Audie for sure. I had her on my island as my first peppy since the game launched and I loved her! Her backstory is the sweetest and the fact she looks like a beautiful fox is awesome. She was great and really suited the personality and I always enjoyed talking to her. I couldn't even bring myself to go and say goodbye to her when I redid my island a couple of weeks ago and I finally had to let her go. I don't have her amiibo either, so I can only bring her to HHA if she appears there herself. If she does, I'm snapping her straight up.