collectible tier list ★ (now closed)

Status
Not open for further replies.
Every weird doll i think is it's own thing, and it's up to the buyer and seller to work something out.

you can't really put a proce on it (I'm not at all saying it's priceless) because different people would be willing to sell it at vastly different prices, and same with buying.

Person A might sell it for 20k to someone who would've secretley been willing to pay 45k, and person B might be looking to buy one for 30k while person C is firm on selling at 50k. the range is way too high to be significant
 
both of those point apply to all collectibles across the board though

in reality, bluntly speaking, all collectibles have no real set value. it's a combination of what the seller wants vs what the buyer is willing to pay, and compromising from there


however, I *do* agree with the general premise of these thoughts, and do believe there should be a minimum of something like 5 sales/trades before starting to set a value baseline down for any collectible
 
Last edited:
i'm not trying to put a price on weird doll price, the price guidelines are only a guide, obviously weird doll is much above what tier 1 is set to atm however me increasing the price of tier 1 is dictating it so i'm leaving it as is. i removed it from tier 0 simply because it's in circulation and is being sold (even if it's just been a couple of sales) so it wouldn't be fair in my opinion for it to be in its own tier

- - - Post Merge - - -

again i can't stress enough lol, this isn't a guideline for pricing, the tier level pricing is just to give a rough estimate of where that collectible might fall into price bracket wise, don't go based off of this guide, i didn't mean to cause any issue by me removing the weird doll from tier 0, it was simply because sales have now been recorded so i don't see how it should be its own tier

- - - Post Merge - - -

ok i put tier 1 as 10k + : ) that makes a lot more sense
 
Last edited:
This isn't really about the tier list, although its great and thanks for the update dear mog

But honestly weird doll value is really volatile too because of circulation or a lack there of. Even of the 5 new ones, most people who possess a weird doll would never really sell or get rid of it... idk what that means about value or selling price, but just a good note
 
I mean t0 is basically the utterly broken ass **** tier, in just about every other usage of it I've ever seen. which really sums up weird doll's perceived value far more than t1 does. even if there have been recent sales (though I do feel like they're gonna be the last we'll see for a long while, if not ever)

maybe we should just put it up to a vote
 
Last edited:
also, for weird doll, t0 could just be labeled as over 20k

this would allow it to far better represent its perceived value, not muddy up the information on all the other t1 collectibles, and not put a set value price on the doll either

- - - Post Merge - - -

seliph said:
to hell with these white collars put weird doll in tier 8
Click to expand...

big brain play, right here
 
mogyay said:
i'm not trying to put a price on weird doll price, the price guidelines are only a guide, obviously weird doll is much above what tier 1 is set to atm however me increasing the price of tier 1 is dictating it so i'm leaving it as is. i removed it from tier 0 simply because it's in circulation and is being sold (even if it's just been a couple of sales) so it wouldn't be fair in my opinion for it to be in its own tier

- - - Post Merge - - -

again i can't stress enough lol, this isn't a guideline for pricing, the tier level pricing is just to give a rough estimate of where that collectible might fall into price bracket wise, don't go based off of this guide, i didn't mean to cause any issue by me removing the weird doll from tier 0, it was simply because sales have now been recorded so i don't see how it should be its own tier

- - - Post Merge - - -

ok i put tier 1 as 10k + : ) that makes a lot more sense
Click to expand...

You're list is amazing! I was really replying to the immediately previous posts and not the existence of the list itself (I really like your list). I assumed/trusted the thing I posted was already understood and that I was being redundant a bit by saying it, so I hope it wasn't taken the wrong way.

the list is incredibly helpful and we're lucky there's someone like you maintaining it :)

edit: I wasn't speaking earlier in a pro-weird doll way, but more just in a it-being-inconsequential way cuz sales of it will always work themselves out

last edit: after re-reading your recent post, we share the same viewpoint!
 
Last edited:
Mogyay, I noticed that the Tier 1 doesn't have the title italics. :p

It's fine though, everyone makes mistakes like me on some days. ._.
 
kikotoot said:
You're list is amazing! I was really replying to the immediately previous posts and not the existence of the list itself (I really like your list). I assumed/trusted the thing I posted was already understood and that I was being redundant a bit by saying it, so I hope it wasn't taken the wrong way.

the list is incredibly helpful and we're lucky there's someone like you maintaining it :)

edit: I wasn't speaking earlier in a pro-weird doll way, but more just in a it-being-inconsequential way cuz sales of it will always work themselves out

last edit: after re-reading your recent post, we share the same viewpoint!
Click to expand...

oh gosh no don't be silly, sorry if it seemed like i was defensive, i was mostly just feeling sensitive about my choice to remove tier 0! thank you so much for the original message! i agree with you, it's a unique collectible in the fact that there's definitely not a base guideline price which is why i updated the pricing for tier 1. i still think that it shouldn't have its own tier because it is technically in circulation and sales have been made which was the whole point in tier 0 but this isn't my guide so if enough people think it deserves it's own tier then i'll put it back

also THANKS CHERYL, will update that now, i'm sleepy and stupid
 
mogyay said:
oh gosh no don't be silly, sorry if it seemed like i was defensive, i was mostly just feeling sensitive about my choice to remove tier 0! thank you so much for the original message! i agree with you, it's a unique collectible in the fact that there's definitely not a base guideline price which is why i updated the pricing for tier 1. i still think that it shouldn't have its own tier because it is technically in circulation and sales have been made which was the whole point in tier 0 but this isn't my guide so if enough people think it deserves it's own tier then i'll put it back

also THANKS CHERYL, will update that now, i'm sleepy and stupid
Click to expand...

Thank you so much for updating this list!
 
shout out to emolga bc i completely forgot to add tortimer.... so this lil guy
characterTortimer.png
is abandoning all his character friends and going into tier 6!
 
mogyay said:
shout out to emolga bc i completely forgot to add tortimer.... so this lil guy
characterTortimer.png
is abandoning all his character friends and going into tier 6!
Click to expand...

Poor Tortimer, no one seems to want him. I thought he would be a lot higher considering there's only around 20 of him. I did get someone who messaged me wanting to buy him though. Seems like a situation of low supply but also low demand.

Perhaps, much like the real Tortimer, he'll get more valuable with age.
 
MapleSilver said:
Poor Tortimer, no one seems to want him. I thought he would be a lot higher considering there's only around 20 of him. I did get someone who messaged me wanting to buy him though. Seems like a situation of low supply but also low demand.

Perhaps, much like the real Tortimer, he'll get more valuable with age.
Click to expand...

i just stuck him there after some brief conversation so potentially he should be moved up however haven't seen tooo many threads about him: ) rarity definitely is a factor, tho i imagine he will become more popular in the future! weird doll 2.0 :thinking:
 
I don't why, I kinda noticed this.

Tier 1 has mostly lighter colors like yellow, pink or white

Tier 2 has mostly pink or purple in some way. :/

Don't know, just wanted to share.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Similar threads

seliph
collectible tier list 2.0 ★
3 4 5
Replies
94
Views
7K
nightglow
nightglow
Nougat
Contest Design me a lineup! 🎃 winners announced + surprise! 🎃
2 3
Replies
41
Views
1K
Sheando
Sheando
DarthGohan1
Your tier list of characters in SSBU?
Replies
2
Views
210
Captain Jigglypuff
Captain Jigglypuff
Alolan_Apples
  • Poll
Favorite Tier 1 Collectible
Replies
16
Views
672
Kirbyz
Kirbyz
Midoriya
  • Locked
Giveaway Midoriya's TBT 20th birthday giveaway thread! [CONCLUDED]
2 3 4
Replies
62
Views
2K
Midoriya
Midoriya
Back
Top