Enter me. You have good taste, because yes FMA is a masterpiece, if we're talking manga. Easily the best standard action shonen manga I've read. It quite simply just does everything right, including plenty of things other manga in the same genre either fail at and/or don't seem to try to do competently. Brotherhood being an adaption of the manga is automatically fantastic, though manga still wins out. Don't care at all for the 2003 anime though. Expected quality animation and fight sequences from Bones and music aside, its dumb imo.
Sending TBT for good taste.