Help me pick a cranky villager!!

[marinara-cabelas]

Hello!!

I’m currently in the process of trying to get either puddles or bob off my island- first question is, which one should i get rid of?

Next question is, I’m torn between Bruce, Fang, and Wolfgang for my island. I need a cranky villager (I had Cyd and while most ppl like him I really didn’t like him). tell me your experiences with any of them and which one was your favorite!!

 

[Croconaw]

Out of those three, I’d go with Wolfgang. My personal favorites are Chief and Butch, though.

 

[Sheydra]

I love fang my hubby has Bruce and not really impressed with him.

 

[-Mars-]

Hm, I had Wolfgang before, I thought he was okay, out of those three I would pick Fang(just that's my opinion, pick whoever you like the most and don't worry about what others think!) my favorite cranky is Wart Jr.

 

[moon_child]

I’ve had Chief the entire time in New Leaf and I love him but his house in NH turned me off (we couldn’t change houses that time yet) so I went with Fang and I fell in love with him. In my new island though, I got Frett as a random move in and I’m actually having a lot of fun having him around I think I’m keeping him for a while.

 

[Rosch]

Cranky wolves are amazing and cool villagers. You can never go wrong with any of them. Although I personally prefer grandpa Dobie.

Both Fang and Wolfgang have education hobbies, so they are practically the same. It all boils down to their design and your preference. I've always confused Fang as a female wolf back then. He even has an effeminate house, both interior and exterior. Meanwhile, Wolfgang has a cooler vibe going on. Just pick which wolf you think clicks with you more.

 

[Tindre]

Fang is adorable, also Tom is super cute with his :3 face and glasses

 

[miyac]

My favorites are Fang and Kabuki, so out of those 3 I'll choose Fang. I have him in my island and I love him!

 

[nightglow]

From the list, I like Fang the most. I had Wolfgang before as a random move in. He was ok.

 

[S.J.]

I think you should go for whichever you prefer, and if you can't decide, you could just let go of whoever asks to leave first and invite whoever you find first!

I prefer Wolfgang of those three villagers, though I'm sure they're all great! As someone else mentioned, Fang and Wolfgang have the same hobby, but I prefer the design of Wolfgang more and his preferred colours in NH are black and green, which I like.

As for who to let leave, I'm partial to a peppy villager, so I'd keep Puddles, but I think Bob is really cute too! All in all, I'm no help!

 

[. Rarity .]

I love Bruce, hes such a cool deer. His design gives off a moody character, like a rebellious bad boy, who hangs on the streets

But he's got style too, with his jacket, and look. His house isn't super special, but its got inner character.

Bruce has always been on my island, hes there to stay.

I do agree with wolves being great crankies, I got Chief and then I also have Static. But I vote Bruce, just because he's awesome.
--

 

[ZeldaCrossing64]

My favorite is Apollo, but out of those three I'd pick Fang. ^^

 

[Flicky]

To the first question, I'd say Puddles. Although I'm not very big on Bob, either.

I've had all three of those in the past, but I'd go with Wolfgang. I'll admit, it's a bit of nostalgia for me - he's been in two previous games of mine, so I have a lot of memories surrounding him.

 

[maria110]

I loved all three of those crankies. Wolfgang has an elegant house exterior and I like his design a lot. Fang has a white house which looks nice with a lot of themes. Bruce's exterior is dark and looks nice with a more gothic theme and his interior is an urban street look. You can't go wrong with any of them.

 

[DarkSlayer1331]

Oh my gosh! I actually love Puddles! She's so cute! Don't get rid of her. And Fang is actually my all time favorite villager ever! He was one of my starter villagers in City Folk and New Leaf, and he's never allowed to leave my island.

 

[Xara]

it’s of course entirely your decision, but i definitely recommend bruce! i’m biased since deers are my favourite animal and bruce is one of my favourite crankies lol, but he’s lovely to have around! i’ve had him in both new leaf and new horizons, and he was awesome both times.

fang would be my second choice, though! he’s a total sweetheart, and i honestly think that he’s the prettiest male wolf lol.

 

[Akeath]

I've only had Fang and Wolfgang, myself. Personally I preferred Wolfgang because his fur is silver, which goes with a Cranky old man.
Wolfgang had more of a cool vibe rather than an old person feel. He was also nice to have, though.

 

[Autumn247]

I had Wolfgang in New Leaf, he was cool as far as I can remember. But now I have Fang and I like him a lot too. I think they're both great cranky wolves. I haven't had Bruce though. Now you've got me curious as to whether I like Wolfgang or Fang better, it's been so long since I had Wolfgang that I mostly forgot what he's like.

 

[Bilaz]

I think Fang is really cute, he has very sweet vibes. And with his islandy house, yet ‘Siberia’ Japanese name + his feature on the cover of K.K. Steppe he tells the story of an old Russian wolf who longs for the sun

 

[Bizhiins]

I had Fang on my island and enjoyed him as a villager. I mostly just like his looks, but I like his house theme too.