[Research Thread!] DIY Recipes vs Villager Personalities

[Lady Sugarsaurus]

DIY Recipes vs Villager Personalities

Welcome!

Welcome to the DIY Recipes vs Villager Personalities research thread! It was brought up as a question by shayminskyforme88 as to if different villagers could craft/giveaway all types of DIYs, or if they were personality locked. More than that.. are some DIYs locked, and other open for all villagers? Well, I am here to find out! If you are interested in helping out with the research, please feel free to post in this thread as I will be keeping track in a more manual way. If you would also like to check out shayminskyforme88's thread, you can check it out here: click! Contribute to both, let us know what you are experiencing! It will help us with the data and allow us to come back to the community with a more concrete idea of what this looks like! I thank you all so much in advance!

4/20/2020 update: So it looks like based on the companion guide, this is in fact true. The DIYs are personality locked, but I still want to test a few things! Like do villagers that come in with amiibo cards different? Do the ones on the beach follow the same principals? Plus, it never hurts to compile a list of all the DIYs and what types of villagers will give them out! So the goal chances a bit, but with any good research project you learn and you adapt!

The Goal?

I think the ultimate goal will be to for sure be able to say, 'x' type of villagers craft this DIY. I would like to know, are there more chances for me to get the ironwood set if I have a cranky villager, or will I just need to wait around until my peppy villagers finally decide to give it to me? What it boils down to is figuring out if ANCH takes on the same types of principals that the ACNL villagers had with suggesting things to beautify your town with. The great thing about ACNH though is that we can always travel around with those handy Dodocodes to get the DIYs we may not be able to get ourselves if the theory ends up proving true.

04/20/2020 goal update: So the new goal, is to not only compile a list of all the DIYs and what villager types give them out, but I want to still know if the way you get the DIYs has a change on any of these! Do the ones on the beach follow the same principals? How about villagers from amiibo cards? Let's find out!

How you can help!

The biggest thing you can do to help is contribute to the research! Please post in my thread, and of course the other thread I mentioned above with your villagers and what they are handing out! If you can remember others too! If you visit an island to get a DIY, let us know! I want to try and factor in a couple different things at the same time, to see if they have an effect on the numbers as well, so please, fill out the form in the spoiler, and help me complete this!

04/20/2020 update: Teddy345 also has a cool thread that you can contribute to! If you have had an amiibo villager and you remember what they asked for to move in, go check out his thread here: click and tell him what they asked for! I'd be curious to see if these are in any way related to one another!

Spoiler: The Form

DIY Name: Which one did you get?
Villager: Who was crafting it?
Personality type: If you know it!
How you obtained the DIY: On your island? Visiting someone? On the beach?
If your own villager: Were they traded? Naturally spawned? Amiibo card?

The Data!

I will be posting all the data I collect here, so you can keep track of what it is currently looking at! I will keep some data under spoiler tags as to not clutter up the form, and I will be putting some of the data out in the open! If you would like to take a look at it, and tell me how you are interrupting it too, I would love that! I would love to see what other people think, get ideas about or realize.. and I've always been of the mindset that more brains are better than one!
​

DIYs from ANY Villagers: All DIYs coming right from your villager, a generalized list.

Spoiler: A-Z List

Angled Signpost
Lazy - 1

Armor Shoes
Cranky - 1

Bamboo Bench
Normal - 1

Bamboo Flooring
Cranky - 1

Bamboo Partition
Cranky - 1

Bamboo Speaker
Snooty - 1

Cherry Rug
Peppy - 1

Cherry Wall
Peppy - 1
Normal - 1

Classic Library Wall
Normal - 1

Coconut Juice
Snooty - 1

Cutting Board
Normal - 1

Fruit Wreath
Cranky - 1

Garden Wagon
Peppy - 1

Giant Teddy Bear
Peppy - 1

Gold Bars
Snooty - 2

Golden Arrowana Model
Lazy - 1

Golden Dishes
Cranky - 1
Snooty - 1

Golden Dung Beetle Model
Lazy - 1

Golden Casket
Smug - 1

Golden Gears
Smug - 3

Golden Flooring
Smug - 1

Gong
Cranky - 1

Green Grass Skirt
Peppy - 1

Honeycomb Flooring
Jock - 1

Iron Garden Chair
Uchi - 1

Iron Wall Rack
Smug - 1

Ironwood Cupboard
Snooty - 1

Ironwood Low Table
Snooty - 1

Jail Bars
Cranky - 2

Log Dining Table
Cranky - 1

Log Round Table
Peppy - 1

Manga-Library Wall
Peppy - 1

Money Flooring
Snooty - 1

Natural Mum Wreath
Smug - 1

Oil Barrel Bathtub
Jock - 1

Pansy Crown
Smug - 1

Peach Hat
Normal - 1

Peach Surprise Box
Normal - 1

Peach Wall
Normal - 1

Shell Arch
Lazy - 1

Shell Bed
Peppy - 1

Shell Fountain
Lazy - 2

Shell Lamp
Uchi - 1

Shell Speaker
Uchi - 2

Street Piano
Uchi - 1

Terrarium
Normal - 1

Tiny Library
Normal - 1

Wild Log Bench
Jock - 2

Windflower Fan
Lazy - 1

Wooden Low Table
Smug - 1

Wooden Mosaic Wall
Normal - 1

Woodland Wall
Normal - 1

DIYs from Naturally Spawned Villagers: All DIYs coming right from your naturally spawned villager.

Spoiler: A-Z List

Angled Signpost
Lazy - 1

Bamboo Bench
Normal - 1

Bamboo Partition
Cranky - 1

Cherry Rug
Peppy - 1

Cherry Wall
Peppy - 1
Normal - 1

Giant Teddy Bear
Peppy - 1

Gold Bars
Snooty - 1

Golden Casket
Smug - 1

Golden Dishes
Cranky - 1

Green Grass Skirt
Peppy - 1

Honeycomb Flooring
Jock - 1

Iron Garden Chair
Uchi - 1

Ironwood Cupboard
Snooty - 1

Ironwood Low Table
Snooty - 1

Log Round Table
Peppy - 1

Peach Surprise Box
Normal - 1

Shell Arch
Lazy - 1

Shell Fountain
Lazy - 1

Shell Lamp
Uchi - 1

Shell Speaker
Uchi - 2

Street Piano
Uchi - 1

Terrarium
Normal - 1

Tiny Library
Normal - 1

Wild Log Bench
Jock - 2

Windflower Fan
Lazy - 1

Wooden Low Table
Smug - 1

DIYs from Amiibo Villagers: All DIYs coming right from your amiibo card villager.

Spoiler: A-Z List

Cutting Board
Normal - 1

Fruit Wreath
Cranky - 1

Golden Gears
Smug - 1

Jail Bars
Cranky - 1

Money Flooring
Snooty - 1

Woodland Wall
Normal - 1

DIYs from Traded Villagers: All DIYs coming right from your traded villager.

Spoiler: A-Z List

Bamboo Speaker
Snooty - 1

Golden Gears
Smug - 1

Iron Wall Rack
Smug - 1

Jail Bars
Cranky - 1

Manga Library Wall
Peppy - 1

Natural Mum Wreath
Smug - 1

Shell Bed
Peppy - 1

Wooden Mosaic Wall
Normal - 1

DIYs from Bottles on the beach: All DIYs coming picking up a bottle on the beach with a DIY.

Spoiler: A-Z List

Armor Shoes
Cranky - 1

Classic Library Wall
Normal - 1

Golden Dishes
Snooty - 1

Golden Flooring
Smug - 1

Golden Gears
Smug - 1

Log Dining Table
Cranky - 1

Pansy Crown
Smug - 1

Credits!

DIY Recipe Pixel by: Mieiki
Pixel Wing and Rose by: King-Lulu-Deer on DA​

 

[meggiewes]

Well, I know Bruce (cranky) gave me a going DIY recipe yesterday. The only other one I remember is that Poppy (normal) gave me a peach hat and a pear umbrella.

Are you counting amiibo card camper DIYs too? Because Fauna gave me a cutting board the other day.

 

[Sir Zyr]

Let's see...

The only ones I remember off the top of my head came from Ankha (snooty) and they were coconut juice and a gold bars, both from her home (though the coconut juice I also got from her at the campsite)

 

[Lady Sugarsaurus]

Well, I know Bruce (cranky) gave me a going DIY recipe yesterday. The only other one I remember is that Poppy (normal) gave me a peach hat and a pear umbrella.

Are you counting amiibo card camper DIYs too? Because Fauna gave me a cutting board the other day.

Thanks for the input! And yes, I would be counting amiibo card villagers and not just ones that naturally spawn in/are traded!

 

[meggiewes]

Thanks for the input! And yes, I would be counting amiibo card villagers and not just ones that naturally spawn in/are traded!

Awesome. I remember fairly clearly that Velma asked for a mossy garden rock. And Mira asked for a wooden mini table yesterday.

 

[MayorBenjamin]

I have the companion guide and yeah, most DIY recipes are only given out by certain personality types. If there's any recipes you specifically want to know about, I can have a look for you

 

[Lady Sugarsaurus]

I have the companion guide and yeah, most DIY recipes are only given out by certain personality types. If there's any recipes you specifically want to know about, I can have a look for you

Thanks for that! I have updated the top post. haha.
I am still going to keep this open and compile a list, just so that you don't have to sit here and type out every DIY.
Plus i'd like to see if different things factoring into it changes anything.

 

[JKDOS]

I swear my lazies keep giving me fruit DIYS, which I feel are probably as bad as the balloon series in New Leaf, except for the apple set.

 

[Lady Sugarsaurus]

Thank you for all the input while I was working on the thread! Everything is officially up now! I would love if people could use the form and give tell me what their villagers are doing, and what you get from your beaches! Thanks guys!! ^w^

 

[shayminskyforme88]

According to @MayorBenjamin Flower crowns can be crafted by any personality according to the guidebook.

 

[AshdewCrossing]

I'd love to collect data and contribute more, but I got these recently so they're still fresh in memory:

Spoiler: wooden low table

DIY Name: Wooden low table
Villager: Graham
Personality type: Smug
How you obtained the DIY: Visiting a friend
If your own villager: Moved in naturally for the friend

Spoiler: wild log bench

DIY Name: Wild log bench
Villager: Sprocket
Personality type: Jock
How you obtained the DIY: My island
If your own villager: Starter

Spoiler: Iron wall rack

DIY Name: Iron wall rack
Villager: Shep
Personality type: Smug
How you obtained the DIY: My island
If your own villager: Traded

Spoiler: Bamboo speaker

DIY Name: Bamboo speaker
Villager: Diana
Personality type: Snooty
How you obtained the DIY: My island
If your own villager: Traded

 

[shayminskyforme88]

DIY Name: Shell Fountain
Villager: Stitches
Personality type: If you know it!
How you obtained the DIY: Visiting

 

[sicklewillow]

DIY Name: Log Round Table
Villager: Felicity
Personality type: Peppy
How you obtained the DIY: On my island. Felicity is doing DIY
If your own villager: one of first four.

 

[shayminskyforme88]

DIY Name: Wooden Mosaic Wall
Villager: Merengue
Personality type: Normal
How you obtained the DIY: My Island
If your own villager: Traded

DIY Name: Golden Arrowana Model
Villager: Bob
Personality type: Lazy
How you obtained the DIY: Visiting Someone

DIY Name: Golden Dung Beetle Model
Villager: Broccolo
Personality type: Lazy
How you obtained the DIY: Visiting

 

[rins]

I can't remember the villagers who gave me fruit DIYs but I got two shell recipes recently so I'll write those down.

DIY Name: Shell fountain
Villager: Sherb
Personality type: Lazy
How you obtained the DIY: On my island, he was crafting
If your own villager: Naturally moved in, my 3rd villager

DIY Name: Shell lamp
Villager: Flo
Personality type: Uchi
How you obtained the DIY: On my island, she was crafting
If your own villager: My starter

I went to a friend's today to pick up a DIY and it was for ironwood low table

DIY Name: Ironwood low table
Villager: Vivian
Personality type: Snooty
How you obtained the DIY: I visited my friend, Vivian was crafting
If your own villager: She isn't mine but Vivian was invited from Mystery Islands.

 

[ctar17]

DIY Name: Shell Bed
Villager: Wendy
Personality type: Peppy
How you obtained the DIY: She was crafting on my island
If you own your villager: adopted

DIY Name: Ironwood Cupboard
Villager: Gloria
Personality type: Snooty
How you obtained the DIY: She was crafting on my island
If you own your villager: mystery islands

 

[nammie]

DIY Name: wild log bench
Villager: hamlet
Personality type: sporty
How you obtained the DIY: he was crafting in his house
If your own villager: from mystery island

 

[galactickat4240]

DIY Name: Angled signpost
Villager: Zucker
Personality type: Lazy
How you obtained the DIY: On my island
If your own villager: Random move in

DIY Name: Money flooring
Villager: Velma
Personality type: Snooty
How you obtained the DIY: On my island
If your own villager: Amiibo card

DIY Name: Cherry wall
Villager: Apple
Personality type: Peppy
How you obtained the DIY: On my island
If your own villager: Obtained from mystery island

 

[iovis]

DIY Name: Gold Bars
Villager: Judy
Personality type: Snooty
How you obtained the DIY: On my island
If your own villager: Obtained from Campsite

DIY Name: Woodland Wall
Villager: Lily
Personality type: Normal
How you obtained the DIY: On my island
If your own villager: Amiibo

 

[Altarium]

I'll try to keep track of DIYs from now on as I don't remember pretty much anything, but let's start today!

DIY Name: Cherry wall
Villager: Marina
Personality type: Normal/Sweet
How you obtained the DIY: On my island
If your own villager: Obtained from mystery island

DIY Name: Natural mum wreath
Villager: Julian
Personality type: Smug
How you obtained the DIY: On my island
If your own villager: adopted

DIY Name: Cherry rug
Villager: Ruby
Personality type: Peppy
How you obtained the DIY: On my island
If your own villager: Obtained from mystery island

DIY Name: Peach rug
Villager: Ruby
Personality type: Peppy
How you obtained the DIY: On my island
If your own villager: Obtained from mystery island

DIY Name: Shell table
Villager: Skye
Personality type: Normal
How you obtained the DIY: On my island
If your own villager: Obtained from mystery island