparent"?

Nearby the render, notice that white block nearby it? That feels transparent or it could be a multiply block.

 

[quincify]

[n,Nov 6 2009, 09:48:11 PM]people are too picky in my opinion. Looks good<br /><br />By the way, did you draw some of it then edit it?<br /><br />Or just took some pics off of the web?<br /><br />i never know how people design siggys.<br /><br />I wish i could

Haha I know >.>

And, no I can't draw to save my life!

 

[Palad][n]

The render is poorly rendered. The brushes are obvious. The border is a bit cheap, hard edge borders are usually the best. The text needs a lot of improvement, and the flow doesn't support the render's direction. 6/10.

I didn't use brushes thank you very much

Sorry, it looked like it <_< .

Also, it's got a weird screen effect on the signature, giving it a "transparent" feel which usually is bad in most signatures, like this one. Also, this signature feels like it needs lighting, that would really help improve it if you know how to place the lighting.

How does it "feel transparent"?

Well your character kinda blends in with the background.
They both look kinda blue

But i still think it looks really good.

 

[NikoKing]

[n,Nov 6 2009, 09:48:11 PM]people are too picky in my opinion. Looks good<br /><br />By the way, did you draw some of it then edit it?<br /><br />Or just took some pics off of the web?<br /><br />i never know how people design siggys.<br /><br />I wish i could

Haha I know >.>

And, no I can't draw to save my life!

I'm not being picky at all, I'm giving concrit. Comparing my concrit to a serious GFX forum (which are typical jackasses), you're better off getting it by me.

 

[quincify]

[n,Nov 6 2009, 09:48:11 PM]people are too picky in my opinion. Looks good<br /><br />By the way, did you draw some of it then edit it?<br /><br />Or just took some pics off of the web?<br /><br />i never know how people design siggys.<br /><br />I wish i could

Haha I know >.>

And, no I can't draw to save my life!

I'm not being picky at all, I'm giving concrit. Comparing my concrit to a serious GFX forum (which are typical jackasses), you're better off getting it by me.

I never said you were being picky, I like how you tell me what to fix. I'm dead serious.

 

[NikoKing]

[n,Nov 6 2009, 09:48:11 PM]people are too picky in my opinion. Looks good<br /><br />By the way, did you draw some of it then edit it?<br /><br />Or just took some pics off of the web?<br /><br />i never know how people design siggys.<br /><br />I wish i could

Haha I know >.>

And, no I can't draw to save my life!

I'm not being picky at all, I'm giving concrit. Comparing my concrit to a serious GFX forum (which are typical jackasses), you're better off getting it by me.

I never said you were being picky, I like how you tell me what to fix. I'm dead serious.

Ah... okay. If I acted like a rooster in a way, then I apoligize. Sometimes when I give concrit I tend to be rude :S .

 

[Palad][n]

[n,Nov 6 2009, 09:48:11 PM]people are too picky in my opinion. Looks good<br /><br />By the way, did you draw some of it then edit it?<br /><br />Or just took some pics off of the web?<br /><br />i never know how people design siggys.<br /><br />I wish i could

Haha I know >.>

And, no I can't draw to save my life!

I'm not being picky at all, I'm giving concrit. Comparing my concrit to a serious GFX forum (which are typical jackasses), you're better off getting it by me.

I never said you were being picky, I like how you tell me what to fix. I'm dead serious.

I think he wants you to bolden the outline of the guy so he would stand out of the background. That would look good

 

[quincify]

[n,Nov 6 2009, 09:48:11 PM]people are too picky in my opinion. Looks good<br /><br />By the way, did you draw some of it then edit it?<br /><br />Or just took some pics off of the web?<br /><br />i never know how people design siggys.<br /><br />I wish i could

Haha I know >.>

And, no I can't draw to save my life!

I'm not being picky at all, I'm giving concrit. Comparing my concrit to a serious GFX forum (which are typical jackasses), you're better off getting it by me.

I never said you were being picky, I like how you tell me what to fix. I'm dead serious.

Ah... okay. If I acted like a rooster in a way, then I apoligize. Sometimes when I give concrit I tend to be rude :S .

Haha, no problem. I can get the same way.