Mafia Island Madness - Town Wins

[epona]

let's say it was a slip by ace
if there is a town cop role, mafia!ace out with role cop by investigating someone, but would you investigate anyone but daniel? so this means: 1) ace and dan are mafia together 2) dan is actually cop 3) ace is cop 4) mafia is dumb
anyway i dont know if it's a good chop

??
If there’s a mafia role-cop and Daniel is town why would maf waste an investigate on him. Like surely they could just assume the claim is true if they know he’s town

 

[voltairenism]

yes, so shawo would know if there is or isnt a mafia cop. if there is a mafia cop there isnt anyway besides dan being mafia that they didnt investigate daniel

this was badly worded. if there is a mafia cop, and daniel is town, mafia MUST have investigate daniel

 

[Geoni]

Dan has already stated that he doesn't want to treat guava's part in it as being beyond self-pres and I wanna know more people's thoughts on that.

 

[Damniel]

As it stands I currently think guava is wolfy for her EoD and haven't had enough to change my mind so like, there's that opportunism/desperation to debate already. Dedenne too.

can we work on possibly resolving shawo and me

after seeing shawo's reaction, i dont think he wants to resolve me and will leave this CC hang

 

[epona]

this was badly worded. if there is a mafia cop, and daniel is town, mafia MUST have investigate daniel

i strongly disagree with this
Why would they care if he’s really doctor or not

 

[voltairenism]

??
If there’s a mafia role-cop and Daniel is town why would maf waste an investigate on him. Like surely they could just assume the claim is true if they know he’s town

because it would return if he is doctor or not?

 

[Geoni]

And I stg if people say I'm defaulting to LHF I'm going to die inside.

 

[voltairenism]

i strongly disagree with this
Why would they care if he’s really doctor or not

eh shawo cc'd today not yesterday right, nevermind

 

[Dinosaurz]

Yeah if Mafia know daniel is town they have no reason to refute his claim

 

[Geoni]

can we work on possibly resolving shawo and me

after seeing shawo's reaction, i dont think he wants to resolve me and will leave this CC hang

Most people don't want to do it.

 

[Damniel]

i strongly disagree with this
Why would they care if he’s really doctor or not

i think there's a misunderstanding here

shawo says its possible both of us are town, but wolves dont know which is doc. but volt says even if both are town the role cop can find that out on their own, but shawo didn't mention this

 

[voltairenism]

basically mafia can check if daniel or shawo are doctors. thats my point
shawo plan's was to confuse mafia so they didnt know who to shoot, or if it they should shoot, since they both can be doctors. but mafia can check it if they have role cops

 

[Dinosaurz]

Nobody wants to day kill a blue role

 

[Damniel]

though if shawo is town, wolves wouldn't have investigated me D1 since i had no CC. but if shawo is town they technically have a reason to

 

[Geoni]

@voltairenism you're basically saying Shawo wouldn't confidently claim-bait as town here knowing a role-cop could exist if I'm understanding you correctly?

 

[voltairenism]

i think there's a misunderstanding here

shawo says its possible both of us are town, but wolves dont know which is doc. but volt says even if both are town the role cop can find that out on their own, but shawo didn't mention this

exactly. so it's a fault on his plan to protect the real doctor

 

[Dinosaurz]

no more people trying to kill themselves please don’t vote yourself

 

[Damniel]

exactly. so it's a fault on his plan to protect the real doctor

yea i think its pretty clear he doesnt believe he's doctor

 

[voltairenism]

@voltairenism you're basically saying Shawo wouldn't confidently claim-bait as town here knowing a role-cop could exist if I'm understanding you correctly?

yes

though if shawo is town, wolves wouldn't have investigated me D1 since i had no CC. but if shawo is town they technically have a reason to

yeah i misremembered i thought shawo claimed d1

 

[epona]

yeah but shawo didn't claim til d2 so it's irrelevant