Help me decide!

[majnin]

The town name idea thread wasn't being too helpful as I get caught up in other names and get distracted. I need a straight answer, what town name idea do you prefer?

Olivine or Pine Bay

Olivine: The Pokemon town where the gym leader's name is Jasmine (my name) so it's pretty cool. I've named a lot of towns this. It's safe.

Pine Bay: I think it would be so cool to have a two word name, and it suits the town really well.

 

[Superpenguin]

Pine Bay, but it's your town, I mean what does it matter what anyone else thinks?

 

[eyeplaybass]

I like Pine Bay. But ultimately, you should do what makes your heart tingle with joy!

 

[Mairmalade]

May I ask what your plans are to make you think Pine Bay would suit your town perfectly? Or do you just think that in general? If that's the case I think the answer should be obvious.

Pine Bay.

 

[charmed girl]

I agree Pine Bay sounds the best.

 

[MadisonCrossing]

I would do Pine Bay, but it's up to you. If you want us to decide, though, it looks like Pine Bay is the one chosen!

 

[Grandpierre]

Pine Bay is pretty great!

 

[ben_nyc]

*insert troublemaker*

Select...


OLIVINE

 

[eyeplaybass]

*insert troublemaker*

Select...


OLIVINE

*GASP*

My human instict to go with the status quo is filled with rage!

 

[Hunch]

Ahah, I named my town Pine Bay, too. I think it's swell.

What makes it odd is that I too was contemplating using a Pokemon town name, though my final choices were Pine Bay and New Bark..

 

[eyeplaybass]

Ahah, I named my town Pine Bay, too. I think it's swell.

What makes it odd is that I too was contemplating using a Pokemon town name, though my final choices were Pine Bay and New Bark..

Strange... it seems that you two may be connected. Perhaps one of you is an interdimensional traveller?

 

[GhulehGirl]

Hmm, both nice names but Pine Bay sticks out. I can just see a rl town being called that

 

[majnin]

Thank you all so much for your help, it seems Pine Bay is a winner. Thank you! If anyone else needs any help on a decision, feel free to use this thread.

 

[Attribule]

Could have went with Olivine, especially since you're right near the ocean and you eventually unlock a lighthouse for your town. It's perfect.

 

[eresin]

Another vote for Pine Bay

 

[Kiwi]

Olivine, definitely! (In my opinion...)
As someone already said: town is near the ocean, there's a lighthouse pwp ...aaand your name fits!

 

[kimmy27]

Olivine, just because I like the Pokemon backstory....I'm a sucker for Pokemon

EDIT: oh, you already chose one.

 

[majnin]

Yeah, to be honest, my heart lies in Olivine.

I restarted my WW and was ready to name it Pine Bay but something... something was stopping me. It was the weirdest thing. As cool as it sounds, I just couldn't do it. Why? Because I didn't come up with it myself.

I was also considering Wishvale. But I didn't come up with that either. Olivine was from my own train of thought and it fits so perfectly it just has to be my town.

 

[Aurora]

I've seen quite a few towns on AC called Pine Bay. It's not very original, but it works for a good average sounding town.

 

[Pelon1071]

Pine Bay sounds really cool.