I need opinions on this sig I made?

[Jikyul]

So, i kind of want to open a sig shop..
But I only made one sig so far, I'm still experimenting ;;
I was wondering how you would rate this
;; Im using Paint Shop Pro x7 and Paint.Net

Constructive Criticism please ^^

UPDATE;
Here's another one I tried;

 

[DarkDesertFox]

Not sure if that is a Free! anime reference at the top left, but overall I think it's kickass. Maybe it could use a darker border, but that's just my preference.

Edit: It says Iwatobi. Of course it's a Free! reference. Shame on me.

 

[Jikyul]

Not sure if that is a Free! anime reference at the top left, but overall I think it's kickass. Maybe it could use a darker border, but that's just my preference.

It is , Im glad someone got it x'D
Thank you! I'll totally keep that in mind, I want to figure out how to add borders in the future !

 

[ATotsSpot]

I love their reflections in the water. Nice.

 

[tae]

i agree on the darker boarder i dea from fox, and if your town is named after Free! then A+ for you omg.

keep making more and playing around with styles!
this one is very clean and crisp and the mirror idea was brilliant~

 

[oswaldies]

It looks amazing. ♥
It just needs more pink...

 

[Jikyul]

I love their reflections in the water. Nice.

Thank you :')
I was actually hesitant about adding the reflections.

i agree on the darker boarder i dea from fox, and if your town is named after Free! then A+ for you omg.

keep making more and playing around with styles!
this one is very clean and crisp and the mirror idea was brilliant~

Yeah, I think i'll add a border depending on which background I use.
It is, as well as the theme song is my town tune.

Thank you so much ^^
and if you're into kpop, we should be friends~

It looks amazing. ♥
It just needs more pink...

I plan on making another sig with a pink concept c:
Thank you!

 

[cheezyfries]

i really like it! i think that i would make the town font bigger so that it's more noticeable, and maybe make the FC text bold? idk, in my opinion with graphic design you have to try everything to make sure it looks good haha, but i think that it looks great for a first signature!

 

[deerui]

this amazing!
free! reference yey

I for real thnk this is so awesome, though, you could add a dark grey/black outline around the "iwatobi, make us free" to make it more noticeable c: and i dont agree on the darker borders, i like it this way, I LOVE THE villagers reflection omg


also add shapes, such as you could make it a cloud, ounded corners, etc.

- - - Post Merge - - -

you could also make the background animated by looking up "pixel scenery gif" or something

 

[Allycat]

looks great!
if you are going to use a grey border, I recommend doing 2 px wide of white border and 1 px wide of grey.
Personally, I think it looks nicer, but it's totally up to you

Other than that it looks totally great!

I used to run a tutorial/resource based paint shop pro website, so if you ever need advice, just let me know!
Though, I don't think you need it. [:​

 

[Jikyul]

i really like it! i think that i would make the town font bigger so that it's more noticeable, and maybe make the FC text bold? idk, in my opinion with graphic design you have to try everything to make sure it looks good haha, but i think that it looks great for a first signature!

Yeah, The more I look, the more it could be bold ,and more visible! I will totally keep that in mind, Thank you so much !!

this amazing!
free! reference yey

I for real thnk this is so awesome, though, you could add a dark grey/black outline around the "iwatobi, make us free" to make it more noticeable c: and i dont agree on the darker borders, i like it this way, I LOVE THE villagers reflection omg


also add shapes, such as you could make it a cloud, rounded corners, etc.

- - - Post Merge - - -

you could also make the background animated by looking up "pixel scenery gif" or something

Yeah I wanted to make a town name that I would enjoy.
Sure! I will totally do that!
Thank you, I thought without the reflection, it would look kind of Odd.
I would love to be able to do animations, but I need to learn xD
Thank you!!

looks great!
if you are going to use a grey border, I recommend doing 2 px wide of white border and 1 px wide of grey.
Personally, I think it looks nicer, but it's totally up to you

Other than that it looks totally great!

I used to run a tutorial/resource based paint shop pro website, so if you ever need advice, just let me know!
Though, I don't think you need it. [:​

Ohh okay, I see what you mean. I agree.
Thank you so much! Of course, there are some things i'm still unsure of. c:

 

[sailorerika]

I really really like the water reflections idea, I don't think I've ever seen anyone do that. I typically don't like this style of signature, but I really like how well done this one is! And I like the border the way it is now and would love to see a pink concept one.

Also side note* I have Butch in boxes if you want to adopt him. I was going to void him tonight because I've had 3 people flake on me when coming to get him over like 5 days and I was tired of holding him. He's original and all that.