Mafia TBT Scummies II - WINNERS ANNOUNCED!

[oath2order]

Introduction:​

Welcome to the TBT Mafia Scummy Awards! This time, we're back and better than before! Vote for the members you think fit best in the Categories provided, be sure to read all the rules, and have fun!

For those who don't know, this is just a fun little way to celebrate mafia and give awards for play styles in the game.

Be sure to send in your votes via PM to me before August 1st, 2014!

---

Categories


Individual Awards​

Best Overall Player
This award goes to the player who is considered to be the best overall player.

Spoiler: Nominees

• Tina
• iLoveYou
• Jeremy
• Ashtot
• KarlaKGB

Best Town Player
This award goes to the player who did the best as town in a single game.

Spoiler: Nominees

• Tina
• Trundle
• LittleBeary
• Lauren
• Natty
• Sataric

Best Mafia Player

This award goes to the player who did the best as mafia in a single game.

Spoiler: Nominees

• Tom
• iLoveYou
• LittleBeary
• Dolby
• Jeremy
• Yui-Z
• oath2order

Best Third Party Player

This award goes to the player who did the best as third party in a single game.

Spoiler: Nominees

• Feloreena
• Jeremy
• Prof Gallows
• Princess
• oath2order

Best Role Claim

This award goes to the player who had the best role claim.

Spoiler: Nominees

• Dolby (I Drive The Bus)
• Trundle (accidentally claiming the wrong doctor in Mini Mafia XII)
• Superpenguin (Sleeper Inventor Toxic Goo)
• oath2order (no specifics)
• Tina (no specifics)

Best Doctor

This award goes to the player considered to be the best Doctor.

Spoiler: Nominees

• Elise
• Kerryelizabeth
• MissNoodle
• Tom

Best Detective

This award goes to the player considered to be the best Detective.

Spoiler: Nominees

• Aerious
• Murray
• MrKisstoefur
• BlueLeaf

Best Vigilante
Due to a six way tie, there is no official winner.
This award goes to the player considered to be the best Vigilante.

Spoiler: Nominees

• Natty
• Cory
• Justin
• Superpeguin
• BlueLeaf
• Feloreena

Best Mistake

This award goes to the player who made the best worst mistake in a game.

Spoiler: Nominees

• oath2order
• Truffle
• Karen
• Trundle
• Natty

Best IRC Mafia Player

This award goes to the player who is the best at IRC Mafia.

Spoiler: Nominees

• Horus
• Mari
• MissNoodle
• oath2order

Host Awards​

Best Run Game

This award goes to the host who had the best run game.

Spoiler: Nominees

• Tina
• Minties
• PurplPanda
• Feloreena
• KarlaKGB (specifically Mini Mafia XIII, also Mafia I)
• Justin

Most Unique Set-Up

This award goes to the host who had the most unique set-up.

Spoiler: Nominees

• Feloreena (Mafia XIII)
• Tom (Mafia XI)
• PurplPanda (Mafia XII)
• Jeremy (Mini Mafia X)
• LaurinaMN (Mafia X)
• KarlaKGB (Mini Mafia V)
• Justin (Mafia VII)

Best Writing

This award goes to the host who had the best flavor text in a game.

Spoiler: Nominees

• Tina
• PurplPanda
• Minties
• Feloreena

---

General Mafia Rules:​

Time Cycle and Phases:
The Scummies will last until August 1st, at which point all voting ends, tallying begins, and awards are given out.

Current Games
Please do not nominate someone for a role they have in an ongoing game.

Wisdom of the Crowds:
Wisdom of the Crowds will not be in these Scummies.

Editing:
Editing is allowed.

Inappropriate Posts:
Scummy Awards can get heated and emotional. Please keep it civil and remember that what happens in the Scummies should stay in the Scummies. Don't let things wash over to the rest of the forum, it's just a game.

Out of Thread Communication:
It is preferred that you do not discuss your votes with other players.

Replacements:
There will be no replacements.

Mod Font:
This is the mod color. It is reserved for the host. Please do not use it.

Question Font:
This is the question color. Use it to ask the host questions about the rules in public. You can also PM me.

---

General Mafia Voting Rules:​

1. This game will use Plurality Vote. For those of you familiar with IRC Mafia, it is the same system. The player with the most votes will win that category.
2. Please be sure to state the game that player
3. Voting is done in via PM. Please PM me your votes.
4. You may vote for yourself, but please do not vote for yourself in all categories.
5. You can vote for the host of the Scummies.
6. You do not have to vote in all categories.

---

If you have not read all the rules, go back and do so.​

 

[Pathetic]

best doctor goes to me!!!!!

first

 

[Blu Rose]

You have two best detective category and in the vigilante category it says "...best detective"

 

[Trent the Paladin]

>best mistake

Inb4kingmaker mafia

 

[Capella]

best scum goes to me gg

 

[Murray]

vote murray for most unique set up

 

[radical6]

if i dont get best doctor (i was doctor 4 fking times) i hate you all

 

[BlueLeaf]

if i dont get best doctor (i was doctor 4 fking times) i hate you all

But that's saved for Tom ; he was an excellent Doctor in Mafia IV!!!1!

 

[MrPicklez]

if i dont get best doctor (i was doctor 4 fking times) i hate you all

Not to mention you died all four of those times.

#rekt

But that's saved for Tom ; he was an excellent Doctor in Mafia IV!!!1!

I read that game and I have to agree with this.

 

[BungoTheElf]

best mistake goes to me woooooo

 

[radical6]

But that's saved for Tom ; he was an excellent Doctor in Mafia IV!!!1!

tom doesnt deserve anything

Not to mention you died all four of those times.

#rekt



I read that game and I have to agree with this.

hey the 2nd one was a modkill. i ended the game. that doesnt count.
also wasnt tom scum in mafia IV lol

fel for best third party player. also blueleaf maybe bc he won in III because thunder and some other loser got modkilled smh

 

[Trent the Paladin]

hey the 2nd one was a modkill. i ended the game. that doesnt count.
also wasnt tom scum in mafia IV lol

>that's the joke.jpg
I claimed Doc and Kayla willingly handed me all the blues on a silver platter.

 

[radical6]

>that's the joke.jpg
I claimed Doc and Kayla willingly handed me all the blues on a silver platter.

shut up i didnt read that disaster of a game

 

[MrPicklez]

tom doesnt deserve anything



hey the 2nd one was a modkill. i ended the game. that doesnt count.
also wasnt tom scum in mafia IV lol

fel for best third party player. also blueleaf maybe bc he won in III because thunder and some other loser got modkilled smh

He was joking lol

 

[BlueLeaf]

fel for best third party player. also blueleaf maybe bc he won in III because thunder and some other loser got modkilled smh

It was boring fun while it lasted.

I'm actually excited to see the results ; the salt being thrown around when the "Best Mistake" winner is revealed should be a spectacle to see.

Would Exalt in XCOM Mafia be considered Third Party?

 

[MrPicklez]

I'm actually leaning towards Purpl for best detective in the "The Honnō-ji Incident" because we both worked together so well with Jer that game. Not to mention I was targeted like 2 or 3 nights in a row by scum.

I'd also like to nominate Tom for being a pretty amazing doctor that game for saving my ass so many times.

 

[radical6]

best detective goes to aerious for inspecting the innocent child
best overall player and best writing goes to tina !

 

[Byngo]

(づ｡◕‿‿◕｡)づ・ *ヽ(◕ヮ◕ヽ)

(ﾉ◕ヮ◕)ﾉ*:･ﾟ✧・ *ヽ(◕ヮ◕ヽ)

VoteNattyForBestEverythingBecauseFriendShipIsMagic

(ﾉ◕ヮ◕)ﾉ*:･ﾟ✧・ *ヽ(◕ヮ◕ヽ)

- - - Post Merge - - -

but for realz I'm seriously at a loss of who to vote for any of those categories... Like I can't remember anything from any of the games except the past few and it's really annoying :c

 

[Geoni]

Feloreena had a very interesting setup for Xcom. I nominate them.

- - - Post Merge - - -

Would Exalt in XCOM Mafia be considered Third Party?

Yep.

 

[Murray]

best detective goes to aerious for inspecting the innocent child
best overall player and best writing goes to tina !

best mafia for killing aerious and saving her the embarassment