Mafia Cell Mafia II: Stuck in Testing[Mafia Win!]

[ryan88]

What? Inactives had the chance to prove themselves as active in past games. When all the active players are gone the game will be dead. They won't post at all. I don't really feel like they'll be able to do anything. I'm pretty sure the people in the first cell mafia game went from most inactive to active. Besides, keeping active players alive will help us more. We don't need them to die day one. Besides, having a player like Tom for example and keeping him alive til the end will be easier to get a read on him.

Now why would we keep tom? He was scum in Sunleth. I would lynch him because he was voted best scum. And because you want to keep him I think your scum

 

[BerryPop]

My inbox is ready! (Sorry, playing ocarina of time)

 

[radical6]

Now why would we keep tom? He was scum in Sunleth. I would lynch him because he was voted best scum. And because you want to keep him I think your scum

......That doesn't mean he's scum in every game omfg. And I want to keep Tom alive because it's easier to get a read on him when time goes on, he will slip up or show big behavior changes. Inactives? I very much doubt they'll get more active, how will we get a read on them?

 

[Geoni]

What? Inactives had the chance to prove themselves as active in past games. When all the active players are gone the game will be dead. They won't post at all. I don't really feel like they'll be able to do anything. I'm pretty sure the people in the first cell mafia game went from most inactive to active. Besides, keeping active players alive will help us more. We don't need them to die day one. Besides, having a player like Tom for example and keeping him alive til the end will be easier to get a read on him.

I'd have to disagree. If there's anything the scum team could be hoping for it'd be that people would do what they always do and vote to lynch an inactive on day one and thus reduce the town count. In a bigger game this might not hurt that much, but twelve is small and even one townie is a significant loss. And from my own experience it's often the first impression that matters the most and the longer active mafia linger (if they're good at being mafia) there's more of a chance that less attentive townies will be manipulated by them. And there are pleeenty of people in this game that I feel won't read into things enough.

- - - Post Merge - - -

Now why would we keep tom? He was scum in Sunleth. I would lynch him because he was voted best scum. And because you want to keep him I think your scum

Calm down and use logic next time you want to try and be helpful.

 

[radical6]

I'd have to disagree. If there's anything the scum team could be hoping for it'd be that people would do what they always do and vote to lynch an inactive on day one and thus reduce the town count. In a bigger game this might not hurt that much, but twelve is small and even one townie is a significant loss. And from my own experience it's often the first impression that matters the most and the longer active mafia linger (if they're good at being mafia) there's more of a chance that less attentive townies will be manipulated by them. And there are pleeenty of people in this game that I feel won't read into things enough.

Do you know how this setup works??????
Let's say Group A lynches scum, Group B mislynches. Group C is last.
Do you think Group C alone can find out scum? I will have no idea who to vote for because they're ALL inactive. Group C most likely won't help during group B's lynch. It makes no sense to keep inactive players.

 

[BlueLeaf]

I'd have to disagree. If there's anything the scum team could be hoping for it'd be that people would do what they always do and vote to lynch an inactive on day one and thus reduce the town count. In a bigger game this might not hurt that much, but twelve is small and even one townie is a significant loss. And from my own experience it's often the first impression that matters the most and the longer active mafia linger (if they're good at being mafia) there's more of a chance that less attentive townies will be manipulated by them. And there are pleeenty of people in this game that I feel won't read into things enough.

- - - Post Merge - - -



Calm down and use logic next time you want to try and be helpful.

You are aware that in this game, we don't essentially have Town numbers. Once a person in a group is lynched, all of the people in the group are removed from the game.

I can see what you're trying to say, though.

 

[BerryPop]

Do you know how this setup works??????
Let's say Group A lynches scum, Group B mislynches. Group C is last.
Do you think Group C alone can find out scum? I will have no idea who to vote for because they're ALL inactive. Group C most likely won't help during group B's lynch. It makes no sense to keep inactive players.

I'm active.

 

[Sid2125]

From what I am seeing. It's either lynch the actives or inactives. Why not lynch the middle group. A>C>B. Assuming we will end with the most active group so the thread doesn't die.

 

[Geoni]

Do you know how this setup works??????
Let's say Group A lynches scum, Group B mislynches. Group C is last.
Do you think Group C alone can find out scum? I will have no idea who to vote for because they're ALL inactive. Group C most likely won't help during group B's lynch. It makes no sense to keep inactive players.

Hmm you know what, I'm thinking about it in a different way and it lines up with what you want to do: we need to keep the groups with active and attentive players alive so that we keep the better voters alive. Group C is full of bandwagoners, aside from you tsun. I think C should get cut out of the picture first, yeah. As much as what I just said previously still applies.

- - - Post Merge - - -

Sorry if I hurt feelings here, but imo these are the strongest players in each group:

A: MissNoodles and BlueLeaf
B: Tom and I
C: Tsundere

Group C should go first.

 

[radical6]

Hmm you know what, I'm thinking about it in a different way and it lines up with what you want to do: we need to keep the groups with active and attentive players alive so that we keep the better voters alive. Group C is full of bandwagoners, aside from you tsun. I think C should get cut out of the picture first, yeah. As much as what I just said previously still applies.

Yes..thats exactly what I said. Group C needs to go asap because they won't help during lynches, you're going to need more active players.

​

vote me for mayor
order should be this
C > A > B
inactive to most active

Group C is mostly full of inactives. Yes I know I'm in it but eh. Crystal, Sid, and Berrypop are all known to be inactive. Inactives need to go asap because they most likely won't help the game at all if they stay in.
Group A has okayish players, 2 inactives (Alise and MissNiamh) and 2 actives (BlueLeaf and Natty).
Group B has what I consider the most activeish players. Tom and Dad are active. Capella is sometimes active in games, depending if she actually posts or not. And Ryan88 kind of bandwagons all the time.

But honestly I'm okay with Group A or Group B being switched. Group C should go first since it's full of inactives.

also cool im in the opening post

 

[Geoni]

Anyways, I think we should take the CAB. ##Mayor: tsundere

 

[BerryPop]

Yes..thats exactly what I said. Group C needs to go asap because they won't help during lynches, you're going to need more active players.

Guys, I'm right here!
Sure, I'm STILL a noob, but I think that I can help.

 

[ryan88]

Oh ok. Anyway... Vote for Ryan88! My plan is to have the active groups up for lynch first. The inactive groups aren't active so we should deal with them last.

B>A>C

I'm going to agree with tsundere. We should get the I actives out first

- - - Post Merge - - -

##UNVOTE

##MAYOR: Tsundere

 

[Byngo]

Hey everyone! I'm just checking in. I'm going to read through stuff later because I need a small break from mafia stuff tonight ;-;

 

[BlueLeaf]

Do you know how this setup works??????
Let's say Group A lynches scum, Group B mislynches. Group C is last.
Do you think Group C alone can find out scum? I will have no idea who to vote for because they're ALL inactive. Group C most likely won't help during group B's lynch. It makes no sense to keep inactive players.

This post made me lean towards getting the inactives put up for lynch first, I am down with this plan.

Considering this is Plurality Lynch and Day won't end quickly if I vote right now (XCOM Mafia oops), I'll place an early vote and change it if I feel the need. ##MAYOR: tsundere

 

[toastia]

Vote count:


tsundere
ryan88
Dad
BlueLeaf

 

[f11]

I think it should be C a b. If c miss lynched atleast the other groups can back is up.

- - - Post Merge - - -

##VOTE: Tsundere

 

[Capella]

I'm active.

you sure about that??

Honestly though CAB is the best bet so uh
##Mayor: Tsundere

 

[Pathetic]

hi i am here readings the thread jesus **** 14 pages already

 

[BerryPop]

you sure about that??

Honestly though CAB is the best bet so uh
##Mayor: Tsundere

Ok you have a point.
##vote: tsundre