Yep. If you are wearing reorderable shirts, pants and shoes, and you lose a game to an outside villager, they will give you a patched shirt, pants and shoes. If you got pants right away, maybe you were wearing a dress? I don't know. They will give you a pumpkin-head first, then the clothes in that order. If you have blank spaces, they will give you either an old floor or old wallpaper. If you have a full inventory, they will swap something for a jack-in-the-box, unless you are only carrying unorderables or golden/silver tools. They actually swapped one of my lollipops for a jack-in-the-box, so I wasn't able to get the full creepy without playing a little in another town.