Made my first signature! Any thoughts?

[superkell]

I made my first few signatures and I wanted some feedback! If they're good I was considering starting to do commissions...here are the first 2 I made! Please let me know what you think \(^-^)/

(most people are saying this one is a bit over-cluttered, which I agree with)

(on this one it bothers me how the border/outline isn't completely smooth, so if anyone knows how to fix that that'd be great!)

(I can't take credit for either of the backgrounds) :3
​

​

​

 

[Avaneeh]

They are gorgeous!! So pretty ;w;

 

[superkell]

Wow, thank you! That's so sweet :3

 

[June]

the first one's a bit cluttered, but i suppose it gets the message across well enough ; v ; and a lot of other sigs look that way too. the 2nd one is very nice though!! personally, i'm not a fan of signatures that are shaped that way but the spacing is really good and the colors go well together so it's easy on the eyes

pretty sure you're good to go w/ commissions !!

good luck if you decide to do so

 

[superkell]

the first one's a bit cluttered, but i suppose it gets the message across well enough ; v ; and a lot of other sigs look that way too. the 2nd one is very nice though!! personally, i'm not a fan of signatures that are shaped that way but the spacing is really good and the colors go well together so it's easy on the eyes

pretty sure you're good to go w/ commissions !!

good luck if you decide to do so

Thank you! I definitely agree with the cluttered-ness, I was wanting something bright and sunny for a background though, which is why I chose it. I couldn't decide between which style I preferred, but I realized there's a TON of options/variety out there for the style. Thanks so much for your input!!! ^-^

 

[himeki]

Wow, the seccond one is beautiul! Keep it up!

 

[superkell]

Wow, the seccond one is beautiul! Keep it up!

Thank you so much! ^-^

 

[Jamborenium]

those are really good for your first time, the second one really sticks out to me it's quite lovely I say

 

[Liseli]

The second one is so beautiful! >w<. I'd definitely buy a signature if I could, heh.

 

[creamyy]

I think it's good and it's quite cute, but the first one is a little cluttered.
I don't think it's necessary to include other fruit in your town if you've already included which is your native fruit.
Also, Neither do I think it's necessary to include both residents and dreamies as it makes the the signature appear crowded.
Signatures have around 10 villagers on them to keep it simple and that's usually the dreamies and not the ones you have in your town at the moment.
BUT, I think for your first time, it looks absolutely amazing. Great job.
I also made my first signature today too! Yay.

 

[Andi]

I think they are super cute!

 

[allykitty]

The second one is breathtaking! Love the fonts you used- particularly the mini fonts I definitely suggest taking commissions !

 

[MOON TRIPS]

I think the small font is hard to read, but that might just be me. :I I do have a problem with reading a lot of those tiny fonts. anyway...
otherwise, lovely work! I like those animated background signatures, but I also like my simple one that I made myself.

 

[Coach]

I really like how the first one has the villagers holding the ice creams!

 

[Mints]

Those are pretty good, im kinda jealous of your skills haha. I really liked how you faded out the background for the second one. Very pretty!

 

[superkell]

I think it's good and it's quite cute, but the first one is a little cluttered.
I don't think it's necessary to include other fruit in your town if you've already included which is your native fruit.
Also, Neither do I think it's necessary to include both residents and dreamies as it makes the the signature appear crowded.
Signatures have around 10 villagers on them to keep it simple and that's usually the dreamies and not the ones you have in your town at the moment.
BUT, I think for your first time, it looks absolutely amazing. Great job.
I also made my first signature today too! Yay.

Thanks so much, your feedback was really helpful! I was trying to figure out the standard stuff people included..to me residents makes more sense than dreamies but I think most people feel the opposite. Do people ever do dreamies and residents?

Anyways, I tried my hand at another signature!:

- - - Post Merge - - -

I didn't realize how many replies this had at first, thank you everyone so much for your feedback! It's all been very helpful and informative!