Mafia Island Madness - Town Wins

[shawo]

U know what doesn’t give us a bias

if we kill docs

Look bro. What's your gameplan after you kill me.

 

[epona]

 

[voltairenism]

Explained in the post above. It wasn't in the role explanation thread so I didn't think it existed. They have regular cop so it didn't make sense to me that there would be a missing pr role in it.

yeah I was ninja'd
iirc the first post didn't have roles in it, only sign ups. it was changed because you mentioned having two of the same roles and dan complained to dinotown that she needs to put this specifics in the op. i may be wrong though

 

[Dinosaurz]

Look bro. What's your gameplan after you kill me.

 

[epona]

yeah I was ninja'd
iirc the first post didn't have roles in it, only sign ups. it was changed because you mentioned having two of the same roles and dan complained to dinotown that she needs to put this specifics in the op. i may be wrong though

omg this is so true wtf

dino only put the roles in the OP of this thread today

 

[Geoni]

I'm ngl, it doesn't say rolecop in the first page of the thread. I was using that as reference for everything. I don't think this one's on me, it was only mentionoed by volt when I remembered it was in signups.

if you look at my earlier posts you'll notice I didn't mention rolecop at all.

Not to mention, this setup's ALREADY imbalanced because there are clues given constantly, rather than giving the reasons why doc can't be a thing, what if mafia has multiple blackmailers, and having multiple docs is a weird form of recompense given to town for the fact that this setup has a mafia-bias due to the fact that it's expiremental?

Doesn't matter if you did or didn't. Multiple blackmailers doesn't counteract the fact that if wolves get down to one player left it's impossible for them to win if both docs are alive, which is why it's widespread accepted to not put two in a game as the link Alek posted stated. Even for experimental.

 

[shawo]

The problem I have isn't that you guys want to kill me even. It's that it's both suboptimal and (imo) clearly mafia lead.

Obviously mafia has an incentive to force a lynch between two people they believe is town. Because at the very least it sorts in docs.

Not to mention, as EVERYONE has pointed out.

TWO DOCS IS BAD FOR MAFIA.

SO IF MAFIA KNOWS THERE'S TWO DOCS. THEIR WINCONDITION IS LYNCHING ONE.

 

[voltairenism]

yeah I was ninja'd
iirc the first post didn't have roles in it, only sign ups. it was changed because you mentioned having two of the same roles and dan complained to dinotown that she needs to put this specifics in the op. i may be wrong though

@Damniel can you confirm this or am i wrong? not sure if it really matters though

 

[epona]

Check the OP, I added role details as requested

 

[voltairenism]

omg this is so true wtf

dino only put the roles in the OP of this thread today

oh there it is

 

[shawo]

I'm gonna get some quotes from myself. Because I genuinely do not think the role thing was added today. I've looked at it like, 4 times.

 

[epona]

@shawo let's say we don't chop you today. how do you feel about chopping ace

 

[Geoni]

The problem I have isn't that you guys want to kill me even. It's that it's both suboptimal and (imo) clearly mafia lead.

Obviously mafia has an incentive to force a lynch between two people they believe is town. Because at the very least it sorts in docs.

Not to mention, as EVERYONE has pointed out.

TWO DOCS IS BAD FOR MAFIA.

SO IF MAFIA KNOWS THERE'S TWO DOCS. THEIR WINCONDITION IS LYNCHING ONE.

Dude all you can really say at this point to get me lynched is this. It's one big 'NO U'

Post automatically merged: Sep 24, 2020

@guav@ why are you voting Ace?

 

[shawo]

I'm fairly certain I checked the potential mafia roles before I asked if there could be more than 1. Given the fact that when I made that post, I specifically mentioned the potential for multiple blackmailers specifically.

Post automatically merged: Sep 24, 2020

Dude all you can really say at this point to get me lynched is this. It's one big 'NO U'

Post automatically merged: Sep 24, 2020

@guav@ why are you voting Ace?

This and that are two different things. Don't convolute them.

I think you're leading a lynch in docs because you're mafia. I think everyone else is lynching in docs because they're bad.

 

[Ace Marvel]

Me on Geoni

 

[epona]

I'm fairly certain I checked the potential mafia roles before I asked if there could be more than 1. Given the fact that when I made that post, I specifically mentioned the potential for multiple blackmailers specifically.

the only way you could have done that is by checking the signups thread, which has role cop listed lol

 

[Ace Marvel]

What I'm hoping happens

 

[shawo]

Btw: given the case where Dan is really doc I think the most likely scenario is that we have no cop.

In that case it doesn't make sense for mafia to have multiple blackmailers (cuz that'd be broken.) And it doesn't really make sense for mafia to have (more than) 1 GF (just to throw mafia off the fact that there's no cop.) Meaning that mafia most likely has VM and not just a bunch of prs.

Of course the more likely situation is that there's only one doc.

Here's the post I was thinking about. I dunno when dino made that specific post.

 

[Damniel]

@Damniel can you confirm this or am i wrong? not sure if it really matters though

that is correct the roles weren't there before

 

[shawo]

So either you believe I went super deep on trying to convince everyone there was no rolecop. Or!!! I didn't know!!!