Need help in choosing new villagers!

[Zen]

Hello! I want to cycle out some of my villagers and I need help choosing new ones!

Here are my villagers:

Bluebear*
Cranston*
Filbert*
Raymond*
Dom*
^^ these ones are staying for now

Olivia - I would love a new snooty to replace her. She's the best, but I wish for her to see the world. I was thinking Whitney?

Kiki - She has been with me since the GC days and I would be sad to see her go, but I do have her on my other island as well. I was thinking Poppy?

Roald - I have too many Jocks and I had to choose between Roald and Dom. It's a very difficult decision and i've been reprimanded for my choice, but I made it nonetheless. I have Apollo prepped and ready.

O'Hare - I love his uniqueness and look. He's one of my favorites. Is there a diff tropical-style villager I can replace him with? Preferable with a tropical style looking house.

Judy - She's amazing! I'm debating letting her go. If I can't find a replacement, she will stay


who would be your choices? Do let me know. I'm trying not to have more than 2 of a personality. This game really needs more dialogue variation. (c'mon nintendo! :/ )

 

[Che5hire Cat]

Whitney and Poppy are nice choices there! I might would recommend besides the two Kitty (another snooty cat, very lovely if you ask me and also pretty underrated) and Freckles (peppy duck, such a cutie, also very underrated). For the replacement of O'Hare, the only tropical villagers I can think of right now are Audie (which would perhaps fit to your search for a peppy? She has also a kinda tropical themed house as far as I know) and Bud (has a tropical-ish look, only disadvantage: He's a jock. Also not sure about if his house is tropical themed). Although personally, I would stick with O'Hare, but that's because I find him cool too, lol. Otherwise, Apollo would be a good choice too if you want him move in. I can't really say anything about Judy however, I only met her once while island hopping and didn't invite her, as she's was not a villager I was looking for. She looks quite cute, but that's all I can say about her. Maybe decide spontaneous if you want to let her go? Or just keep her for now if you really like her, you can always let her go some day and find another villager.

And I agree with the dialogue variation, it starts to bother me too here and there.