What single species island would you have?

[Katie0391]

I would love an all cat island. If I ever got a second switch/island I would go for cats. Deer or sheep would be a close second

 

[KittenNoir]

1000% I would have a cat island

That's it just cats and I would never let them go haha I wish that could happen I never find cats when I go island hopping.
The only cat I have on my island is Kiki which I got from a lovely user here.

 

[Sheando]

My favorite species is anteaters and I’d love to collect them all, but there aren’t a full 10 and I really dislike missing personalities.

My next choices would be either sheep or dogs. I did consider making a sheep/dog/anteater island with 3/3/4 of those species types, but I just love variety too much! If I ever went through with it I’d have Antonio, Anabelle, Cyrano, Snooty, Curlos, Wendy, Vesta, Cherry, Bones, and Benjamin.

 

[Serabee]

Well, my first thought would be "cat", because they're my favorite animal in-game and IRL. But I also see SO MANY cat only islands. The more I think about, the more I think an aviary themed island would be fun. But I'd also want to mix the bird species a bit. Like, mostly typical birds, but also an ostrich or two. I don't think I'd do chickens or penguins, since they wouldn't really be common in an aviary.

 

[PacV]

Deers. Fun thing cause i don't have any...

 

[Kg1595]

I think variety is the spice of life, so I would probably never go the single species route. That said, I have never had a dog villager, yet I like so many of them, so that would be an interesting one.

 

[annex]

Squirrels.

Caroline, Blaire, Hazel and Poppy are so cute. I don't plan on replacing any villagers or restarting, but if I did, I would have all squirrels.

Also, if anyone has Nibbles in their town, I would love to dream visit so I can meet her in person.

 

[jadetine]

This is an excellent discussion! I had to double check how many species there were and on villagerdb.com the filter shows a whopping 35 Types!

My favorite aesthetic is zen/ Imperial/ bamboo, and I would love to build a ninja village of frogs.

But considering how the species would twist your town theme, I think a village of elephants would be hilarious! Having them blast my Peppa Pig theme on giant Timpani drums with each conversation just tickles me.

I am currently at 0% for both of these goals, but I am 3 villagers away from completing my foodie crew, so maybe Tia can be my next target...

 

[. Rarity .]

This is an excellent discussion! I had to double check how many species there were and on villagerdb.com the filter shows a whopping 35 Types!

My favorite aesthetic is zen/ Imperial/ bamboo, and I would love to build a ninja village of frogs.

But considering how the species would twist your town theme, I think a village of elephants would be hilarious! Having them blast my Peppa Pig theme on giant Timpani drums with each conversation just tickles me.

I am currently at 0% for both of these goals, but I am 3 villagers away from completing my foodie crew, so maybe Tia can be my next target...

Ohh, who are the last three?

 

[jadetine]

Ohh, who are the last three?

Tangy, Tia, and maybe Mint. My main regret is that there are no dudes other than Chadder... maybe I'll swap in Angus or someone. I have so many peppy villagers (my least fave) and no cranky (da best imho).

Current crew: https://villagerdb.com/user/jadetine/list/current-villagers

 

[Meadows]

Squirrels!

Squirrels have the most villagers that I like in a single species.

 

[Xeleron]

Honestly, it's really hard to pick but I think if I could only pick one species I would pick pigs : Chops - distinguished gentleman, Agnes - love her simple yet very elegant design, Boris - cute fangs, Hugh - always rocking his heterochromia, Rasher - looks like a meanie, but is actually very caring , Peggy - epitome of cute, Gala - big eye queen (they remind me of the eyes from the characters in Cuphead and I'm here for it), Cobb - Zombie? Frankenstein? It's a mystery and the world may never know the truth, Pancetti - Obligatory snooty (tbh, I'd prefer Sue E as the snooty, but she isn't in the game ).

Other good options for me are Hamsters, Elephants, Penguins, and Ducks.

 

[Etown20]

I think squirrels, ducks, or bear cubs would be fun. I've also thought of doing a squirrels + ducks combo island with 5 of each.

 

[Nunnafinga]

This thread has brought back memories of when I was putting my New Leaf single species towns together.It took a lot longer to gather up the villagers back in the pre-Amiibo card days but fortunately there was always a lot of generous people here on TBT who were willing to give me villagers for free.I chose to do a duck island for New Horizons because it was the first single species town I did and it had the most mistakes...heh.

Quackle- ducks
Bam!- pigs
Newt- frogs

 

[Bethboj]

I could easily have a full island of cats. A full island of bobs would be great actually!

 

[Peach_Jam]

Ah I have a lot of faves, but I think I'd go with cats! Squirrels and deers would be a close second though •̑‧̮•̑

 

[LuchaSloth]

I honestly don't think I could do it. There is no species that I just like a whole lot. If I had to, I would probably go with cat, just because I think there are enough pretty solid choices there. But, again...it's not really something I would ever do.

 

[AgentBlade]

Probably rabbits because I love Cole and Dottie and I share a birthday with doc.

 

[squidpops]

Cat for sure! They're the one species I like nearly every villager of. My lineup would be Bob, Kabuki, Lolly, Kiki, Mitzi, Raymond, Punchy, Tangy, Purrl, and Katt!

 

[Soigne]

ducks !!