Kirbystarship
Senior Member
I'm going with a nightmares lynch.
-
Staff favorites and raffle winners have been announced for TBT's Season of Giving! See the latest announcement thread: TBT's Season of Giving 2024: Closing Ceremony. Thank you to everyone for sharing your creativity and generosity during this event!
Mafia A Game of Mafia - Endgame - Mafia wins!
- Thread starter N e s s
- Start date
Lynch needs to happen. The only thing a no lynch gives us is us not taking a shot at possibly hitting mafia. You know where that gets us? An extra round where mafia gets a freebie. Lynch gives us much more info than a no lynch does. You can see who voted for who and what their motivations, were, who jumped on wagons, etc.
My current thought is FleshyBro.
My current thought is FleshyBro.
Hmmm looks like no one is doing any scum hunting and just simply voting people on the basis of who annoyed you the most. Tardis, while I agree that a mislynch can be helpful in narrowing down suspects, I don't agree on mislynching someone who does not appear scummy in the first place. That is wasting a lynch. If you can provide more evidence on why you think Nightmares can flip red, I'll consider it. And if you're town, you should help look for other suspects as well instead of tunneling Nightmares for playing like a noob.
I think we've already established in Double Cop Mafia that not lynching will only benefit mafia. Town lost because we did a No Lynch on the first day. If you want to improve on your play and actually help town this time (if you're town that is) please work on your reading comprehension and don't just post irrelevant questions/fillers. It's starting to tick me off.
--
Who do you suspect so far?
Ness/Dolby, can you make the names on OP clickable? Thank you <3
I think we've already established in Double Cop Mafia that not lynching will only benefit mafia. Town lost because we did a No Lynch on the first day. If you want to improve on your play and actually help town this time (if you're town that is) please work on your reading comprehension and don't just post irrelevant questions/fillers. It's starting to tick me off.
--
Who do you suspect so far?
Ness/Dolby, can you make the names on OP clickable? Thank you <3
I agree with you, I was going to say something about fleshy but I didn't. At the same time I want to go with my own choice as I trust no one and don't want to bandwagon. Though fleshy does seem suspicious, I'm not up for bandwagon and I'm sticking with hunter for now. I agree with voting someone though.
it p much looks like the votes are super scattered rn lol. i think more reasoning needs to be brought up for a lynch so more town can agree on it.
i don't find anyone sus except for tardis a little but he could just be trying to be more aggressive. i know he wants to improve and change his gameplay.
the only person, if I had to vote RIGHT NOW, would be nightmares. i don't think she's scum but she's the least likely to contribute. id honestly rather not vote her though.
i don't find anyone sus except for tardis a little but he could just be trying to be more aggressive. i know he wants to improve and change his gameplay.
the only person, if I had to vote RIGHT NOW, would be nightmares. i don't think she's scum but she's the least likely to contribute. id honestly rather not vote her though.
@Seroja - Well Nightmares does indeed seem detrimental but we couldn't lynch someone unless we have profound evidence that they are indeed worthy of lynch. It is indeed hard for me to keep a FOS on a specific suspect due to lack of profound evidence. As you and Curry stated earlier in the thread, Mafia can get a free lynch if a lynch did not occur the following night.
So out of all the people, I'm keeping my eye on Nightmares due to the fact that they are being a detriment in our scum hunt by not contributing in any way. FleshyBro is likely but he actually states why he is not in favor of a lynch. If any evidence is discovered that might contradict our view on our suspects, I will most likely change my vote.
So out of all the people, I'm keeping my eye on Nightmares due to the fact that they are being a detriment in our scum hunt by not contributing in any way. FleshyBro is likely but he actually states why he is not in favor of a lynch. If any evidence is discovered that might contradict our view on our suspects, I will most likely change my vote.
Kirbystarship
Senior Member
Do you know what a Policy Lynch is? I said if we can't find someone to lynch we should Policy Lynch Nightmares.
- - - Post Merge - - -
@discord I see you lurking thoughts about the game so far?
Oh I must have missed that. Thanks for the info. But I still think it's too early to decide that. Hunter is a better candidate for a policy lynch imo. Or is he banned? Anyone knows?
Hmmm just like hiyori I'm not suspicious of anyone yet. But I'll try to give my thoughts on each player. Everyone is mostly on null right now though.
Kirby is posting more seriously this game since he did say he wanted to post less fillers. It could be him trying to change his mafia play style, but I feel like he's trying to be a more helpful town. It is also a bit of a risky play for him as mafia to lead a lynch on Nightmares right now, so I'm not scum reading him for it.
Fleshybro hmm I think fleshy's suspicions on Liam was understandable and I don't get any scummy vibes from him. I just don't think he's mafia for now.
Discord I don't know what to make of their posts to be honest. What they did was mostly repeat exactly what others have said while not trying to seek out new information from other people- so the discussion just ends there. I'm gonna keep an eye on them.
Liamslash is doing well so far. He gives me the same vibe as in the Double Cop mafia- posting & questioning freely. I town read Liam the most.
Nightmares is as always, not helping much. But I don't agree with voting her yet.
Hunter x Hunter is going to be like how Locket was in the last newbie game. I don't think they will help much at all in this game. As far as policy lynching goes, Hunter is the better candidate.
Hiyori is being very conservative in this game. I am not sure how to read her yet but I'll be careful with her (mostly because of the last game and nothing else).
Curry is probably someone I will be most careful of. He seems to post just enough helpful information/thoughts to not seem scummy. But I'm mostly null on him.
Kirby is posting more seriously this game since he did say he wanted to post less fillers. It could be him trying to change his mafia play style, but I feel like he's trying to be a more helpful town. It is also a bit of a risky play for him as mafia to lead a lynch on Nightmares right now, so I'm not scum reading him for it.
Fleshybro hmm I think fleshy's suspicions on Liam was understandable and I don't get any scummy vibes from him. I just don't think he's mafia for now.
Discord I don't know what to make of their posts to be honest. What they did was mostly repeat exactly what others have said while not trying to seek out new information from other people- so the discussion just ends there. I'm gonna keep an eye on them.
Liamslash is doing well so far. He gives me the same vibe as in the Double Cop mafia- posting & questioning freely. I town read Liam the most.
Nightmares is as always, not helping much. But I don't agree with voting her yet.
Hunter x Hunter is going to be like how Locket was in the last newbie game. I don't think they will help much at all in this game. As far as policy lynching goes, Hunter is the better candidate.
Hiyori is being very conservative in this game. I am not sure how to read her yet but I'll be careful with her (mostly because of the last game and nothing else).
Curry is probably someone I will be most careful of. He seems to post just enough helpful information/thoughts to not seem scummy. But I'm mostly null on him.
Thought I might also post my reads, why not.
Kirbysuperstar- Not too sure, I don't understand why they are pushing a lynch on nightmares. Nightmares never helps but I don't see that as a reason to vote them, it's a bit bad to vote someone because they just don't help. But I do understand it to a degree, I have null/slightly suspicous vibes from them.
FleshyBro- I feel suspicious of them. The logic behind the no lynch isn't good enough for me. Added because what happened in double cop. They are giving me scummy vibes for sure.
Curry- I agree with what they said about fleshy and listen to them, at the same time I don't want to town read them and trust them fully.
Discord- Null. Haven't got any feelings.
Nightmares- Not helping like normal, but I don't want to vote them just because of that
Seroja- I agree with them, what they said about me also put me on ease. I town read them for now.
Hunter x Hunter- I really think that they are just really weird. No idea what they are on, now that they're gone I still have nothing to go on. But there leaving made me more suspicious.
Hiyiori- Pretty nill. I agree with them to a point so that makes me town lean.
My reads for now. My keyboard is half broken so it took me forever to write.
Kirbysuperstar- Not too sure, I don't understand why they are pushing a lynch on nightmares. Nightmares never helps but I don't see that as a reason to vote them, it's a bit bad to vote someone because they just don't help. But I do understand it to a degree, I have null/slightly suspicous vibes from them.
FleshyBro- I feel suspicious of them. The logic behind the no lynch isn't good enough for me. Added because what happened in double cop. They are giving me scummy vibes for sure.
Curry- I agree with what they said about fleshy and listen to them, at the same time I don't want to town read them and trust them fully.
Discord- Null. Haven't got any feelings.
Nightmares- Not helping like normal, but I don't want to vote them just because of that
Seroja- I agree with them, what they said about me also put me on ease. I town read them for now.
Hunter x Hunter- I really think that they are just really weird. No idea what they are on, now that they're gone I still have nothing to go on. But there leaving made me more suspicious.
Hiyiori- Pretty nill. I agree with them to a point so that makes me town lean.
My reads for now. My keyboard is half broken so it took me forever to write.
Kirbystarship
Senior Member
Going to post reads tomorrow
Nightmares
(￣。￣)～ｚｚｚ
I was thinking about a hunter x hunter lynch as they're inactive at the moment, but I'm quite unsure at this point. At the moment, they're the person I'd go for the most at the moment...
- - - Post Merge - - -
Also I'm going to help Town as best I can this game ok :/
This game hasn't even been up long seriously
- - - Post Merge - - -
(I'm going to school, so please don't go on about me not helping LMAO)
- - - Post Merge - - -
Also I'm going to help Town as best I can this game ok :/
This game hasn't even been up long seriously
- - - Post Merge - - -
(I'm going to school, so please don't go on about me not helping LMAO)
Last edited:
Kirby, his want to lynch Nightmares seems to be desperate and rather like clutching at strings. This is possibly just his regular typing/ play style but it comes across a little harsh, bland and to the point. To me it seems like he may be mafia and it's trying to play it off by not saying anything that'd give him away and instead come across helpful. His whole "calm under pressure" facade, just a little calmer now than in previous games. I'm pretty sure he's a good enough player not to give it away as easily as that though, so my suspicions are likely redundant.
Sejora definitely comes across as town, there's no reason at all so far for me to read her otherwise and not much to read into, playing it safe.
Discord. I'm honestly not sure. The whole not contributing much and mostly just agreeing seems off to me. I just having a very slight feeling of suspicion and distrust at the moment.
Liamslash. I removed my vote for him, I don't have any real reasons to be suspicious of him at this point. He's posting and contributing normally.
Nightmares seems fine to me, I don't see her as not really helping, I think she's trying. Regardless of her input, no scummy vibes.
Hiyori*, compared to other games I've seen her play she isn't contributing nearly as much as I think she usually would and her posts seem pretty 'bland' so far, other than that one "shut up" post. There could be any reason for that though. From what I've seen she seems to contribute slightly more and come across slightly more friendly and hepful when she's mafia, and she isn't really coming across that way at the moment. No real suspicions however as I'm sure she's a good enough player not to give away that she's mafia by simply contributing slightly less but she possibly is mafia and is just quietly observing at this point, playing a little differently, but I don't think that's her. My suspicions are probably redundant again here.
Curry*. I agree with what Sejora said regarding Curry, he just seems to be posting as to not come across scummy. Still, I have no real suspicions and I feel like I'll get a better read on him after he posts his reads.
Hunter x Hunter. There's not really much to base an answer off. I'm leaning towards lynching him by default at this point.
I agree with Sejora, if we policy lynch Hunter is probably the best candidate at the moment, I personally don't see the incline to policy lynch Nightmares.
Sejora definitely comes across as town, there's no reason at all so far for me to read her otherwise and not much to read into, playing it safe.
Discord. I'm honestly not sure. The whole not contributing much and mostly just agreeing seems off to me. I just having a very slight feeling of suspicion and distrust at the moment.
Liamslash. I removed my vote for him, I don't have any real reasons to be suspicious of him at this point. He's posting and contributing normally.
Nightmares seems fine to me, I don't see her as not really helping, I think she's trying. Regardless of her input, no scummy vibes.
Hiyori*, compared to other games I've seen her play she isn't contributing nearly as much as I think she usually would and her posts seem pretty 'bland' so far, other than that one "shut up" post. There could be any reason for that though. From what I've seen she seems to contribute slightly more and come across slightly more friendly and hepful when she's mafia, and she isn't really coming across that way at the moment. No real suspicions however as I'm sure she's a good enough player not to give away that she's mafia by simply contributing slightly less but she possibly is mafia and is just quietly observing at this point, playing a little differently, but I don't think that's her. My suspicions are probably redundant again here.
Curry*. I agree with what Sejora said regarding Curry, he just seems to be posting as to not come across scummy. Still, I have no real suspicions and I feel like I'll get a better read on him after he posts his reads.
Hunter x Hunter. There's not really much to base an answer off. I'm leaning towards lynching him by default at this point.
---
(To further explain my reason for currently voting no lynch) I'm not completely against a lynch or anything, I agree that not lynching is counterproductive but I just don't think lynching someone because they're annoying or acting like a newbie or something isn't the best idea. I'd lynch someone if I had a good reasoning behind doing so, but I don't at the moment, but I'm not set on not lynching, I'm still looking into it. Isn't lynching someone with little to base it off pretty pointless too? Considering that it's only day one and there hasn't been a great amount of play, all of my suspicions are pretty much just based of my own reading too far into things and really have no real backing to them, after N1 I feel like I'll get a better read of who's playing. I agree with Sejora, if we policy lynch Hunter is probably the best candidate at the moment, I personally don't see the incline to policy lynch Nightmares.
While I do actually actually agree, you did vote hunter less than three hours into the game just because he was "annoying", you're suspicious of Kirby for doing something that you pretty much done yourself? It doesn't make me sus of you or anything, I just think your reasoning there is a little off
- - - Post Merge - - -
(@Seroja, I just noticed i've spelt your name wrong multiple times, swapped the r and the j, I'm not sure why I made that mistake but I can't edit it now, so I'm sorry about that!)
Thanks for the reads Liam and FleshyBro.
Also, a Shiida and Curry scum team is dangerous (because of their experience). I'm gonna have my sus goggles on them until I'm thoroughly convinced that they're town.
It's okay, a lot of people make the same mistake lol and I didn't even notice if you didn't point it out. I'm really sleepy right now so I'm going to take a nap. We have 12 hours left if I'm not mistaken. I'll be sure to vote before day ends.
Also, a Shiida and Curry scum team is dangerous (because of their experience). I'm gonna have my sus goggles on them until I'm thoroughly convinced that they're town.
Nightmares
(￣。￣)～ｚｚｚ
Sorry, was I acting bit stressy this morning? I'll try and keep calm lmao
- - - Post Merge - - -
So right now I'm kinda suspicious of kirbystarship. He was telling me I need to practise more at Mafia and even VMed me telling me to join this game....just to lynch me straight away? Scum? It could be he's noticed me being the easiest Townie to lynch, as I'm terrible at this game, so he's trying to get me lynched..... or it's Kirby being weird, and me looking into this too much
- - - Post Merge - - -
(*oops I said lynch way to keep many times..close together....nvm)
- - - Post Merge - - -
So right now I'm kinda suspicious of kirbystarship. He was telling me I need to practise more at Mafia and even VMed me telling me to join this game....just to lynch me straight away? Scum? It could be he's noticed me being the easiest Townie to lynch, as I'm terrible at this game, so he's trying to get me lynched..... or it's Kirby being weird, and me looking into this too much
- - - Post Merge - - -
(*oops I said lynch way to keep many times..close together....nvm)
Nightmares just seems to be copying me.
Trying harder means coming up with your own ideas.
I decided to vote fleshy instead, hunter really isn't doing much now. I'd much rather wait on them to do something and fleshy just looks like they are copying everyone else's opinions.
Trying harder means coming up with your own ideas.
I decided to vote fleshy instead, hunter really isn't doing much now. I'd much rather wait on them to do something and fleshy just looks like they are copying everyone else's opinions.
