I like the first template (not so much on the style of the character, but whatever), but I would also like the little rarity leaves that are on the third template included on the first template if we go in that route.
I don't like the second template, I'm sorry, it's just...meh.
The third, well, I like the leaf, though I dislike the "gamecube exclusive" thing. Why is that needed? I also vote that any flavor tet is from in-game or picture quote, nothing creative or whatever.
Hah, well I do crazy realism and stuff so in my free time my rendition of characters changes a bit. But we can worry about that once the template is decided. They'll probably be much closer to the actual characters when the cards are done.