What’s your personal tier list? - uchi/sisterly

[WaileaNoRei]

I thought this was a good time for another one of these. Absolutely loving everyone’s input on the first thread! I love seeing how strong all our opinions are and how different we think about the same villagers!

This is another type with I think a lot of different opinions

Personally, I currently really like a lot of the uchi villagers designs, but I don’t think I did at first, and my opinion on them has changed probably the most over time, toward the positive.

I love how different they all are, and how interesting and unique the designs are.

S - currently I am loving plucky much more than I originally imagined, and she is my number one favorite. And I have always thought Deirdre was just a practically perfect uchi

A - I like more and more of the uchi villagers. I’ve had agnes, Ursala, Reneigh, fuchsia, pashmina, muffy, and Shari, and honestly ended up liking every one of them far more than I expected. Would love to have Charlise and Paula in particular on one of my islands some day. Each sisterly villager I have had gives me a slightly different impression of the personality type and I have found that really fun.

B - I feel like these villagers could easily move up into the A category, but if I had to choose some non favorites they would still fall into that category.

C - I don’t have strong feelings about these, but even the c tier villagers I feel I could probably come to like/ love, if I gave them the chance’

D - maybe it is unfair, but I have always found cherry overrated (even though I am not trying to make anyone feel bad for liking her). Her features are actually cute (I like the crooked smile), and I like dogs, but for some reason she just gives off a vibe to me of trying too hard too be cool.

F - I just don’t like superhero villagers, any of them. But for the record, of the two, if I had to pick I would go with Rocket though. (Sorry to fans of these two!)

Edit: oops forgot the link!

https://tiermaker.com/create/animal-crossing-new-horizons-uchi-sisterly-villagers-117711

 

[Moritz]

Do you have a link to do this like you did in the last thread about smugs?

 

[WaileaNoRei]

Do you have a link to do this like you did in the last thread about smugs?

Sorry about that! I added the link above! Thanks for pointing that out.

 

[Moritz]

This list is relative to sisterly villagers.
If I was rating all the villagers in the game, their tiers would be different.

Apart from the bottom row. No. Just no.

 

[Sander]

Tough one, sisterly is definitely my favorite female personality in New Horizons, but I don't like many of the designs and there are so few.

 

[Firesquids]

My list is also only relative to sisterly villagers

S-
Reneigh: Her name is a great pun, I like her hair cut, and she's got cute piercings. I'm not usually into brown and pink but she makes it work, Plus the Uchi dialog makes her sounds like Applejack and my irl sister loves Applejack so it works out for me lol
Muffy: What a cutie. She's never lived in my town/island but I've always been into her gothic lolita vibe.
Cherry: She lived in my NL town for a long time and I've always liked her,. She was the fist animal I noticed had piercings and I always thought that was neat. Just a cute alt-rock doggo
A -
Frita: She's adorable and I feel highly underrated, she lived in my NL town for a while and she always made me want to make a town of food themed villagers, never got around to it though
Rene: She lives in my sister's town, she's pretty cute too, kind of a butch vibe. (Does anyone else think all uchis are lesbians? lol)
Agnes: She also lives in my sister's town, I think she's pretty cute, her mouth looks like Peppa Pig's
B -
Pheobe: She's a pheonix so that's pretty neat, I think her house in NH is hilarious
Pashima: one of the cuter goats, not much to say about her
Fuchia: I used to hate her but her design has really grown on me, she's fab
Dirdre: took cottage core a little too far but she likes what she likes I guess
C-
Mira: I like her theme well enough but the execution leave something to be desired. I think it's the white eyelashes maybe?
Kat: She rubs a lot of people the wrong way, she just has an off-putting character design. I dig her confidence though
Rocket: Another unpopular one, I think she's funny but no way is she moving in
Paula: Hippie aunt bear. Got kind of a Janice Jopplin thing going I think, pretty meh
Flo: She lived in my NL town for a bit, pretty forgettable tbh
Diva: I'm not a fan of her "hair" it makes an outlier in the frog category for sure, and not in a good way (same with Jambette)
D-
Canberra: I think that's his name anyway, looks like a jerk. What... Canberra's a girl? I've been misgendering her forever, my bad. That actually makes me liker her character design more now, move her up to C tier.
Tammy: She spills your lunch and insults you while all the other kids laugh
Charlise: She was one of my two starting villagers in NH and I couldn't wait for her to leave. Her colors clash too much to be attractive (sorry girl, u kno its true doe)
Hazel: The Frida Kahlo girl squirrel. I'm not really a fun of squirrels in general so she has no place in my town
Plucky: Brown chicken, nothing to see here
Pink bear: I don't even know her name, and I thought I knew all of them. A literal "who?" (Hmmm I think I would name her Alice lol)
Sylvia: Super Karen, that is all.
F-
Shari:

Spoiler

 

[ayeeprill]

Agnes is a queen. I know my opinion on Katt is an unpopular opinion but she's my birthday twin, so I've always had a soft spot for her! Pashmina is awesome as well, I want to have her on my island at some point!

Sylvia and Charlise are my least favorites. The lack of sisterly villagers makes me sad. Only 24?

 

[Moritz]

Shari

I... I wish I did not know that

 

[azurill]

Flo will always be one of my favorites. I was happy when she was one of my starters on Serenity. Phoebe and Pashmina are on my new leaf towns and would be sad if the left.
I liked having Canberra more then I thought I would. She was my starter on my second island.

 

[peachycrossing9]

Here's how I currently rank the sisterlys. Most of them I am really not much of a fan of. A lot of the designs for the sisterlys just don't appeal to me.

Agnes and Pashmina are probably my two favourites for this personality.
Diva is one of the worst villagers to exist. She was my starter on my first island, and she haunted me for way too long and didn't want to leave. It was horrible.

I had Plucky as one of my starters for my current island, and he really grew on me while I had him, so he has moved up in ranking. Usually he would be at C.

 

[Moonlight.]

i hope you continue doing these, they're really fun to do

 

[Flicky]

I'm not too big on the sisterly type, but I do love Cherry and Phoebe. Also, didn't realize Canberra was a girl! Gonna have to get her on my island for that reason alone.

 

[.: Meri :.]

Oh man, I really like sisterly villagers, so this was a little tough ahaha. I wish there were more of them though!

Best gal: I love Deirdre's autumn aesthetic and I think she pulls off white lipstick incredibly well!

Also extremely cool: These two are in my "beloved villagers who didn't quite make the dreamie list" category. I almost went with Reneigh for my New Horizons island, since I wanted to have one of the new villagers, but ultimately chose Raymond. I'd love to have either of them in a future game.

Very cool, would definitely hang out with: I really like most of these girls and would be happy to have any of them, though I might not keep them forever—though Pashmina is actually here for a different reason. I love Pashmina in New Leaf, but I don't like how her aesthetic changed in New Horizons at all, so I had a hard time figuring out where to rank her. I miss when she was a goth goat. ;-; The corseted shirt looked so good with her horn color too. Also, I just wanted to mention that Flo is quickly growing on me, although I'd kind of overlooked her for a while.

Mostly like: Either I like them for the most part (minus one little thing), or I just like them okay. Charlise grew on me when I had her in New Leaf, and I really like Renée's design, but I'm not big on their home aesthetics. Shari is cute, but the possible inspiration of her yellow markings left me a bit disturbed, and while I'm not big on the superhero villagers, I think Rocket's pretty cool and I love her little hair curl.

Okay, but not to my personal liking: I'm not big on Frita's fast food theme, and Fuchsia's color scheme is a little bright for me. Plucky looks like she's perpetually terrified, but won't say what it is she's scared about, and I think that'd make me a little anxious.

Their eyes scare me: Mira's a little intense and it feels like both Sylvia and her joey are judging me. Katt looks like she might be sizing me up for a fight and I'm not sure I'd feel comfortable turning my back on her.

 

[Nunnafinga]

I liked the ucherly villagers a lot more in New Leaf so I've had a difficult time finding any that I really like for New Horizons.Only Katt,Deirdre and Reneigh have really piqued my interest.

 

[maria110]

Muffy, Reneigh, Mira, Agnes, Deirdre -- love them all. Reneigh and Muffy are permanent villagers for me.

 

[BigBadButterfree]

Wow, I didn't realize how little exposure to Sisterly villagers I have. And this is counting both NH and NL! Luckily, I don't really have much against any of them. The only one I "don't like" is a mild dislike, and I only had her back in the GameCube game when she was a snooty.

 

[Stikki]

S = villagers I've had and loved or I really like the design of
A = villagers I like
B = villagers I am neutral on. Phoebe is here because I really liked her in New Leaf, but I don't like her creepy interior at all in NH.
C = Villagers I don't know and/or don't particularly like
D = Charlise. I hate Charlise more than any other villager. She was a pain in New Leaf and I've never forgiven her.

 

[TofuIdol]

 

[idiotdoomspiral]

Uchis are my favourite personalities, i wouldnt say that i actively dislike any of them

 

[820]

Sisterly villagers are probably my favorite personality type, so here:

I like how it seems like the two in the Renéeigh tier are looking at each other over their shoulders.
I also don't like dissing frog villagers since they're my favorite animal in real life, but a lot of them are kinda oof.