Mafia DA:I Mafia

[N e s s]

Hi hello it's me from the other side

It's day one, the day I choose to lurk and **** POST. But I come to you all with a heartfelt plea: This election day, please consider supporting the #LynchDad2015 campaign. Why do this you ask?

1) Dad is scum
2) Dad is anti-town scum
3) His silver tongue will spin magnificent lies around you all
4) If he's got a killing power expect him to us it Night 1 because he likes to shoot first

Thank

Calling dad scum for no real purpose is pretty scummy to me, you seem to be stereo typical ATM. Would you mind giving me a real reason as to why you're choosing dad? I think you deserve to be lynched if you don't give me a solid answer, this whole post here is pretty scummy.

 

[Trent the Paladin]

Calling dad scum for no real purpose is pretty scummy to me, you seem to be stereo typical ATM. Would you mind giving me a real reason as to why you're choosing dad? I think you deserve to be lynched if you don't give me a solid answer, this whole post here is pretty scummy.

Because Dad is always scum. Rule #34 of TBT Mafia, Dad is always scum.

Also you're trying too hard newbie.

 

[N e s s]

Plus there's no solid evidence of any of those facts at the moment.
1.He's said nothing so far to make someone choose him.
2.Thats a repeat of 1, no relevance.
3.as far as I can tell with him going at Daniel he's told 0 lies, I'll see it first than believe it.
4.that's the only thing that could be true, but he hasn't slipped up to make anyone believe that.
that post is a lie to try to keep you alive, but to me it's showed that you are a Liar.

- - - Post Merge - - -

But the question is..am I? >

 

[PandaDarling]

Tbh, I made a few scumtells that game but asking questions isn't one of 'em.

A lot of experienced mafia players will ask questions as either side, because it provides information flow and it helps them seem towny.



Still salty tbh.



As this says. Rune bandwagoning early is not alignment tell.

--

On that note, Trojan is scummy anyhow, so that's not even a bad vote.

BUT

@Rune

Why did you choose Trojan to annoy, specifically? Just because he's your friend? Why then not your other friend you've got to join?

@Dad

Thoughts on Trojan and/or Panda?

@Panda

I don't remember you fingering anyone, want to do that now? And by finger I mean "Suggest might be scum"

I mean, scumreads aren't easy to come by, so I don't expect it to be strong. But we've already had 6 pages.

you don't remember me fingering anyone ? you mean last game ? and yes we have had 6 pages now which probably over 4 of those is worthless chit chat and joking....

i think Dad seems i bit bully-ish in his questioning

 

[Trent the Paladin]

Plus there's no solid evidence of any of those facts at the moment.
1.He's said nothing so far to make someone choose him.
2.Thats a repeat of 1, no relevance.
3.as far as I can tell with him going at Daniel he's told 0 lies, I'll see it first than believe it.
4.that's the only thing that could be true, but he hasn't slipped up to make anyone believe that.
that post is a lie to try to keep you alive, but to me it's showed that you are a Liar.

It's day one, the day I choose to lurk and **** POST.

Hi yes refer to this.

Also you're not fun Agent Hydra.

 

[N e s s]

Thank you I try to be not fun.

- - - Post Merge - - -

Plus I feel stupid now and probably am trying to hard ._.

 

[Trent the Paladin]

Relax and enjoy day one, go with the flow. Don't be like Dad and Ender.

 

[Geoni]

Dad how come you didn't answer my question ?

The age thing? Did.

- - - Post Merge - - -

Also I don't intend to come off as a bully, and I think the lot of you can handle my play. Except Trojan, for some reason they're intimidated? That's my only thought on them so far, Ender.

Also, Tom randomaccused me in order to appear as if he was reaction testing in a previous game I played with him, and he turned out to be scum, so that should be recognized and remembered.

- - - Post Merge - - -

I've been responding to everything because I wanted to start off the game with a friendly icebreaker. I also am trying to whittle out any reads I get from everyone, I want to see how they respond and I can try formulating an opinion from there.

If you were using small talk for reaction testing then you'd be using it as a means to start scumhunting. Yet my questioning and seriousness is also scumhunting and you suspected me for it, so that'd be a little hypocritical. Anyways, got a long day tomorrow so bye for now.

 

[PandaDarling]

sorry Dad you did answer me i apologize, thank you....

 

[Arstotzkan]

Hi

- - - Post Merge - - -

Answer my question or I'm calling you Scumella.

Still reading back, but holy **** this is gold.

 

[oath2order]

People have already posted, and every response has to be typed out with at least some level of deliberation. You've already generated some small talk, too.

DAD I MISSED YOU.

you don't remember me fingering anyone ?

What the hell kind of mafia games have you all been playing??

Hi hello it's me from the other side

It's day one, the day I choose to lurk and **** POST. But I come to you all with a heartfelt plea: This election day, please consider supporting the #LynchDad2015 campaign. Why do this you ask?

1) Dad is scum
2) Dad is anti-town scum
3) His silver tongue will spin magnificent lies around you all
4) If he's got a killing power expect him to us it Night 1 because he likes to shoot first

Thank

Hi scumlord

 

[Arstotzkan]

This is probably gonna turn into a rambly mess btw. I'm typing this as I'm reading this over. Glad to see that day 1's had a more productive turn in general from a few games ago.

Spoiler: miscellaneous responses

When I put all my faith in LaBelle and payed off, good times.

Still don't get why you did that lmao.

Hi hello it's me from the other side

It's day one, the day I choose to lurk and **** POST. But I come to you all with a heartfelt plea: This election day, please consider supporting the #LynchDad2015 campaign. Why do this you ask?

1) Dad is scum
2) Dad is anti-town scum
3) His silver tongue will spin magnificent lies around you all
4) If he's got a killing power expect him to us it Night 1 because he likes to shoot first

Thank

Tom plz. ur logics are too strong.

@Trojan suspicion: I can see it. It seemed awful hypocritical for him at the beginning just to kinda be like "wELP WHOS SUSPICIOUS GUISE" without giving an opinion of his own. Other than that, he said that he was intimidated by Dad despite being the one in the beginning asking who's suspicious and then he made that vote. Needless to say, I'm not townreading him lmao. Trojan, I'm seconding (thirding?) the question on why you made your vote.

@Daniel suspicion: I could see why he would say that there isn't enough to go off of at the beginning, but what really got me was his icebreaker post:

I've been responding to everything because I wanted to start off the game with a friendly icebreaker. I also am trying to whittle out any reads I get from everyone, I want to see how they respond and I can try formulating an opinion from there.

- - - Post Merge - - -

I saw you voted for Trojan, Rune. Any reason why you voted other then to just annoy them like you said?

He made posts with the intent of them being idle chatter? Daniel, why not just cut to the chase? Mafia isn't a game where people play nice - after last game, I thought that'd be clear.

There's also the fact that he said that scumhunting was suspicious. Like I get Ender did that when he was mafia (I did that too when I was town in the same game), but how does scumhunting = suspicious? It supports information flow.

@Dad suspicion: Wut lmao. He's one of my strongest town reads at this point actually, so why.

- - - Post Merge - - -

What the hell kind of mafia games have you all been playing??

....

 

[Arstotzkan]

I think he means FOS, for the record. I've never heard someone use "fingering"...

 

[EnderWiggin]

I think he means FOS, for the record. I've never heard someone use "fingering"...

Aye, one for the San-man.

Get it, he puts you to sleep.

Hey, it's a bone-ified joke!

 

[N e s s]

Lol nice. *high fives*

- - - Post Merge - - -

So guys, out of the people who's posted currently, who's the most suspicious out of all them? I'm currently set on Daniel because he was acting really suspicious at the beginning, like kat said, he had the idea of chatter, but that's scumhunting, he even said he was. I also have a small trojan suspicion he's been acting kinda weird, but there's not too much evidence to support this. Also to the dad suspicions he's not being suspicious, he's just being frank with everyone, wanting to know who they think is suspicious. However I do agree he was being a bit of a bully.

 

[Arstotzkan]

Gimme a break - I can be pretty humerus when I want to be

(That was really good holy crap)

 

[EnderWiggin]

I bet you could be. After all, errybody's got a funny bone.

No laughs? Well I guess I've got a bone to pick with you buddy. You're gonna drown in puns, and you can bet I've got a skele-ton.

- - - Post Merge - - -

I'm still set on Trojan for most suspicious but it's not a strong read.

 

[N e s s]

I'm still set on Trojan for most suspicious but it's not a strong read.

why do you think it's trojan? I'm slightly suspicious of him, but I'm pretty set on Daniel right now.

 

[EnderWiggin]

Pre-empts day-start, is wishy washy while trying to get others to talk.

Lack of commitment.

Mafia often have the need to say things. So they'll often talk very shortly after the day starts if they're around. Not a reliable read but it's a good way to start discussion going.

And the rest of the posts I hope I don't have to spell out why they're meh.

 

[Damniel]

Sup you all. Still reading back a bit.

- - - Post Merge - - -

#lynchdad2015 is so priceless.

- - - Post Merge - - -

I started the little chat just so that everyone started to talk, saying oh so who's suspicious is a pretty weird way to start off the game.