I'm going to give it a solid 10. To be fair, I live in Texas and we're currently undergoing quite a remarkable freeze and snow that us Texans are not prepared or made for. (everything is pretty much shut down, even gas stations... and even... WALMART) I had no power for all of Monday. I played the Festival on my switch pretty much all I could till it eventually died and would of played it more if I could cause once darkness hit... there wasn't much for me to do in the dark and cold. Something I should of thought about more so earlier so I would of played it less in the afternoon, whoops! So it was quite a escape from my alien atmosphere and the stresses coming from it.
Pave is awesome, quite a memorable NPC unlike Jingles who I have practically forgotten his general personality. He even had more flair to him than Jack, who mostly just had some good dialogue but very little actual presence himself.
The atmosphere was probably tied for best alongside Halloween. The confetti, the music, the villagers, the town center, the sales npcs, the feathers, Pave, Pave's stage, and just everything screamed there was a special event and it was welcomed. Some are complaining about the villagers running up to you and doing emotes, but I honestly think this is one of the few times the villagers actually felt lively and like a community. I know to some they are more collectibles that get shelved and collect dust, but it's nice to see some love go into the villager actions especially since you could just ignore them and didn't have to interact with them.
The furniture is awesome which seems to be a popular opinion. Most of the holiday furniture is honestly easy to shelve after he Holiday cause Santa's Sleigh or Jack O Lanterns really look out of place in the Spring or Summer. The feather and tiki like themes going on with this set was amazing in terms of being useable for a much longer or even year round (like us blue in winter) which I don't think any of the other sets (Wedding is one I haven't done, but I look forward to it cause of similar reasons) really hold a candle to.
The process was alright, I did enjoy catching the feathers and hunting them down. Trading with villagers for other colors also helped with the RNG like at one point I ran out of Reds and couldn't find more for awhile... thankfully villagers helped me out there. I know the common gripes are having to talk to Pave multiple times or the feathers not stacking more, but I feel the former is a New Horizons problem overall... I mean just consider mystery island hopping, buying nook miles items in mass, or clothing shopping as examples. Jack was a lot of dialogue himself as well for every candy. The feather stacking was cause of the trading system. They wanted to let you trade up to 3 feathers at a time, so that's why it was set up that way. I typically was just throwing down my prizes as I got them, so I didn't have much inventory issues!
I loved it. This one and Halloween were great. Thanksgiving, Toy Day, New Year's, Random Firework weekends, and etc. were all pretty bare bones to me. I have not experienced the Egg apocalypse or the Wedding event though.
Also there were several moments that I enjoyed like these...
View attachment 356710
They were matching eachother's fur color and dancing together at the start, these two started it off in cuteness overload.
View attachment 356711
Red Team Assemble!
View attachment 356712
Love her evil little face plotting getting my feather.
View attachment 356713
And some actual cute dialogue all around instead of the usual "I sit here." or "Hey, I saw you did a thing yesterday."