• Guest, you're invited to help build our new TBT time capsule! It contains three parts, with some of its elements planned to open in 2029 and others not until the distant future of 2034. Get started in 2024 Community Time Capsule: Blueprints.

Mafia Island Madness - Town Wins

voltairenism said:
yeah this wifom and ate are very characteristic. but to quote "The Question" from earlier, this could be replicated by ace mafia imo
Click to expand...

I mean yeah but they're folding under literally 0 pressure.

Ace isn't wifoming when like, 4 people are going on him. He literally just folded under the push of two people.

Also you would have to assume that both Geoni and Epona are town in the case where Ace is mafia. Which doesn't even seem realistic. (Mafia wouldn't fold under a mafia bus.)
 
as a doctor, i couldve only seen the one possibility for shawo to be town here fake claiming. if this play is centered around protecting me im willing to wifom with my protect. very clearly either of us will be targeted at this point. even if town, this CC will take up the whole game as long as it exists and just distract. i also wanted to wait for D3 but this won't be let go
 
voltairenism said:
shawo whos mafia with epona and geoni
Click to expand...

I thought Alek was mafia but they're going to get modkilled. I townread hikari for one post on d1 and they're gone. Guava, dedenne, and dino are impossible to sort, but if you made me put money on it, I'd say it's probably 2 in dedenne, guava, and dino. Making it a 4p mafia team.

I'd say there's a good chance it's dino (who did just jump on the doc kill.) and ... dedenne? or guava? neither of them seem willing to push in docs, I think it's possible that guava is mafia aligned because they're willing to jump ace, making.... dedenne town?
 
noah fence but geoni and i have been mafia together before and it went a lot smoother than this
 
Damniel said:
ideally the D1 wagon just wasn't formed on me and i didn't need to claim, but now we have this
Click to expand...

THIS shouldn't even be happening. The logical justification for the doc kill has ONLY been explained by volt, but it's been pushed by at least 3 different people without as much of a justificatioon for the point.

Everyone keeps saying "two docs can't be a thing because it's bad for mafia." but that's also the PERFECT reason why mafia would do everything they can to force a kill into the docs.
Post automatically merged:

Geoni was afk for a solid day on d1, and you only started trying today.

If you're saying you're not mafia because mafia would be doing better idk what that even means.
 
shawo said:
I mean yeah but they're folding under literally 0 pressure.

Ace isn't wifoming when like, 4 people are going on him. He literally just folded under the push of two people.

Also you would have to assume that both Geoni and Epona are town in the case where Ace is mafia. Which doesn't even seem realistic. (Mafia wouldn't fold under a mafia bus.)
Click to expand...

This not AtE, I legit just want to die, but I won't be on the replacement waiting list. My slot dies with me.
Half of the players are MIA most of the day, which is totally understandable, too are waiting to be replaced.. The only town I trust is me so if it's not Geoni is me.
 
shawo said:
THIS shouldn't even be happening. The logical justification for the doc kill has ONLY been explained by volt, but it's been pushed by at least 3 different people without as much of a justificatioon for the point.

Everyone keeps saying "two docs can't be a thing because it's bad for mafia." but that's also the PERFECT reason why mafia would do everything they can to force a kill into the docs.
Click to expand...

why are you wilfully ignoring the fact that i've said ALL DAY that i don't want to vote between you or daniel today
 
Actually when I think about it more. I'm pretty sure guava is mafia. They're not even trying to sort in me and Damniel even though guava is usually pretty quick to at least try and get a read on me.

I keep thinking "they're gonna try harder later" but it's already ... day 2 of day 2. It's too late.
 
epona said:
why are you wilfully ignoring the fact that i've said ALL DAY that i don't want to vote between you or daniel today
Click to expand...

I saw you say that, and I respected that. And then you changed your mind? I mean mafia is a game about thought flow. If you're telling me that you NOW don't want to still, then I'll take that into consideration. But after I've made that claim, a solid, 5 times, this is the first time you've responded to it.

Non-response was the same thing as agreeing that it was true.

Do you still not want to go in docs?
 
shawo said:
I saw you say that, and I respected that. And then you changed your mind? I mean mafia is a game about thought flow. If you're telling me that you NOW don't want to still, then I'll take that into consideration. But after I've made that claim, a solid, 5 times, this is the first time you've responded to it.

Non-response was the same thing as agreeing that it was true.

Do you still not want to go in docs?
Click to expand...
i tried to see if shed chop you today and she said no
 
epona said:
this is really annoying : )
Click to expand...

You're actually the person I'm least confident is mafia. Given the assumption that you're mafia. I think it's safe to say that your higher post quality and more set gameplan is "trying" vs yesterday. If you're not mafia than obviously that sentiment isn't true.
Post automatically merged:

Damniel said:
i tried to see if shed chop you today and she said no
Click to expand...
Then I messed up. I'm sorry that I had the wrong impression, given the fact that I assumed you were pushing me to get me killed.
 
shawo said:
I saw you say that, and I respected that. And then you changed your mind? I mean mafia is a game about thought flow. If you're telling me that you NOW don't want to still, then I'll take that into consideration. But after I've made that claim, a solid, 5 times, this is the first time you've responded to it.

Non-response was the same thing as agreeing that it was true.

Do you still not want to go in docs?
Click to expand...

i think you're mafia but i have not made any move toward voting within you or daniel today and have been pretty firm that i do not want to do that. i've said this multiple times apart from once where i said i could maybe be swayed to chopping you today
my vote is on ace. i asked how you feel about voting ace and you ignored me outright
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

EvilTheCat6600
Goodbye And Good Riddance To My Second Island
Replies
0
Views
220
EvilTheCat6600
EvilTheCat6600
Alolan_Apples
Island Improvements Questionnaire:
Replies
9
Views
307
Asarena
Asarena
Plum Pudding
Question regarding Harvey's Island
Replies
5
Views
158
J087
J087
mayor.lauren
Buying Cataloguing?
Replies
0
Views
86
mayor.lauren
mayor.lauren
Jeremy
  • Locked
  • Poll
Besting Blunders - Community Voting
Replies
4
Views
884
ShawnFuzz
ShawnFuzz
Back
Top