Mafia Island Madness - Town Wins

[Antonio]

I would like an answer to my question btw.

 

[epona]

Something recently did come to mind but I don't know if it's worth anything, either due to me doubting myself or that's it's not actually worth anything.

Before I go into it, I have a question if anyone wishes to answer. Aren't mafia usually like super aware of their town meta or have a town meta in mind that they follow to be perceived as town?

i think that depends on the player
i know myself that i play similarly as wolf and as town and it's a trap people fall into when they're reading me bc they think i'm analytical so it's a 'towntell' if i'm inconsistent indecisive when that's genuinely just me lol

i'm also pretty sure glow has said that she makes a point of playing differently each game

 

[voltairenism]

I would like an answer to my question btw.

idk i was rand mafia twice, once in a joke game and the other i was outed by a cop a couple hours in

 

[Damniel]

i literally just have nothing to say

do you think there’s anything AI about volt bringing up a discusion you perceive as unproductive?

overall very passive tone from epona here but that’s not AI yet

 

[Antonio]

i think that depends on the player
i know myself that i play similarly as wolf and as town and it's a trap people fall into when they're reading me bc they think i'm analytical so it's a 'towntell' if i'm inconsistent indecisive when that's genuinely just me lol

i'm also pretty sure glow has said that she makes a point of playing differently each game

Who do you think out of everyone here would fall into that category then?

 

[Dinosaurz]

i think I was godfather once and got lynched day 1 or something lmao

 

[epona]

do you think there’s anything AI about volt bringing up a discusion you perceive as unproductive?

overall very passive tone from epona here but that’s not AI yet

what point of volt's are you referring to

 

[Damniel]

i play as the gods command me to

Post automatically merged: Sep 21, 2020

what point of volt's are you referring to

they brought up the discussion of mechanics that led to 2 pages you expressed you didn’t like

 

[epona]

Who do you think out of everyone here would fall into that category then?

i don't really have an answer to this bc i don't have experience of everyone as both alignments
i don't really see where this q is going

 

[Antonio]

Something recently did come to mind but I don't know if it's worth anything, either due to me doubting myself or that's it's not actually worth anything.

Before I go into it, I have a question if anyone wishes to answer. Aren't mafia usually like super aware of their town meta or have a town meta in mind that they follow to be perceived as town?

Post automatically merged: Sep 21, 2020

i don't really have an answer to this bc i don't have experience of everyone as both alignments
i don't really see where this q is going

you'll see

Post automatically merged: Sep 21, 2020

Can everyone else answer the question.

 

[Dinosaurz]

Post automatically merged: Sep 21, 2020

you'll see

Who are you asking to answer?

 

[Hikari]

wew that was alot to read up on lol

I found hikari’s reactions a little bit odd! they didnt seem to be questioning ace at all, which is interesting to vote for later!

Post automatically merged: Sep 21, 2020

note* not vote. but i did indeed just vote hikari!

i mean i did agree with you that we shouldn't dismiss the chance of being mafia due to previous trends, which i would define as "questioning" ace's logic. but as I said before, I don't think ace said this as a means to protect geoni, as it felt more like he was trying to think of things from a statistical standpoint. its defiantly something to keep in mind if either geoni or ace end up being mafia.

 

[Antonio]

Who are you asking to answer?

everyone

 

[Ace Marvel]

Post automatically merged: Sep 21, 2020

you'll see

Post automatically merged: Sep 21, 2020

Can everyone else answer the question.

I guess, but I'm no expert since I have been mafia only once, but yeah the idea was to play your normal self.

 

[Dinosaurz]

everyone

I can’t remember honestly

 

[Antonio]

I can’t remember honestly

the question or?

 

[Dinosaurz]

the question or?

When I was last mafia lmao

 

[FinalArcadia]

Just popping in real quick to say I'm slowly reading the thread since I've only just logged in, seen my role PM, and saw D1 has started lol

Will hopefully be back with some kind of thoughts in a bit, but yes I'm not MIA

 

[epona]

i play as the gods command me to

Post automatically merged: Sep 21, 2020

they brought up the discussion of mechanics that led to 2 pages you expressed you didn’t like

volt asked the host a question about the game mechanics, that's not the same thing as using mechanics as a drawn out discussion point when it's not relevant which is what i take issue with

i just think pages of discussion about mechanics and flavour are pure filler, i've always held that view and i was stoked that we were choosing our own flavour names bc it meant we could avoid role-flavour discussion yet somehow we still got into it with the whole dobie thing in the first few pages lol

 

[dedenne]

Post automatically merged: Sep 21, 2020

you'll see

Post automatically merged: Sep 21, 2020

Can everyone else answer the question.

but didnt you say if anyone wishes to answer? what if some people dont wish to answer?