Oh my gosh, I can't believe you had Agnes too! Those are some great villagers!
Louie was my other starter, and I didn't think I'd like jock villagers, but really he's fine. He's very sweet, and I don't know if different jocks have different dialogues, but Louie is actually lovely. The villagers I'm most attached to are Agnes, Louie and Patty (who I've loved since Pocket Camp), but I'm also pretty attached to Megan, Savannah and Rhonda too. I have a lot of normal and peppy villagers on my island, so I've been thinking of finding a cranky!
Do you have favourite personality types, or do you try to keep it even on your island (like one each or something)?
Oh you have a lot of villagers I haven't seen! Savannah looks really cool! My cranky villager is Octavian, and he's been really lovely despite what his scowl might make you think. I hope you find a cranky villager you like. Dobie is a really cute one!
I don't really have a favorite personality type, but I really think it's interesting to see how all the personalities interact with each other. So I've really been trying to keep it even, although it's hard with how unbalanced the personality types feel! I'm with you in that I'd instinctually go with mostly normal and peppy villagers.
Do you have a theme/aesthetic for your island or a goal for it?