Mafia Detonate to Shyna: A Quick DBD Mafia (ENDGAME)-Mafia Won

[Dolby]

I think Zendel has a blue role.

If you know what a blue role is (town PRs) these comments really don’t help town

If you mean he’s maf (red) that’s fine I guess

 

[cornimer]

I think Zendel has a blue role.

It's best not to say who you think has blue roles because we need to keep blue roles alive. If mafia knows who is blue they will probably kill them

 

[Byngo]

I think Zendel has a blue role.

so uhhhhhh revealing who u think is blue (wether ur right or wrong) is a giant no no

 

[PunchyTheCat]

Oh oops..

- - - Post Merge - - -

My scumread is kinda clear. If Zendel is lynched fml

 

[amazonevan19]

Was gonna say, if you think someone's blue, then just stfu and not out it in the thread, cuz now maf can bluesnipe

And I agree on the white text moratorium

 

[PunchyTheCat]

(Kind of clear to me)

 

[Byngo]

Oh oops..

- - - Post Merge - - -

My scumread is kinda clear. If Zendel is lynched fml

did you atleast skim through a few games to get an idea of how the games work, or was this a yolo situation

 

[moonford]

Punchy seems like a confused player, which isn't alignment indicative.

Remember Bianca in her first game? (she was scum in Franchise Wars)

Newer players are trickier to read, they have no meta and their confusion doesn't really mean anything unless they slip.

 

[amazonevan19]

townreading punchy since I doubt he'd be this dumb as coached scum, not gonna lie

- - - Post Merge - - -

Punchy seems like a confused player, which isn't alignment indicative.

Remember Bianca in her first game? (she was scum in Franchise Wars)

Newer players are trickier to read, they have no meta and their confusion doesn't really mean anything unless they slip.

Yeah it could be a Bianca situation again, but for now I slight townread him

I love how Bianca is cited as an example of not trusting noobs pretty much every game now

 

[PunchyTheCat]

did you atleast skim through a few games to get an idea of how the games work, or was this a yolo situation

I've read through a few games.

 

[moonford]

Oh and the bizarre statements every now and then which trips everyone up.

 

[cornimer]

For now I'm townleaning Punchy as well, his post about him and Dedenne seems like something only new town would post

 

[PunchyTheCat]

Well thanks everyone for calling me a noob, I need more thought on my second scumread.

 

[moonford]

Well thanks everyone for calling me a noob, I need more thought on my second scumread.

There's no need to be offended by it, everyone was one at some point and you have done several things so far which indicate that you are slightly bewildered.

 

[amazonevan19]

Well thanks everyone for calling me a noob, I need more thought on my second scumread.

no offense but it's your first game so we're going to call you a noob accordingly.

also any reason why you're not outing your scumreads? you outted your town/blue read but not your scum...hmmmm

 

[cornimer]

Well thanks everyone for calling me a noob, I need more thought on my second scumread.

Yeah don't worry about it. Everyone called me a dumb noob in my first game. It's nothing personal, we're just trying to seperate purposeful scum acting from genuine inexperience.

 

[PunchyTheCat]

no offense but it's your first game so we're going to call you a noob accordingly.

also any reason why you're not outing your scumreads? you outted your town/blue read but not your scum...hmmmm

Well I think you're scum. And yes I am a noob, I wasn't being sarcastic.

 

[Byngo]

thoughts pretty much align with everyone’s regarding punchy. Hes being reckless, even for new scum. id expect much more reservedness

 

[moonford]

no offense but it's your first game so we're going to call you a noob accordingly.

also any reason why you're not outing your scumreads? you outted your town/blue read but not your scum...hmmmm

I was thinking the same, but I doubt he has any concrete reasoning because there is barely any posts that have been made which are really notable.

I'm interested to hear his reads nonetheless.

Does anyone have any other reads despite the town reads on Punchy?

 

[PunchyTheCat]

Did I not just submit my #1 scumread? Oh wait I did

- - - Post Merge - - -

That sounded rude, sorry Zendel