My brother has the same thing!
I got merengue marina fang shep from him
All he gets is cute villager move ins and I always get the ugliest villagers cough cough barold
I remember that in my previous save file I kept getting Marshal in my campsite and being really pissed because I never gave a damn about him, but at the same time I knew there were people out there who would cry their teeth out over my "luck".
And I was like dammit Marshall, could you please stop bothering me and let me get MY dreamies? There's tons of mayors out there who would kill to have you in their village, dammit.
....and this is why in my mind Marshall will always be a pesky little troll XD he even has that cute troublemaker's expression so... XD