*is gonna play the part of Jas0n.
Guys, how's he gonna get better if you say it's pretty good for his first sig? it's not very good and he knows it. The light is cut off and a line breaks between that and the rest of the sig. He either took the render with t he light from another area in gimp/photoshop and compress the two image, which is why the Scizor layer is boxed in, or he just made it that way. the font doesn't mix well, the lighting on Scizor looks poor, and the background looks a bit dull. Also, there is no border.
Okay, there are extreme cases in which you can rate a sig, but more than half of the time, first sigs suck, hell, you should've seen mine. The best thing to do is give criticism or tutorials, if it sucks, tell him it sucks, don't say it's nice and try to make his self-esteem higher.