IGN Gives TP a 9.5

[Bulerias]

IGN's ONLY gripes are lack of voice acting and lack of orchestrated music... And that the graphics are basically the same as the GCN ones.

http://wii.ign.com/articles/746/746691p2.html

I'm really glad about this... Although I thought they'd give it a 10, but yeah...

 

[Jeremy]

I think we can get our 10 with SSBB.

 

[Grawr]

What was a game that IGN rated a ten? Yeah, TP got the same score as Elite Beat. But Twilight Princess'll be much better, ofcourse.

 

[Bulerias]

I think we can get our 10 with SSBB.

Never, believe me. The game will feature a horrible online play system, and that will definitely not give us a ten.

 

[Sporge27]

Ocarina of time for one....right? I think it was....
and elite beat agents does seem fun....

 

[Sporge27]

I think we can get our 10 with SSBB.

Never, believe me. The game will feature a horrible online play system, and that will definitely not give us a ten.

I don't know.... online has yet to be a killing thing in reviews, as long as the multiplayer is as good as SSBM it should be over a nine...

now wait a minute wh did I read IGN geve TP a 10 somewhere....I should have checked the actual site.

 

[Bulerias]

The weird thing is that Matt called TP his favorite Zelda game ever, the best launch title ever, and one of the best games he's ever played, but gave TP a 9.5 all the same. I think if Matt reviewed Ocarina of Time back in the day, he would have given it a 9.5 or lower. That's just me though. I think Matt's against giving games perfect scores.

 

[Bulerias]

I think we can get our 10 with SSBB.

Never, believe me. The game will feature a horrible online play system, and that will definitely not give us a ten.

I don't know.... online has yet to be a killing thing in reviews, as long as the multiplayer is as good as SSBM it should be over a nine...

now wait a minute wh did I read IGN geve TP a 10 somewhere....I should have checked the actual site.

For a game that's built around the multiplayer experience, online WILL INDEED be the killing thing. Sakurai himself said online for SSBB will be "bare bones, at best", so we will definitely not get a 10/10 for SSBB.

 

[Sporge27]

Now on IGN how is the 9.5 rating there? it isn't a combination of the press reviews and reader reviews is it? because people are at an average rating of 9.2 while the pree is at 9.7 .....

 

[Bulerias]

Now on IGN how is the 9.5 rating there? it isn't a combination of the press reviews and reader reviews is it? because people are at an average rating of 9.2 while the pree is at 9.7 .....

What the heck are you talking about? TP always had a 9.5 on IGN. It's not the combination of press and user reviews...

 

[Sporge27]

Now on IGN how is the 9.5 rating there? it isn't a combination of the press reviews and reader reviews is it? because people are at an average rating of 9.2 while the pree is at 9.7 .....

What the heck are you talking about? TP always had a 9.5 on IGN. It's not the combination of press and user reviews...

Hey I'm no expert on how sites rate things, that is why I ask when I see a correlation between that sort of thing.

 

[Jeremy]

I think we can get our 10 with SSBB.

Never, believe me. The game will feature a horrible online play system, and that will definitely not give us a ten.

You have no way of knowing this. SSBB will probably be a better game than TP, which was made for the GCN.

 

[Jeremy]

Here is a list of TP reviews:
http://www.gamestats.com/objects/748/748589//articles.html

As you can see, GameSpot gave it the lowest and IGN gave it second lowest (unless you count the one out of 5). Most of the websites gave it a 10.

 

[SL92]

*gives up going to IGN* What did NP give it? Or did you not get ti yet?

 

[Bulerias]

I think we can get our 10 with SSBB.

Never, believe me. The game will feature a horrible online play system, and that will definitely not give us a ten.

You have no way of knowing this. SSBB will probably be a better game than TP, which was made for the GCN.

No way of knowing? Sakurai already confirmed it. :\

 

[Jeremy]

I think we can get our 10 with SSBB.

Never, believe me. The game will feature a horrible online play system, and that will definitely not give us a ten.

You have no way of knowing this. SSBB will probably be a better game than TP, which was made for the GCN.

No way of knowing? Sakurai already confirmed it. :\

So you're saying he said the online play for the game wasn't good? Yah right...

 

[Bulerias]

I think we can get our 10 with SSBB.

Never, believe me. The game will feature a horrible online play system, and that will definitely not give us a ten.

You have no way of knowing this. SSBB will probably be a better game than TP, which was made for the GCN.

No way of knowing? Sakurai already confirmed it. :\

So you're saying he said the online play for the game wasn't good? Yah right...

He said the online play would be "bare bones, at best".

Source

 

[Bulerias]

Although online play was announced over a year ago, Sakurai admits he isn

 

[Jeremy]

He says it's simple, not bad.

 

[Bulerias]

He says it's simple, not bad.

Simple = bad
Complicated and in-depth = good

It's like MKDS's online and MPH's online. MKDS was extremely limited online, and MPH had voice chat, etc etc...