I rotated through several mmo's, mostly based on my old favorite ones shutting down
I can't remember what my first one was, and I haven't seen it mentioned in this thread. It's been so long, if you asked me to describe it, I couldn't tell you anything. Oh well, I guess it's truly lost to time. Here's a somewhat chronological list of when I STARTED playing games:
1. Barbiegirls. Other than the one I forgot, this was one of my first, along with the below game. There was a special zone where this was this genie girl, and little me had a MASSIVE crush on her back in the day without knowing. It's really a shame it's dead now.
2. PIXIE HOLLOW ONLINE!!! This was one of my first and definitely my all time favorite of the mmos I played as a small kid. The gameplay was relatively entertaining, with you exploring the map and playing minigames respective to the areas they were in, but what really pulled me in was the artwork and atmosphere the game had. It was an incredibly visually pleasing game, and having cute fairies was really the icing on top of the cake. My sister and I made a youtube channel for pixie hollow back in the day. We both shared an account at first, but then she got her own. We both had memberships for the whole time we played on our grandpa's clunky desktop. I really can't express my love for this game enough, and I'm still sad that disney pulled the plug on it. I bet that it would still be popular today with kids!
3. Movie Star Planet. I never really liked this "game" that much, but I liked spending my mom's money on getting new clothes for my character. The site is STILL incredibly slow, and I don't know why parents let their kids spend so much money on it. I'm surprised it's still up to this day. MSP is my least favorite of all the games I played.
4. FreeRealms!!! This game was REALLY all over the place. It's basically World Of Warcraft, for children. Sadly, this one is dead too, because the devs actually cared about it but "no longer had the resources to maintain it's servers", which still makes me feel somber. This was my 2nd favorite from this list. I don't know if what I remember is true, but I used to be so astounded at how big and varied the map was, with so many different zones and atmospheres. The combat was pretty dull and repetitive, but I was more obsessed with the visuals and customization of the game. You could do so much in freerealms, from exploring other peoples houses, dungeon crawling, mining for money, I can't even remember it all! Seriously, this game gets so much love from me. There's a project dubbed FreeRealms Sunrise, that even has a discord, that makes it's objective reviving the game for free, but I doubt that it will ever work. The servers need money to be maintained. Anyways, FreeRealms was amazing and I really miss it.
That's all I can really remember right now, oops. I forgot the names of the other ones I played, seeing as the ones I forgot were from smaller companies and didn't have large playerbases.