Pokémon Generation 5

chet_manley

Senior Member
Joined
Jun 8, 2018
Posts
635
Bells
155
Switch
2630-9248-4224
What's going on with Generation Five? I've never played Black or White (or Black2/White2) and I understand they are all entirely different games with different plots.

Are the games worth getting into? I have a complete living Pok?dex in generation 7 and I was kind of thinking about how I never really give any shine to the Gen.5 Pok?mon. I don't mind that they basically tried to recreate the gen.1 Pok?dex and have an entirely stand-alone game/region.

Just running down the 'dex, what are some of your favorite 'mons? What about least favorites?

Best:
Scolipede is a cool addition to the bug/poison family.
I actually kind of like Crustle.
The fossil Pok?mon are cool.
Deerling/Sawsbuck look cool.
Joltik/Galvantula look cool.
I feel like I should use Eelektross on a team sometime.
Mienfoo is interesting-looking.
Volcarona is one of my favorite Pok?mon and on my current team.

Worst:
The elemental monkeys are a mess
Musharna -- It's a fetus with an umbilical cord growing from its head
Sawk and Throh are just silly. I don't like Pok?mon that wear clothes.
Darmanitan is a clown.
Garbodor is lazy.
The Vanillite family aren't the best Pok?mon out there, but they are the worst.
Klink line is dumb.
The legendaries and mythicals are uninspired.
 
I honestly don’t know why no one has responded to this yet, but I will.

Generation five is worth getting into, imo. The story, the characters, the settings and locations and everything are all very, very good. As for some of my favorite mons from the generation,

Best:

Drilbur and Excadrill are pretty cool, and at one point I know Excadrill was in the Uber tier of Pokemon due to how OP it was.
The Deino/Zweilous/Hydreigon line is really great, and honestly my favorite from the generation.
The Litwick/Lampent/Chandelure line is also really awesome, and Chandelure is pretty good with a high special attack.
Cubchoo and Beartic is probably your best bet here if you want an ice type. Beartic is pretty strong and will do well against dragons.
The Tynamo/Eelektrik/Eelektross line is great and also has no weaknesses thanks to its ability, so if you want an electric type catching a Tynamo and raising it would be best.
Lastly, Zorua and Zoroark are probably one of the best dark types in awhile during this generation as the ability illusion really confuses others when battling them.

Worst:

I would agree the elemental monkeys are pretty lame and have problems.
The Pidove/Tranquill/Unfezant line isn’t that great and nowhere near as great as the Starly/Staravia/Staraptor line from generation four (especially because Staraptor can learn Close Combat).
Lillipup/Herdier/Stoutland line is okay, but not that great.
The Sewaddle/Swadloon/Leavanny line has terrible typing with bug and grass.
Basculin is boring af and fails as a water type.
Maractus is just forgettable to be honest.

That’s about as much as I have to say about generation five. If you haven’t already played it, you definitely should. I hope my lists and explanation about the region will help you decide which Pokemon you like and which Pokemon you’ll avoid a little bit. :)
 
Last edited:
People ALWAYS say generation 5 pokedex is unoriginal and a recreation of generation 1, but that may only be the case from a pokedex standpoint. Look closely, does Roggenrola's line REALLY look like Geodude's line? Does Timburr's line REALLY look like Machop's line? Does Tympole's line REALLY look like Poliwag's? Only pokemon that are too similar to me is Musharna and Drowzee. Munna is cute though so...

Anyways, I love generation 5 pok?mon. Possibly my favorite dex actually. I dunno why but they all really grew on me. I have favorites though:

Best
Zorua/Zoroark are my favorite pokemon. They look cool, are dark types, and their illusion ability is really great!
LITWICK! I loved it as soon as I saw it! Litwick and it's evolution line are awesome idc what people say!
Zekrom 2nd favorite legendary mascot behind Yveltal. It's just to damn cool plus Dragon/Electric type is pretty unique.
Sandile's evolution line is really cool to. Desert crocodiles! Also ground/dark is pretty cool.
Whimsicott is so adorable! Even if it's been a pain in the neck! XD
Vanillite and the other ice cream mons are adorable idc what they say fight me >:0
Genesect is my favorite mythical of gen 5. It just find it really badass. Looks like a killing machine literally/metaphorically.

Worst:

Both trios of the region are my least favorite legendary trios. Forces of nature look too similar... until they got their new forms which is kidna okay though Landorus-T is my most used mon in battles.
The legendary musketeer's don't interest me at all, except for their signature sword move that Aegislash ended up steeling lol
Kyurem looks ridiculous. It looks like a giant mutated chicken that just thawed out of the freezer. Kyurem-B looks kinda cool to me though
Ducklett! omfg that thing is annoying! Hard to believe it evolves into the beautiful Swanna
Klink's evolution line looks dumb as heck, I agree with that.
Trubbish and Garbodor are in fact ugly, but the ARE poison type SO. Though, I wish they never existed just so people can stop hating on gen 5 because "GeN 5 sUcKs BeCuAsE gArBoDoR" -.-
 
Last edited:
I've personally never played Gen 5 but I've heard a lot more good about it than bad. I would love to get my hands on a copy of White Version, I've been wanting to play it since it released when I was in 5th grade.

As for the pokedex, I'm not gonna lie, Gen 5 is probably the best set of Pokemon that GF has created. Sure, there are still a few that I absolutely hate like the Klinklang line, but there's a ton of pokes that I really love, like Scolipede, Serperior, Gigalith, and Zoroark. I do not at all have a problem with pokes like the Vanilluxe line and Garbodor, since their origins actually tie in well with the theme of the region. I also love all of the legendaries (except for the forces of nature, but even Tornadus Therian is awesome imo), especially the box legends.
 
Generation 5 are some of my favorite games in the series, and the only things that really keep them from being my absolute favorites are the quality of life changes the series made afterward that I very much appreciated, particularly the increased ease of breeding (especially IV breeding with Destiny Knot) in Generation 6 and how fast and easy it is to EV Train in both Generations 6 and 7.

I would definitely say they're worth getting into, though everyone's tastes vary so obviously no one is going to like everything and it might turn out it's not for you.


Best
Escavalier: I like the knight aesthetic in general, so I really like Escavalier and it's one of the standouts for me not only from Generation 5 but across all generations as one of my favorite Pok?mon. It's pretty great with an Assault Vest (though, that wasn't introduced until the next generation) too, provided you're accounting for its typing when in battle.

Serperior: One of my favorite starters in the series, especially since Grass is my favorite type. Unfortunately it didn't get the Contrary Hidden Ability until after this generation had passed, but it was my favorite one to use even despite that.

Cofagrigus: Unfortunate name aside, I really like Cofagrigus and its Mummy ability. The design is nice and the ability has some utility in certain situations.

Galvantula: I liked the introduction of a spideresque Pok?mon and the name and typing are pretty neat. Fast, frail, fun.

Eelektross: Great design, no weaknesses, what's not to love?

Beheeyem: I like the alien design for Elgyem and Beheeyem and the rewriting memories thing is pretty neat. They're really slow, but hey, that can work on a Trick Room team.

Garbodor: I was indifferent to it at first, but then I came across a shiny Trubbish and grew to appreciate it. Now I'm fond of it. Not the best Pok?mon competitively but I like it.

Swanna: It's a very plain swan, but I like birds in real life so that's fine by me. It was great in the rain with its perfect accuracy Hurricane and Hydration ability. Do keep in mind that Generation 5's weather could be permanent if you had something with Drizzle or Drought like Politoed or Ninetales respectively, so this was a great time for Swanna.

Sawsbuck: The seasonal appearance change mechanic is nice and, as I already mentioned I'm fond of Grass-types, I have a soft spot for it. I especially like the Autumn form.

Excadrill: Not much to say, just really like it. XRileyx touched on the fact that he was great in Generation 5 especially though, so yeah, worth using.

Archeops & Carracosta: Great fossil Pok?mon. Only unfortunate thing is that Archeops doesn't get a Hidden Ability to replace the unfortunate Defeatist.

Scolipede: It's a great design and fun to use.

Emolga: I'm not one for the Pika-clones, but of them I'd say Emolga is the best and most interesting that we've gotten.

Chandelure: I'm fond of Ghost-types and the design and typing drew me in as soon as I saw Litwick for the first time. Good special attacker.

Haxorus: The axe-inspired design is really nice and it's one of my favorite Dragon-types in general.

Cryogonal: It's just a big angry snowflake. Most people probably don't like that, but I've just had a fondness for it since I saw it. I like Winter and snow, so hey, works for me.

Hydreigon: It might not be gold, but I can't help but think of King Ghidorah when I look at it and that's a good thing. It was a monster in Generation 5 since Fairy hadn't yet been introduced, the naming scheme for its evolutionary line is fun, and it's one of the most memorable of the generation.

Volcarona: My only complaint is how long it takes to evolve. Great Pok?mon.

Kyurem: I like standard Kyurem's design since it's supposed to be the husk of what was once a great dragon before the other two split off from it. I wish we got its return to glory instead of getting Kyurem-W and Kyurem-B, both of which look pretty hideous.

Genesect: Best mythical of the generation, as Nox said. Great design and the Drives are a fun gimmick.

There are others I quite like as well, but this is long enough as is.




Worst
Meloetta: I really like Meloetta's design and concept, but they really flubbed the landing. Whereas other Pok?mon like Keldeo and the Weather trio can change their forms by using an item or other outside influence, Meloetta's form change is determined by the use of Relic Song changing her form in battle and it wears off after the battle is over. That really sucks for choosing a nature, making a moveset, etc. because one of those moves will always end up being Relic Song, a special move, if you want to use Pirouette Forme, a physical attacker.

Kyurem-White and Kyurem-Black: They're fine to use in battle I guess, but as I mentioned when previously talking about standard Kyurem in my favorites list, it's a shame that they didn't give us the original dragon. They're fine, if a bit busily designed and kind of ugly, but they feel like a missed opportunity for me.

Stunfisk: Just a pretty unfortunate design. I don't hate any Pok?mon, and it has its own aspects that make it sort of interesting from a design inspiration perspective, but...eh.

Conkeldurr: Like I said above, I don't hate any Pok?mon, but through no fault of its own Conkeldurr is just a better Machamp in all regards. Which is kind of a bother to me because I absolutely adore Machamp. So Conkeldurr steals its spotlight a bit.

Musharna: Forgettable, though at least it gave us the Dream World while that was still a thing. Additionally, Mew is the superior fetus Pok?mon.
 
I went through b2 somewhat recently to get stuff for living dex, and as I mentioned elsewhere, the game is basically pure visual porn for anyone that enjoys sprite-based graphics
 
I went through b2 somewhat recently to get stuff for living dex, and as I mentioned elsewhere, the game is basically pure visual porn for anyone that enjoys sprite-based graphics
um...what?? XD
 
Back
Top